8 ms·
Government's Empty Buildings Are Costing Taxpayers Billions
- spindritf 13y agoThen the agency has to make sure another one doesn't want [the building]. Then state and local governments get a crack at it, then nonprofits — and finally, a 25-year-old law requires the government to see if it could be used as a homeless shelter. Every one of those regulations is perfectly reasonable. Yet when put together they lead to empty buildings staying empty, expensive and useless. This is a very uderappreciated consequence of regulation in general.
- mschuster91 13y agoIt should be made a law that Congress (or for that matter, any law-passing authority, this problem exists not just in the US), should before passing any law evaluate its impact and interference with already existing law. Such thorough checks would also quite likely regularly turn up the "bit rot" equivalent of laws...
- cmelbye 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congressional_Budget_Office http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congressional_Budget_Office ?
- mschuster91 13y agoLooking at the crap we Europeans see happening in the US, I seriously doubt the efficiency of this agency. A good example is that story about the old lady on HN who had rented an illegal building. One agency demanded that she be evicted, yet another law forbid the eviction, or such.
- crusso 13y agoNot sure about their efficiency, but the CBO is normally way off on their estimates for what various programs are going to cost. Unlike in a lot of life, being wrong in the government has little or no impact upon your ongoing viability.
- predius 13y agoA lot of this isn't actually the CBO's fault... because they're totally non-political, or need to appear to be, they score things according to the letter of the law. The thing is, the letter of the law is never followed, as whenever the painful (cost reduction) parts start to apply, Congress votes to nullify the pain, which makes them more expensive. See the 'doc fix'.
- crusso 13y agoI'm not that interested in fault. I'm interested in its reliability as a source of information. I'm interested in the trust that their information is given when they're wrong so often - for whatever political or non-political reason. CBO numbers are used as a shield by politicians to push their agendas. I wish that they didn't have that shield because voters were more aware of its inaccuracy.
- jeffdavis 13y agoThe CBO scores based on the information given to them. It's a "garbage in, garbage out" problem.
- bennylope 13y agoNot sure what an old lady renting a building has to do with the CBO, but I suspect that cmelbye is pointing out not that the CBO is efficient at its job, but that institutionalizing impact measurement (CBO) is insufficient in the face of powerful political incentives. That's how I read it, anyhow.
- cmelbye 13y agoThe stuff I see here in the US is nothing compared to what happens in Europe -- people incite revolution, no one seems to know who's in charge, and governments attack their own people in broad daylight! Your generalization is as meaningless as mine is. The USA is roughly the size of your continent and its land can be governed by any number of rules and regulations, depending on where you are. For every Texas, there's a California. For every Germany, there's a [Ukraine|Greece|Spain|...].
- mschuster91 13y agoNeither Turkey nor the Ukraine is in the EU, that point of yours is a bit off. And for our treatment of the African refugee seekers, well I compare that to the US-Mexican border. No side is better in any way than the other. But agreed, how we Germans treat Greece is disgusting. Basically, everyone claims "how bad the Greeks are", but the bailout money does not go to the Greeks but to our own banks. This has never been to "rescue Greece", but to rescue our fucking banks.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y ago"It should be made a law that Congress (or for that matter, any law-passing authority, this problem exists not just in the US), should before passing any law evaluate its impact and interference with already existing law." Ironically, that law would have so many impacts on so many other laws, it would be impossible to evaluate them all. It's the halting problem for lawyers. :)
- mitchty 13y agoMight get them to repeal some useless laws and trim down the laws they want to pass so they don't impact so much. I don't think it would be that bad overall once they realize the quagmire their current methodology really means.
- gamblor956 13y agoIt's already the law...Congress already has several agencies that deal with these sorts of analyses. The most famous are the Congressional Budget Office and the Congressional Research Service. They deal with this silliness all the time, so they're actually quite good at it.
