3 ms·
What you describe is predatory trading, which is a trading strategy engaged in by players at many speeds. And all you've shown is that the price impact of a wha
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
What you describe is predatory trading, which is a trading strategy engaged in by players at many speeds. And all you've shown is that the price impact of a whale dumping stock is now felt by the whale, not by the other players in the market.
I.e., before the big player decided to liquidate the natural price was X. After they decided to liquidate the natural price is Y < X. The market will move from X to Y, it's only a matter of when. If the whale sells at X, the other players eat the loss. If HFTs predate on the whale, the HFTs gain, other players take less of a loss, and the whale eats more of the loss.
Why is this bad? Is it somehow a desirable feature of the markets that Goldman can dump 1M shares of AAPL and the rest of us are supposed to eat the price impact?
Also, predation is unlikely to be affected by an FTT. You typically make well over 6bps from predatory strategies. It's only the low margin market making which will be affected.
- crdoconnor 13y agothis strategy is ineffective with the transaction tax. it should be obvious why. the whale is normally a pension fund or some other institutional investor that doesn't have the resources of an hft. that means they get burned. I find it somewhat amusing that you're assuming that the rest of the market needs to be protected from the pensioners by Goldman Sachs.
- yummyfajitas 13y agothis strategy is ineffective with the transaction tax. it should be obvious why. Explain like I'm a 5 year old child how a 6bps tax will prevent HFTs from running a strategy generating 20-100bps of alpha. It'll certainly prevent them from running a market making strategy generating 1-2bps. You also still haven't explained why it's better for the whale (i.e., someone large enough to move markets) to be able to make others suffer the price impact of their trades.
- jules 13y agoHow is the whale making others suffer? If an investment fund is forced to sell because of its terms, then it's making itself suffer. It's just that now HFT traders get to serve as the useless middle man.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoConcrete example. The whale wants to dump 1MM shares which will result in a price drop from $105 to $100. Currently the bid/ask is $104.9/105.1. If the whale sells at 104.9, the market will figure it out, and the counterparties who just bought will find the price of their shares drops to $100. A predator forces the whale to suffer more of the price impact while making price improvements for the counterparties. I don't see a reason to prioritize the whale over the counterparties.
- jules 13y agoFirst, the "benefit" to the counterparties is infinitesimal. The predator is going to scape up the market at as lost cost as possible. Second, shares don't magically lose underlying value just because an investment fund is forced to sell. Longer term the price will go to whatever it would go anyway. Investors who bought did not lose that $5. Besides, even with HFT involved the short term price will still drop to $100 so everyone holding those shares still "suffers". Suffice it to say that this is a ridiculous argument which I'm sure you are not actually making but I'm just pointing this out. Third, because of shady HTF practices like flooding the exchange with orders, it's most likely actually hurting the counterparties, impeding their ability to adjust their price. Now tell me, what social good did the HFT middle man bring?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoSupply goes up - price goes down. If whales weren't worried about price impact they wouldn't be hiding their offers (typically by running HFT systems of their own, or renting them) to begin with. Third, because of shady HTF practices like flooding the exchange with orders, it's most likely actually hurting the counterparties, impeding their ability to adjust their price. I don't understand. Counterparties want to buy and a predator is improving prices. How does this hinder them? I'm not asserting that predation is socially good or bad. It marginally increases market efficiency and causes small players to lose less money to the big boys - that's the extent of my claims. I just don't understand why everyone seems to think helping the big players is somehow socially beneficial. What's good for Goldman is good for America?