7 ms·
Papers, Please: The 'boring' game that became a smash hit
- b0b0b0b 13y agoThe article doesn't offer much on how it became a hit. I learned about Papers Please from nerdcubed on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sV-6YSye2Vo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sV-6YSye2Vo I bet he hasn't spent anything on, say, a google ad campaign.
- sillysaurus3 13y agoI think it became a hit as a natural consequence of being so good. He had to do almost no work on promotion, iirc. But I think he was a fairly popular gamedev (or at least not-unknown) before he made Papers, Please. One thing to realize is that game reviewers like Yahtzee and especially TotalBiscuit always have their eyes open for new games that have new gameplay. That is, games with game mechanics that have never been thought of before. So if anyone here happens to make one, and it's fun, then you'll probably be able to get picked up by TB. And since he has >1M YouTube subscribers, that's quite a lot of publicity. (Papers, Please was picked up by TB. It's how I heard of it.)
- leoc 13y ago> I think it became a hit as a natural consequence of being so good. He had to do almost no work on promotion, iirc. But I think he was a fairly popular gamedev (or at least not-unknown) before he made Papers, Please. Looking at it a little cynically for the moment ... in the old days, the main bottleneck that prevented everyone from having their own commercial computer game was money and juice with publishers, while the second-place bottleneck was juice with console manufacturers. Now those factors are much less restricting than before, so everyone has their own indie game. ;) But that means there are many, many more games than the maximum number that can ever achieve significant sales and attention. So the new bottleneck is public attention, and the new king gatekeepers are the gaming media (including Penny Arcade, Let's Players like Totalbiscuit and so on), who can direct the public's attention to your game. So which players are ahead in the new game? Guys with gaming-media juice, either through having gaming-industry recognition or being ex-journalists themselves. Step forward Tom Francis (PC Gamer -> Gunpoint), Jim Rossignol (Rock, Paper, Shotgun -> Sir, You Are Being Hunted) and Lucas Pope (Naughty Dog -> Papers, Please). Now that is a little too cynical, because the new game does seem to be significantly fairer to people who simply make (or would be able to make given funding etc.) a game good enough to deserve attention, and certainly Gunpoint and Papers, Please are notably good games (I haven't played Sir yet). (I should also emphasise that I'm not any kind of expert here, I'm just looking at the situation from the outside.) But I think there's likely some truth to it.
- jdonaldson 13y agoI learned about it first from the Haxe/Openfl mailing lists. They're usually where the language users go to promote some of their games and pet projects like this. However, even on that group there was very little in the way of information on the game. It really did feel like this grew entirely by word of mouth.
- pekk 13y agoYou can't really explain this (or many other recent indie successes) without including the relatively recent influence of Steam Greenlight.
- leoc 13y agoNot to deny that Greenlight is important but that seems to be overstating it. There was lots of buzz about Papers, Please back when it was still just a free-download beta on Lucas Pope's website; now it's on not only Steam but also GOG and the Humble Store. Of the notable "indie" hits from the past 3-4 years, most were probably (or certainly) in development before Greenlight was even announced, several got on Steam without going through Greenlight at all, several were successful on other platforms before going onto Steam (Amnesia, SpaceChem (initially rejected for Steam) ...) and some have kissed off Steam completely (famously Minecraft). If anything Greenlight looks a bit like Valve's late entry to the Humble Bundle/XBLA party.
