5 ms·
Project Cybersyn (1971)
- sjclemmy 13y agoI love this kind of modernist, socialist utopian ideal. It's gratifying to think that whilst the idealogical battles of the 20th century were still playing out, the idea of marshalling effort and resources toward the common good without capitalism was viewed positively. And the chairs, I love the chairs. It reminds me very much of the Dharma Initiative from the TV series Lost.
- sonnyz 13y agoOh yeah, I can picture the scientist guy walking out to talk about the rules of some experiment.
- dabrowski 13y agoAnd now think that quite the opposite idea, the post Pinochet free market economy, was what made Chile the richest country in South America. As a rule of thumb, good intentions bring very bad results if you need government violence to implement them.
- hdevalence 13y agoWhereas Pinochet implemented his "good intentions" without violence? Reality check, please.
- dabrowski 13y agoHe obviously did use violence. However, are you suggesting that you need government violence to minimize goverment's involvement in economy?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 13y agoYou must be aware your second paragraph negates the first. Pinochet's "good intentions" (which is subject to debate) were implemented through the very liberal use of violence. They should have, therefore, yielded very bad results (which they did, in the short term). One is left to conclude Allende's reforms could have yielded equally good long term results without the illegal resort to violence.
- dnautics 13y agoHuh? Allende was no saint either, he certainly used violence directly. One of the biggest complaints about Pinochet was that he did everything that Allende was accused of (including torture) but worse, of course Pinochet was in power for a longer period of time.
- rbanffy 13y agoWhat accusations are you talking about? Allende did a lot of things some may consider questionable (land redistribution, statization) but torture is usually not among them. There was some preparation for guerilla operations, from both sides, in case a coup happened (as it did) and some armed resistance to the expropriations (which were legal according to the then valid laws).
- dnautics 13y agoyou're right, torture is usually not among them these days, but it's in the historical record, and chilenos of the time were aware it was going on. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Agreement_of_the_Chamber_of_Deputies_of_Chile https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Agreement_of_the_Chamber_of_D... "g) It has made frequent politically motivated and illegal arrests, in addition to those already mentioned of journalists, and it has tolerated the whipping and torture of the victims;"
- rbanffy 13y agoSo, you are bringing up a document used to justify the coup as a credible source of accusations that were never proven in the years following its original publication, despite the interest of a government that used violence routinely to prove them and justify its own brutality as a lesser of two evils. Excuse me if I find it difficult to believe in it. I don't think you should take it as a representation of the truth either.
- thanatropism 13y agoThis keeps coming up. I read pretty much everything Stafford Beer put up about the functioning of the system, but we never really saw a specification of the system dynamics-based model of the chilean economy it was supposed to be based on. Now, if you've ever played with how a sys-dyn model is built... timing your delays is crucial. "Real-time control" is a super cool idea, but there are stochastic deferrals between actions by policy-makers or decentralized agents and their systemic consequences. Mis-time these and you'll just be inducing cycles. That's a reason why modern economic planning is all based on watching response signals. We watch inflation and unemployment not because the relatively low thresholds that trigger action are catastrophic, but because inflation is a symptom of an overheated economy. We can't track demand and supply at the level of every commodity, and if we did, we wouldn't know how capacity expansion relates to effective availability to the consumer (this is a mistake countries that try to deal with hyperinflation with heavy intervention keep making, with the inevitable shortages in supply). TL;DR: Zomg tech
- shubb 13y agoThis is cool but... given the moden economy is built on automated statistical models, couldn't we look at advanced capitalism as a sort of highly supervised, decentralized version of this? The problem for me with the way we do things currently, is that the criteria the model is optimising (arguably economic growth) for don't seem to completely describe what most people would want the economy to do (improve living standards, individual freedom, 'happiness')...
- _delirium 13y agoIn a way that's what some of the early 20th century Marxists (in the group of "Orthodox Marxists") were arguing. In the extreme form of that view they had a view on management that aligned nearly 100% with the view of the big capitalist "barons". A common view among industrialists of the era (starting in the late 19th century) was that modern scientific management, statistics, supply-chain-management, etc., was making bazaar-style capitalism obsolete, and ushering in an era of efficient, centralized, vertically and horizontally integrated, scientifically optimized production. That was one of the arguments used against anti-trust legislation: industrialists argued that anti-trust legislation was just purposely shoring up obsolete, inefficient models based on the medieval bazaar, which were out of touch with a modern scientific, centralized industrial sector. A certain variety of early Marxism said more or less: yes, we agree with all that. Except for one thing: once industrial capitalism has centralized the economy, with a few huge trusts running things as a smoothly oiled production machine, the shareholders are now more or less superfluous. So, we'll just knock 'em off and distribute the proceeds of this machine among all the workers equally. The industrial capitalists only disagreed with the idea of socialist central planning in that they didn't want to distribute the proceeds of central planning, not in believing that decentralized planning was better. Many did agree that some kind of redistribution was necessary so that all society benefitted, but they preferred redistribution managed by the monopoly capitalists themselves in the form of philanthropy, which they felt they would be able to thoughtfully manage (Andrew Carnegie's The Gospel of Wealth is representative of this view).
- motters 13y agoFor anyone interested in this the Eden Medina book provides some historical background. I think eventually that Cybersyn will be viewed as an early attempt at post-capitalist economics in which resources are efficiently managed in real time and there is feedback at every level.
