2 ms·
I love this game, though I haven't completed it for all of the endings. I love the idea and the design, that is...first of all, Lucas Pope is the developer I as
by danso 13y ago
I love this game, though I haven't completed it for all of the endings. I love the idea and the design, that is...first of all, Lucas Pope is the developer I aspire to be...able to singlehandedly dream up a concept and execute it, and be totally personable on Twitter to the mass of fans he deservedly generated.
I fell in love with the game ever since I saw the YouTube trailer and read some of his game dev diaries...It's hard to think of a modern game that has such limitations -- the color palette, the clunkiness of the interface, the unforgivingness of the scoring system -- for such artistic intent.
But what I think is particularly noteworthy and inspiring was how Pope didn't make the game as a political statement. He (from what I remember in his early podcasts) thought about the idea while waiting in customs, and wondered if a game could be made of the drudgery of this work. His commitment to making a game that excelled as a game resulted in a game that was actually fun, while being an artistic achievement and politically engaging, for sympathizers of both the state and the refugee.
(As counter-examples, I think "Cart Life" is also an amazing achievement in art, but not a very good game because of unintentional bugs. Also, most artistic games in which you mostly just walk around until the game ends).
David Simon, who created "The Wire", complains quite bitterly that his intent was to make a show that raged against institution and bureaucracies, and yet people only talked about Omar and all of his other characters...Simon did such a great job of plot and characterization that it overshadowed his political aims. I kind of see "Papers, Please" as the opposite of that...Pope just wanted to make a great game, and he did such a great job of it that it turned out to have a compelling political message.
Anyway, it has my vote for being included in the MoMA's video game collection. And it's inspired me to go back into games programming, at least as a hobby.
- kderbe 13y agoLucas Pope kept a Papers, Please development journal from start-to-finish: http://forums.tigsource.com/index.php?topic=29750.0 http://forums.tigsource.com/index.php?topic=29750.0 It was fascinating for me to read because: 1. The art and design are almost unchanged from the original Photoshop mock. 2. Pope is wonderfully gracious to the other indie developers who give initial feedback. 3. He engages really well with the influx of new people that appear whenever his (at the time) beta game gets featured on a gaming news site. He has a knack for knowing which suggestions to consider, and explains to fans why the others won't work with the game. It demonstrates a level of maturity, both in personality and in craft, that few other game developers seem to have. 4. In the post-release update, he details the internal tools he built to manage the game's development, especially its day-to-day plot.
- nekopa 13y agoHey, I want the last three hours of my life back, and that's from just reading the dev journal! You are correct in his way of dealing with people, really suggests a level of maturity, confidence and open mindedness about him. I like the way that he seems to seriously consider people's ideas, and is not afraid to incorporate me wines into his game. The fingerprinting for example.
- maxiepoo 13y agoInteresting, do you have a link to any of those David Simon comments? I always thought that the themes of "The Wire" were so coherently presented that they would be impossible to overlook.
- danso 13y agoThis is the first that comes to mind: http://artsbeat.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/04/05/the-game-never-ends-david-simon-on-wearying-wire-love-and-the-surprising-usefulness-of-twitter/?comments#permid=2 http://artsbeat.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/04/05/the-game-never-... > But actually, the comments I made that seem to critique viewers who found The Wire late were not so intended. I thought, when I made that remark, that I was speaking to the reporter not about viewers in general, but specifically about folks pursuing the recent bracket-tourneys about best characters, shows, scenes, etc. It was to that silliness -- and nothing more -- that I tried to say simply this: The folk sponsoring such belated silliness were not there when the show aired. Now, years removed, they parse it piecemeal and to meaningless effect. And rarely in the debate of Omar v. Stringer or Season Two vs. Four does anyone argue, say, the drug war, or the role of public education or the vagaries of market capitalism. That's the wearying part for me. That people find the show when they do, or that people like or dislike what they will -- who can take offense at that? But is it okay to admit the Omar-is-so-cool bracket tourneys don't interest people who made the show? That debate about what we got right or wrong about urban America would be, to us, more purposeful and validating? Apparently, no such context conveyed, either through my fault or in the edit of the Q&A, or both. Sorry if anyone thinks I was actually complaining about people liking The Wire, or when they got there. I wasn't. My critique went to how certain media folk assess the story, and how empty that stuff seems to our real purpose. I agree with David Simon...because every real fan knows that Bunk is the real star ;)
- Cthulhu_ 13y agoThat's /The/ Bunk, thank you very much, :p. As for not everyone looking at series like the Wire the same way, that's just natural. I'm sure a lot of people think Papers, Please is a shit game too. Can't argue with taste, can't steer people's priorities when it comes to TV shows either. The Wire for example needs a lot of attention and concentration to watch; a lot of people have some TV show on in the background, and only pay attention when something (or someone) draws attention to them.