3 ms·
I know the graphic designers have long since won this battle, but I still feel like there's value in underlining links. Underlined links are discoverable -- it
by smacktoward 13y ago
I know the graphic designers have long since won this battle, but I still feel like there's value in underlining links.
Underlined links are discoverable -- it's obvious at a glance that they are links, rather than body text.
Underlined links are noticeable -- they stand out from a sea of non-underlined text, drawing the eye to them.
Underlined links are self-explanatory -- it's obvious what you're supposed to do with them (i.e. click).
These are all valuable UI benefits.
The solutions that most sites that have abandoned underlined links have taken up in their place all have drawbacks compared to the good old underline:
Underlining the link on hover/rollover reduces discoverability -- you don't know for certain whether something's a link or not until you investigate it.
Making links a different color reduces usability for the color-blind; red-blind people have no idea that your red links look different than your black text does.
Making links bold, italic, or a different size all leave the possibility of confusing the link with body text that happens to share the same typographical presentation. (You can underline text too, of course, but that's relatively rare on the Web because of the strong association of underlining with links.)
Nobody cares about this argument anymore, I know, so I don't expect anything to change because of it. I just think it's worth noting that there are good reasons to prefer underlining links that don't boil down to "stuck in 1996".
- bluthru 13y agoFor links buried within copy, I agree. For a list of search results where you know every entry is a hyperlink? Pure visual noise and I'm glad it's gone.
- wmeredith 13y agoI agree. As long time UX watchdog in many of the companies I work for (interaction designer/developer) I always want to see links underlined if they are inside a larger body of text. Menus and link lists? Not as big of a deal as long as it's still consistent with establish interaction patterns of the whole project.
- existencebox 13y agoI feel a similarity between this and infiniscroll, without trying to draw false parallels. Whenever each comes up, I find myself asking "but why do I even want this?". It feels like a bunch of people trying to iterate on techniques for the sake of iterating on techniques. I have some slight equivocation with myself over the above, after having written it; since it seems to lead the question "isn't almost everything just iterating until a breakthrough", but to be pragmatic, I have to draw a line somewhere before I start shaving yaks, and perpetually tweaking how I look at "THIS REFERS TO SOMETHING SOMEWHERE ELSE" seems to be getting quite four legged and fuzzy, so I'll leave it in. (to be more productive about this all, if a UI designer wants to try and make a compelling argument for "why I want this", I'd certainly give it the time of day)
- huskyr 13y agoWhen we're complaining about UX changes in Google Search anyway: i really miss the old left-hand side menu with search filters, especially with image search. They've hidden it under 'search tools' where it takes more clicks and it's a lot less visible than the old way.
- mbesto 13y agoFrom an article in 2004 that is still very much relevant today: Underlined blue text is still the most obvious visual indicator of a link ...and more... http://www.nngroup.com/articles/guidelines-for-visualizing-links/ http://www.nngroup.com/articles/guidelines-for-visualizing-l...
- hnriot 13y agoseriously??? My 12 year old daughter could spot a hyperlink from a hundred yards without the ugly underlining. She told me "it's obvious". Links are inferred by their placement, you click on google search results more than a couple of times and you learn. Humans figured out fire, the wheel, perspective and now space travel so I really don't think the lack of underline is really going to dent anyone's web experience. People keep saying the same old nonsense that underlining helps them discover etc, but come on... seriously, if you really believe that you're in the wrong place. "Nobody cares about this argument anymore" - finally I agree with you.
- lnanek2 13y agoYeah, honestly, at most places I work this would never fly because we support people with disabilities and that means having more than just color indicate something is a clickable link. There are even laws forcing this, ADA, for government and education. Personally, I think they should at least make the summary clickable if they are going to do this.
- cjensen 13y agoI use xScope [1] to simulate seven types of colorblindness. The blue titles are distinctive in every simulation. Does xScope miss something? Or are you assuming that blue is not distinctive because most colors are not distinctive? [1] https://iconfactory.com/software/xscope https://iconfactory.com/software/xscope
- geetee 13y agoAt risk of sounding heartless, catering to the lowest common denominator sucks. Like supporting IE6-level suckiness. There is more than enough information available in markup for accessibility software to override design choices.
- trayfare 13y agoYou don't sound heartless, you just sound like a lazy whiner.
- agumonkey 13y agoFirst time I met this 'new' design, I thought it was a rendering bug[0]. Next time I understood it was testing, and I just thought 'why' ? Google seems desperate to find things to tweak while ignoring things that I find obvious: - right click event turns the url in a trackable monstrosity [1] - shortened url can't be copied [2] - no, sharing doesn't only mean 'publish on g+' - filters could be made faster [3] - g+ has comment notifications, gmail has nothing [1] facebook => https://encrypted.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=facebook&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CCYQFjAA&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2F&ei=AhoiU53iBcSo0AWp4oCIAQ&usg=AFQjCNGug_CqO9cxLI8dHdn-CceO8_ie5w&sig2=iGblH1CoFfkWGoFpmAMIKA&bvm=bv.62922401,d.Yms https://encrypted.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=facebook&sourc... and [2] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.facebook... https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.facebook..... [3] instead of submenus that pops at opposite side, toggle buttons for instance year|month|week , or local|global . The old right side vertical list was better (even though lacking features). [0] Chromium had some issues on my platform (or maybe just my distro) recently
- reubenmorais 13y ago> - no, sharing doesn't only mean 'publish on g+' I sympathize with the feeling, but do you really expect them to drive people to their competitors? Do you think Facebook's Share button should allow you to Publish on G+ as well?
- agumonkey 13y agoGood point, I forgot was logged in, and judge google.com as a public page (unlike facebook primary essence). Logged off, the `share` option is gone. But that remark was in the context of mangled URLs. I can't right-click, double click nor select to get the URL and pass it along. Very broken IMO even though I understand they want me to visit said page.
- existencebox 13y agoA personal anecdote: I was an avid youtube user, but their nearly ceaseless iteration of everything from sidebar contents to full on page layouts and link availability (I remember a time when one could go from the video listing of one channel belonging to one user directly to another channel's usable video links. This now takes 2-3 clicks, depending on your definition of usable.) has me at a point where I get frustrated when I have to use the service, and am actively looking to migrate off of it. Soundcloud has almost entirely replaced youtube for me in the music sense, the problem seems to be that there's no video service "core" enough that "everyone" uploads "everything" to it. A lot of handwaving there, but youtube has a certain amount of critical mass in that area, AFAIK. (if I'm living in a little google bubble, I'd appreciate other video services, but I feel like I'm aware of most of the main ones ala vimeo, and as I said, critical mass.) Note: I feel like google treats most of their services like this. I personally have felt nothing but decreased usability since the not-TOO-far-removed-from-pure-html days of gmail. (The pinnacle for me was shortly after the integration of gchat and the polish that came after, but before the great whitespace apocalypse.)
- tyilo 13y ago>Making links a different color reduces usability for the color-blind; red-blind people have no idea that your red links look different than your black text does. Either you have no idea what it means to be colorblind or you are talking about an extremely small percentage of all colorblind people.