- ommunist 13y agoFrom my perspective it is even post-socialist, not to say post-capitalist. Since socialism supersede capitalism. What was attempted in Chile was to jump even further within a time of single human generation. It will never be forgotten.
- CaptainSwing 13y agothe term 'post-socialist' is generally termed 'communist'. Allendes Chile was actually relatively moderate in its socialism, in the sense that he was a radical reformist rather than a revolutionary. I agree, however, that there was a great potential for something much more dramatic (ie, a true decentralised communist planning) within the cybersyn project.
- CaptainSwing 13y agoI second this. For anybody who cant be fucked sear hing up the link on wikipedia the Eden Medina book is called 'cybernetic revolutionaries'. It's a great piece of research (although, in my opinion, lacking somewhat on both political and technological analysis. It seems to be the best book out there on cybersyn). Also, for anybody interested in the general ideas check out the novel 'Red Plenty' by Francis Spufford. Its about attempts at a similar scheme in the USSR and the problems it faced (more ideological and organisational than technological) What makes Cybersyn interesting for me, particularly in relation to the Soviet schemes, was the decentralised nature of it, including the (unfulfilled) ideas of bringing workers into the fold. Also, the Adam Curtis series 'Pandoras box' (youtubeable I think) discusses both cybersyn specifically and the ideas around it.
- netcan 13y agoFrom the Marxist perspective, isn't communism post-socialism? IMO, as an idea, this isn't post-anything. It fits very nicely (almost to the point of cliche) into the "modernist" family of ideas. Socialism was the most prominent political and economic philosophy of modernism. Objectivism is another example. Anti-socialists of the modernist period (who often objected to modernism as a whole) kind of parodied modernism in a way that is similar to this. Super efficient computers that calculate truth and can run everything optimally. Fredrick Hayek (an early postmodernist) parodied social "scientism" and socialism in just this way. He argued that this kind of planning is doomed no matter how big your computer is because the requisite information is unknowable, not just unknown. I see this as something like a 1950s science fiction work. But I'm biased. I don't think this will ever work and I hope it won't either.
- veganarchocap 13y agoMillions wasted on expensive systems and software to manage and negate the damage caused by an inherently inefficient method of running an economy. One size does not fit all, no matter how much state software you create to make it so. If you combine this level of technology at a micro level, combined with the incomparable efficiency of the market, THAT is when you start to see incredible things starting to happen. From small businesses monitoring their sales and orders in real-time, sharing their data with their marketing agency via api's. To construction companies using internet of things to monitor structural wear to alert them of replacements needed. It's at this market oriented macro-level that you will see the greatest advantages. Creating and making the technology to power that is most important. And that's where we come in!
- rbc 13y agoThere is a software implementation of Beer's Viable System Model in Smalltalk. The VSM was part of the basis for Cybersyn. See: http://ss3.gemstone.com/ss/VSA.html http://ss3.gemstone.com/ss/VSA.html
- szpak 13y agoStafford Beer's Chilean Cybersyn project was one of the inspirations for the Community Memory (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_Memory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_Memory) project in the Bay Area in the early seventies, which, being the first public computerized bulletin board system (and flea market), helped lead to today's World Wide Web and related.
- nnq 13y ago...but it was not even let to to either work OR fail on its own, so we'll never know if some of the ideas could have worked. ...like it happens with all attempts of any kind of technocratic government: sooner or later some groups of power totally freak out contemplating god knows what imaginary consequences of its future development and pull the plug on it and paint it as another "failed experiment". When will we actually become mature enough to be able to truly run social-engineering experiments in a scientific way and asses their results? (repeatedly and periodically, because with time people's mentalities change, so what didn't work in the past might work in the future and viceversa). When will we accept that "political 'science'" can only be an experimental 'science', so we have to at least try and run unbiased experiments from time to time and see what works better, instead of just letting the blind watchmaker of evolution run its inefficient search of the problem space? As an analogy [EDIT+ to clarify] of how wrong I think we do politics and social engineering now [/EDIT]: Imagine that in medicine you'd run 10% of a drug trial, then stop/pause it and make an "educated guess" based on this 10%, and based on this published guess have people vote whether to put the drug on the market or not. Sounds reasonable to anyone? :)
- dnautics 13y agoTo run with your analogy. Let's take the case of vioxx, which was voluntarily withdrawn by merck after post-approval experiments showed statistically significant increases in heart attacks - never mind that this is exactly biasing the 'experiment' against vioxx (http://www.evanmiller.org/how-not-to-run-an-ab-test.html http://www.evanmiller.org/how-not-to-run-an-ab-test.html). The people vote to withdraw vioxx from the market. Because, heart attacks! Well, what of the plenty of people who decide that they'd rather have a slightly increased risk of heart attack instead of debilitating, quality-of-life-shattering daily pain? To take it further, what about conditions that specifically only address a minority of people, let's say that we made a drug that cures sickle-cell anemia, but gives a 100% chance of getting cancer by age 70. Who should make these decisions? Also: Who gets to be the person deciding on the 'educated guess'? And how can I be this person so that I can pick my pharmaceutical stocks ahead of time?
- kingkawn 13y ago
- frabcus 13y agoIf you want a 5 minute video digestion of this, including who Stafford Beer is, I gave a lightning talk at Liverpool Ignite. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJkxvVOm01g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJkxvVOm01g