2 ms·
Business model: improve OSS and ask for payment to release result as open source
- amichail 19y agoWould this make sense? You make whatever improvements to OSS that you like and then you ask people to pay you so to release your improvements as open source. You could also release binaries to try to convince people that paying to open source your improvements would be worth it.
- corentin 19y agoIt's called ransomware. Fabrice Bellard (http://fabrice.bellard.free.fr http://fabrice.bellard.free.fr), who is not your average hacker, tried this model with kqemu and as far as I know, despite the great quality of his work, it didn't work (he finally decided to release the thing under the GPL). Stephen King tried a similar system for a novel and it didn't work either (he quit writing it). John Carmack has a model that works: initially release the thing under a proprietary license, make money with it and then release it as open source software.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- davidw 19y agoPeople have tried it, and it doesn't seem to work very well.
- amichail 19y agoThe advantage is that you would have complete freedom in what you do. It's not like you are working for anyone.
- davidw 19y agoBy not work I mean that people don't seem to be able to make a living at it, let alone "get rich". There are a few cases of people successfully doing a commercial version that gets features before the free version, but that's sort of a different thing than the "ransom" (as it's known) model. This has been discussed on the Free Software Business list before: http://www.crynwr.com/cgi-bin/ezmlm-cgi?mss:11850:200710:ldikcdjhgmbngilaanlm http://www.crynwr.com/cgi-bin/ezmlm-cgi?mss:11850:200710:ldi...
- SwellJoe 19y ago"The advantage is that you would have complete freedom in what you do." Unless what you want the freedom to do is make a reasonable amount of money. I'm not saying don't do it, if you want to be able to work a bit more on projects you love--I've done it several times, and don't regret the time spent or the low figures earned. "It's not like you are working for anyone." Here you're wrong. You're working for everyone that sends you a dime, and they will let you know it, too. Open Source users who've been asked to pay are among the most entitled software users on the planet--more even than Open Source users, in general--I'm a (happy) Open Source developer of 8 years, and I've done several ransomware projects and I think it's a great way to get things done...but don't imagine that your users will be particularly nice when you ignore them. So, by the definitions of many of the folks here at news.yc, it's not a viable business model. Actually, by almost anyones definition, it's not a viable business model. But, it is a fun way to work on projects and make a little pocket money. If you can make the project profitable in other ways simultaneously, like writing a book about it, writing articles for magazines or a popular blog, providing high end services to deep-pocketed corporate customers, etc. you can make a living...I know many people who've done just that, including myself for several years. But you won't get rich and you won't be without a boss--you'll have dozens of bosses.
- queensnake 19y agoIf it's big enough, release the software but make people pay for the documentation. That's how NumPy and VTK do it, currently.
- SwellJoe 19y agoI know the developer of NumPy. He has a real job (working predominantly on NumPy and SciPy). Documentation sales provide pocket change. And the VTK folks provide services, and I'm certain it's a much larger source of revenue than documentation.
- brl 19y agoAsk payment to who exactly? The 'community'?
- amichail 19y agoAnyone can contribute to the payment. When it's high enough for you, you would release your code as open source.
- SwellJoe 19y agoIt doesn't work very well. Virtualmin was originally developed in this manner. We made about $10000 total over the span of about a year...and a big part of that was due to my existing relationships with ISPs and hosting providers that desperately wanted a non-cPanel solution to the problem. Very little of it came from people I wasn't already doing thousands of dollars a year in business with.