11 ms·
If American public transportation fans would stop fantasizing about trains and instead do what really works for most people -- buses Trains really work for lar
by untog 13y ago
If American public transportation fans would stop fantasizing about trains and instead do what really works for most people -- buses
Trains really work for large numbers of people. A single NYC subway train can carry something like 2,400 people. A bus can carry something like 1/10 of that at best. Once you factor in the subway and local train services to New Jersey, CT, Long Island and Upstate New York you really, really don't want to think of buses as the future of mass transit in dense urban areas.
- benesch 13y agoOh god. Even a bi-articulated bus with 240 people on it is emphatically not a bus I would want to be on.
- maxerickson 13y agoSure. Trains work great where you already have them and lots of people that want to ride them. They also work pretty well if you have a massive budget and the political will and power to build out sensible routes. So they don't work for a whole bunch of the U.S.
- mikeash 13y agoBudget, political will, and power are three sides of the same coin (you heard me), and one person's "fantasizing about trains" is another person's "trying to convince the public that it's worth spending the money".
- soperj 13y agoHelsinki has a subway though. This is on top of that.
- tricolon 13y agoHelsinki has a tram system (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_tram https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_tram) and bus system. The metro is mostly for getting to/from East Helsinki (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_metro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_metro).
- tuukkah 13y agoThe single metro/subway line is nothing compared to bigger cities, but don't forget the three urban railways and the hugely popular bus rapid transit (line 550)! These form the basis for a network of high-service trunk lines in this wide urban area of only 1.4 million inhabitants. Here's a nice schematic of what the system will look like in 2016 when the subway extension west of Ruoholahti is complete, the lines 560 and 500 have started, and the M and I trains have expanded to become the airport trains V and P: http://www.flickr.com/photos/29682104@N04/9711135644/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/29682104@N04/9711135644/
- willyt 13y agoThe trouble is, trains require a certain density to be economic and to run a frequent enough service to be convenient. The ideal city density for an efficient metro service is roughly equivalent to streets of 4 or 5 storey apartment blocks. If you've ever been to Barcelona then you'll have an idea of the ideal density. Very few urbanised areas of the US meet this requirement and most of the areas that do fit the bill date back to before the 1920's and already have mass transit. Buses can operate in cities of lower density, but still require a certain critical mass. I don't have the figures to hand but there has to be a certain number of households within 5 minutes walk of a bus stop to make it viable and many suburbs aren't dense enough for this. See the book 'Cities for a small planet'. Also the Reith lectures on this topic: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00gxns8 http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00gxns8
- danielweber 13y agoYes, keep the trains where you have them. But to reduce car ridership, work on making buses good enough that professionals want to take them to get to work.
- anologwintermut 13y agoThe story that trains are superior for high density is not necessarily true. Buses with dedicated lanes appear to have high throughputs and lower infrastructure costs ( not to mention can continue to run into lower density areas or have routes more easily changed as the population density shifts). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_rapid_transit#Comparison_with_light_rail.2F_metro_systems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_rapid_transit#Comparison_wi...
- tacticus 13y agoBut significantly greater operational costs. Those comparisons are with light rail not heavy rail like the new york subway.