8 ms·
Mark Zuckerberg calls Obama to complain about NSA
- rhizome 13y agoPreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7394131 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7394131
- iLoch 13y agoThe hypocrisy is astounding.
- res0nat0r 13y agoYeah, it's strange to think that Facebook could be analyzing all of the data their users voluntarily upload to FB to try and make them money.
- intslack 13y agoI'm going to echo another comment I saw here yesterday: if Mark cared he would put his money where his mouth is and back off datamining IM conversations and enable OTR by default. Mark only cares because the IC is, in a way, damaging his brand by plainly revealing the dangers of centralized services. The hypocrisy is Facebook's repeatedly sneaky approach to "permissive" marketing. While Facebook will never have a gitmo or "enhanced interrogation program," that doesn't excuse their complete disdain for user's privacy such as actively tracking the movement of users across the web, for example, data they most definitely didn't volunteer.
- declan 13y ago>back off datamining IM conversations and enable OTR by default. Do you have more info on Facebook "datamining IM conversations?" We learned last year that Microsoft does this: http://www.h-online.com/security/news/item/Skype-with-care-Microsoft-is-reading-everything-you-write-1862870.html http://www.h-online.com/security/news/item/Skype-with-care-M... But I don't recall any evidence that Facebook does. Of course I may be misremembering, and I did write a piece for CNET (before leaving to found http://recent.io http://recent.io) titled "Facebook's outmoded Web crypto opens door to NSA spying": http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-57591560-38/facebooks-outmoded-web-crypto-opens-door-to-nsa-spying/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-57591560-38/facebooks-outm...
- MichaelGG 13y agoWe did not learn that Microsoft "datamines IM conversations". All we know is that Skype (like other IM services) has a URL checking service. It's possible that only the URL is sent to Microsoft outside of whatever normal encryption Skype uses. There may be some technical questions we might like answers to (why do HTTP URLs apparently not get scanned; why does it only do a HEAD request), but the most obvious answer is that it's some detail of MS's anti-spam/phishing system.
- ta_fbp 13y agoI remember skype being known for making it possible to spy on user conversations, text and audio/video, way before microsoft bought it. With microsoft moving skype back from p2p to centralized server architecture doesn't hints at making spying on users more difficult.
- MichaelGG 13y agoThat's a separate issue. Obviously Skype could have MiTM connections since forever. They probably were legally required to do so, too. But decoding messages isn't the same as "datamining" them. And it's disingenuous, in context of IMs being datamined for advertising, to call an antispam service datamining, even if it's possibly technically true.
- declan 13y agoThis turns on the definition of "datamining." Surely scanning ostensibly private messages to update a database, even one built for innocuous purposes, especially without clear and conspicuous notice to users, is one form of it. From the H-Online.com article: A spokesman for the company confirmed that it scans messages to filter out spam and phishing websites. This explanation does not appear to fit the facts, however. Spam and phishing sites are not usually found on HTTPS pages. By contrast, Skype leaves the more commonly affected HTTP URLs, containing no information on ownership, untouched. Skype also sends head requests which merely fetches administrative information relating to the server. To check a site for spam or phishing, Skype would need to examine its content.
- pswilson14 13y agoSurely, you see a difference between a data company collecting data from users who willingly hand it to them, and a government that forces those companies to hand over private data against their will?
- Argorak 13y agoSure. I also see a difference between a company asking everyone for that data in a clear fashion and one that tries get hold of every scrap of data from its users, even if it has to do with non-users (e.g. by collecting their address books). To be clear about address books: they are "yours", but they hold data that you may not have permission to give away.
- spacehome 13y agoFacebook can ask me all they want for my data, and I won't give it to them. The feds literally don't give me a choice.
- Argorak 13y agoThat is true, but moral standpoints are not black/white and Facebooks moral standpoint in the whole privacy debate isn't quite the strongest. Facebook will basically take any interaction with them as a "yes". Also, Facebook didn't ask me when my friends gave my phone number and address to them. Zuckerberg has repeatedly shown a lot of moral flexibility on those issues - so the irony is definitely there.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- spacehome 13y agook, I concede that point, but none of my friends are giving my info to the NSA, either.
- 13y ago
- vlasev 13y agoIs the fact that he's a hypocrite make his point irrelevant?
- skore 13y agoNo matter how frowned upon straight quoting wikipedia may be, this seems appropriate: > Nothing is more unjust, however common, than to charge with hypocrisy him that expresses zeal for those virtues which he neglects to practice; since he may be sincerely convinced of the advantages of conquering his passions, without having yet obtained the victory, as a man may be confident of the advantages of a voyage, or a journey, without having courage or industry to undertake it, and may honestly recommend to others, those attempts which he neglects himself. --- Samuel Johnson I think Mark Zuckerberg is sincere in his request. And I think his sincerity and thus his self-delusion is the far bigger, systemic problem.