- NamTaf 13y agoAs the article is more about the developer and his story rather than the game itself, the premise of the game isn't quite captured in the article. Specifically, the tension comes from the fact that you are in some fictional former soviet state, which just opened up a border security crossing again. You've been posted to man it, and now live with your family in a government housing estate. You have a finite amount of time to process people through the security gate each 'day' and you're paid based on how many people you get through, with fines for incorrect processing (which of course gets harder and more convoluted as the game goes on). At the end of each day, your income and expenses (for rent, food, electricity, medicine for your son/wife/elderly parents as needed) are shown. The tension comes from rushing to process enough people to ensure you don't have to go without food, or turn off electricity, or not medicate your family. However, if you make too many mistakes by rushing, you get fined too much and you don't get to care for your family. It's really far more gripping than you'd expect because the whole art style, audio and interactions (both between days via a daily newspaper, and with the people as they enter through your booth/events that unfold during that) really help paint a picture of a desolate former soviet wasteland of poverty and misery. Couple that with the distilled essence of 'putting food on the table for your family so they don't starve' being the motivating factor, and it can be quite high-tension to try to not have your family inevitably starve and freeze to death with crippling illness. For $5 (if you grab it during a steam sale), it's worth the experience for sure. I'd have been happy paying the standard $10 for the unique experience it offers.
- notahacker 13y agoIf it's all in the setting I hope he releases a sequel set in a developing country where you're trying to rack up as much as many informal "administration fees" as possible without getting caught...
- scotty79 13y agoIf you detain people in Papers Please the guard who does the actual detaining gives you a cut. It feels like sort of a bribe.
- hwang89 13y agoPapers' site: http://papersplea.se/ http://papersplea.se/
- hibikir 13y agoThe indie market is quite open to games that really come out of left field, instead of following the same 5 genres indies always go back to, if just because they are easy and well understood. Lucas had made a couple of nice mini-games before that showing how relatively unconventional gameplay can be quite fun if attached to a good premise. The Republia Times is pretty much the same emotional concept but with different gameplay. A big part of the game being a hit IMO was the beta was just out there for download, and it was a very polished first third of the game. A few large blogs picked it up, and at that point, if the game is any good, it'll just sell a whole lot. The demand was so big that Steam approved it for Greenlight out of schedule: It was greenlit after just a week or two on the process. Either way, It's a game that is very easy to recommend.
- mercurial 13y agoNow we just need a game simulating an analyst in a large SIGINT agency of a fictional superpower. Can you gather enough metadata in a day to feed your family?
- Cthulhu_ 13y agoI would not be surprised at all if this was already in the making. With that in mind, I'm surprised there hasn't been a ton of clones for Papers, Please yet - like how Minecraft and Terraria clones are all over nowadays. Also, instead of feeding your family, the object of the game should be to keep your EFF-friendly colleague from going rogue, :p
- pgl 13y agoAnd they won! Best Strategy and Simulation in 2014.
- _pmf_ 13y agoI bought it because I thought there's no way this could be fun, but it turned out not only to be fun (in a depressing way), but also to feature a really great emergent story line, which immediately puts it above 80% of other games.
- danso 13y agoI love this game, though I haven't completed it for all of the endings. I love the idea and the design, that is...first of all, Lucas Pope is the developer I aspire to be...able to singlehandedly dream up a concept and execute it, and be totally personable on Twitter to the mass of fans he deservedly generated. I fell in love with the game ever since I saw the YouTube trailer and read some of his game dev diaries...It's hard to think of a modern game that has such limitations -- the color palette, the clunkiness of the interface, the unforgivingness of the scoring system -- for such artistic intent. But what I think is particularly noteworthy and inspiring was how Pope didn't make the game as a political statement. He (from what I remember in his early podcasts) thought about the idea while waiting in customs, and wondered if a game could be made of the drudgery of this work. His commitment to making a game that excelled as a game resulted in a game that was actually fun, while being an artistic achievement and politically engaging, for sympathizers of both the state and the refugee. (As counter-examples, I think "Cart Life" is also an amazing achievement in art, but not a very good game because of unintentional bugs. Also, most artistic games in which you mostly just walk around until the game ends). David Simon, who created "The Wire", complains quite bitterly that his intent was to make a show that raged against institution and bureaucracies, and yet people only talked about Omar and all of his other characters...Simon did such a great job of plot and characterization that it overshadowed his political aims. I kind of see "Papers, Please" as the opposite of that...Pope just wanted to make a great game, and he did such a great job of it that it turned out to have a compelling political message. Anyway, it has my vote for being included in the MoMA's video game collection. And it's inspired me to go back into games programming, at least as a hobby.