- ta_fbp 13y agoIt's not really news that in the USA, corporations claim for themselves rights attributed to a person while at the same denying the same rights to the actual persons.
- slowmotiony 13y agoCan regular Americans call Obama too or is it just rich people?
- medikoo 13y agoPresident's time is limited, so it's better if just representatives of bigger groups of people call him directly. I think we can say that in some sense Mark represents larger group of people.
- Ygg2 13y agoIn other words, only rich people :P
- vlasev 13y agoIt's not BECAUSE they are rich though...
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago> in some sense Mark represents larger group of people. Who? My guess would be Facebook employees and venture capitalists.
- davyjones 13y ago"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others."
- vlasev 13y agoMaybe you can try a few rungs down the ladder?
- 37prime 13y ago“How dare the NSA spy on Facebook users. Their informations are property of Facebook."
- DominikR 13y agoWho else should own the data if not Facebook?
- dredmorbius 13y agoThe users, and/or non-user individuals whose data it is.
- roymurdock 13y agoWhen you accept the terms of agreement, you trade your data for the privilege of accessing and using the site. Information doesn't become data until it's recorded through the use of a website. If privacy is an urgent concern for you, then why use Facebook in the first place? It's basically a public forum where you share things, creating data. It's ridiculous (at least in this day and age) to think that Facebook would provide such an extensive service for free. You're going to pay for it with your data.
- dredmorbius 13y agoWhen you accept the terms of agreement I'm not a Facebook user. Whose user agreement governs the use of my data on Facebook? Dittos for Google or other data aggregators who acquire data from elsewhere. And/or ignore the explicit stated preferences of users. And/or change the rules governing data use post-facto.
- samsolomon 13y agoWell, users are volunteering their information to Facebook. They aren't doing it for the government.
- 13y ago
- tempodox 13y ago<blockquote> "When our engineers work tirelessly to improve security, we imagine we're protecting you against criminals, not our own government," Zuckerberg wrote </blockquote> Small correction: The US government ARE the criminals you need to protect against.
- ta_fbp 13y agoAs usual, facebook PR is fallacious. Naively pretending they don't know governments are historically often engaging in criminal activities to draw attention away from the fact facebook is a massive surveillance too, one that past political regimes could only dream about, which by some kind of magic should be acceptable on grounds that it is done by a private corporation for commercial profit.
- bsaul 13y agoWhich reminds me of : what are the current realistic alternative to facebook as of today ? I'm thinking of some tech that would let me remain in control of the data i show to my friends.
- balladeer 13y agoThere are such alternatives out there and you'll find it if you look for it but you shall not migrate to those service because your friends are not yet there. Everybody stays thinking the same.
- ta_fbp 13y agoYou could try email, xmpp instant messaging, self-hosting your website, and so on. Maybe a secure p2p tool such as waste. But one way or another the problem is usually the same, your friends are locked in by facebook and don't want to use something else to see what you want to show them.
- tomelders 13y agoI feel it's worth pointing out that Facebook won't lock you up without trial in a secret prison, torture you and violate every human right you have because of something you think. There is a real difference between what Facebook does and what the US government does.
- ta_fbp 13y agoI feel it's worth pointing that facebook makes it easier to identify and locate people who end up in prison without trial and so on. For a little while I've wandered into the business of finding the identity behind an online account and finding the physical whereabouts of said person for private companies and state police. It was in the pre- and early facebook era and it was sort of detective work, picking up details and clues, cross-referencing data, some wild guess and luck. Then facebook grew to the monstrous thing it has become, and now these past employers do not require external contractors to do this kind of job, they just go to facebook and do the job themselves in little time.
- declan 13y ago>I feel it's worth pointing that facebook makes it easier to identify and locate people who end up in prison without trial and so on. Can you identify one person that Facebook has identified who has wound up sentenced to prison without a trial? No? Didn't think so. I'm not a defender of Facebook and have posted critically elsewhere in this comment thread about FB data-mining. But the grandparent post has it right: Facebook != the government. Facebook wants to show you ads to buy stuff you don't need. The government wants to arrest you, strip search you, and imprison you for smoking a plant it decreed is unlawful, or transferring a series of bits it decreed is unlawful.
- comice 13y agoA phone call is a cute gesture. If he really meant what he said he'd go to court.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]