- kderbe 13y agoLucas Pope kept a Papers, Please development journal from start-to-finish: http://forums.tigsource.com/index.php?topic=29750.0 http://forums.tigsource.com/index.php?topic=29750.0 It was fascinating for me to read because: 1. The art and design are almost unchanged from the original Photoshop mock. 2. Pope is wonderfully gracious to the other indie developers who give initial feedback. 3. He engages really well with the influx of new people that appear whenever his (at the time) beta game gets featured on a gaming news site. He has a knack for knowing which suggestions to consider, and explains to fans why the others won't work with the game. It demonstrates a level of maturity, both in personality and in craft, that few other game developers seem to have. 4. In the post-release update, he details the internal tools he built to manage the game's development, especially its day-to-day plot.
- dangero 13y agoIt seems likely that a lot of people bought it, like I did, for a novel experience regardless of whether or not the experience is actually fun. We're living in quite the renaissance of game exploration. I wonder if the indie game genre will continue to flourish or if this is a temporary moment of history. Regardless it is probably as strong as it has ever been right now. Gone Home is another recent and interesting "game" to check out: http://store.steampowered.com/app/232430/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/232430/
- pekk 13y agoSince you just linked an indie game on Steam, you probably have to acknowledge that Greenlight is a significant contribution to this renaissance. Some people might not like to hear this, because Steam is a DRM platform. But if the Pirate Bay had a similar ability to promote the development and sale of indie games, it would have happened already.
- dangero 13y agoI'm not sure I would refer to Steam as a DRM platform. Steam application deployment does have apis built in for DRM, but they are not required for release by Valve. It's up to the developer to decide if they want to DRM lock their game using the provided tools.
- malka 13y agosteam by itself is a DRM. It controls that you are authorized to launch the game, etc. However, I find this kind of DRM acceptable, since it does get in the way of the legit buyer extremely rarely.
- aninhumer 13y ago>It controls that you are authorized to launch the game Steam provides an infrastructure and API to perform this check, but the developers decide whether to use it. There are many games on Steam which don't use this DRM, and can be launched directly from their install directories even if Steam isn't running.
- corin_ 13y agoSince the article mentions the BAFTA Games Awards a few times: Papers, Please didn't win best game, which was to be expected (though his former employer's The Last Of Us did win that and 4 other awards), however it did win for best strategy/simulation, which was a surprise win (not easy for an indie game to take a bafta). It seemed quite popular at the event, had a few people cheering every time it was mentioned.
- rumcajz 13y agoBureaucracy by Douglas Adams deserves to be mentioned in this context: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bureaucracy_(video_game) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bureaucracy_(video_game)
- Quaro 13y ago>You know when you play a first-person shooter that claims to be about “how far you’re willing to go to protect the ones you love,” or “the true cost of a life,” or “moral ambiguity,” but the gameplay actually consists of shooting hundreds of dudes in the face? And you know how in the back of your mind, you wonder, “I wonder what it’d be like if a game actually designed its gameplay around those concepts rather than just duct-taping them on through noninteractive story?” >Papers, Please is that game. It manages to ask (and importantly, not answer) questions of duty, safety, privacy, family, self-interest, and morality through an incredibly simple, focused set of mechanics based around checking transit papers and stamping passports. http://www.heyash.com/why-i-like-papers-please/ http://www.heyash.com/why-i-like-papers-please/
- xg15 13y agoA good review of the game from a few months ago: http://scientificgamer.com/thoughts-papers-please/ http://scientificgamer.com/thoughts-papers-please/
- psionski 13y agoThe guy in the second screenshot does not correspond to his picture in the passport... in fact, I think that's a spy.