- msandford 13y agoIt's a great idea but mandating it won't make it happen. You have to get people in office who actually care about not making bit rot in the law. Most of the folks making laws right now at a Federal level like the bit rot because it gives their donors loopholes to drive their armored cars through. For example a large chunk of what the Federal government is doing right now isn't specifically authorized by the Constitution, but the Congress doesn't care. "Necessary and proper clause" they say, nevermind that running well over half the Federal government on the necessary and proper clause defeats the whole idea of limited enumerated powers. I don't have any good suggestions on how to fix the problem with the officials not really caring to do their jobs, though.
- dbecker 13y agoI don't know if the irony was intended, but this sounds like another level of regulation (likely requiring additional levels of auditing, etc)... potentially yielding the exact opposite what it intends. I briefly worked for the Federal Government, and I recall an immense amount of paperwork being generated by the regulations of the "Paperwork Reduction Act."
- Loughla 13y agoI call bull on this one, fella; I think you're a bit ignorant on this matter. I'm federally funded, and have been for the better part of my career. The paperwork reduction act has nothing to do with physically reducing paperwork, and more in reducing the work burden to the public. It states that every form has to have a justification tied to your guiding principle, and that the public should know how difficult the form will be to fill out. In other words, if the OMB says that form 1014a(1) should only take 15 minutes to complete, it's up to your office to ensure that is the case, if you created that form. As far as physical paperwork - it only adds a couple of lines to document headers, and in the case of enormous institutions, it's listed on their main website or main document to avoid adding it to the rest of the documents. The paperwork reduction act is usually the brunt of office jokes when it pops up on paperwork, because most people have no idea what it is and it sounds funny, and because it may add a line or two. I'm guessing you've seen that disclaimer and went from there.
- dbecker 13y agoI think you're a bit ignorant on this matter. I don't know why you need to turn this into a personal attack, but you are dead wrong in everything you assert about my beliefs and experience. By paperwork, I meant the work burden... and we spent a lot of time getting approvals for small scale data collection efforts. Maybe you have gone through the process. But I have, and it was a headache.
- Loughla 13y agoIt's not a personal attack? Being called ignorant just means that you don't know something. Stupid, that's an insult, but ignorant simply means that you don't know. Your comment stated that the paperwork reduction act added paperwork, which you used as an example to the statement "potentially yielding the exact opposite [of] what it intends." The intention of the federal paperwork reduction act isn't to reduce the physical amount of paperwork to you. It is to ensure that all paperwork has a purpose, and a timeframe for completion that isn't overly burdensome. Therefore, your premise that its main goal was to reduce the physical number of pages for federal programs is incorrect, I assumed you were ignorant of what the federal paperwork reduction act was, and I explained it. I have gone through the process of having federal forms cleared with the OMB at the federal level, large scale and small scale data collection, and have worked with them in several capacities. I don't like that I have to have everything relate to my goals and purpose or that I have to conduct studies on the front end for forms, but I see the purpose for it.
- humanrebar 13y agoI'd like every law and regulation to have an expiration date.
- logfromblammo 13y agoSeconded. If every law had to be re-passed every six years or so, that would tend to limit the number of laws that could be in existence at any given time. I don't recall which, but some culture had a tradition whereby the entire body of law had to be read aloud in public before any new business could be conducted. It feels in my memory like it might have been Medieval Iceland. That is an excellent tradition. But I also get the feeling that all we'd get from Washington DC is an act every 6 years to reauthorize the entire US Code in its entirety, which would pass without debate in about 30 seconds.
- humanrebar 13y agoI had a similar thought regarding omnibus renewal of regulations, but it's a technical problem that could be addressed. Perhaps by introducing another reform I would like to see: make it trivial (maybe through a petition?) for U.S. citizens to sue the government to get laws repealed. I'm not a lawyer, but my understanding is that, which some exceptions, you need to be actually harmed to have standing to challenge laws on constitutional grounds.
- Loughla 13y agoThat just allows for new earmarks and stipulations with an increased possibility of corruption and more influence from vocal special interest groups on a regular basis. It's counter-intuitive, but sometimes inefficiency is the safest course of action. Not necessarily the best, but the safest. And not always, I need to stress that again.
- humanrebar 13y agoI don't follow your logic. Why would earmarks be more likely if laws had expiration dates?
- bitJericho 13y agoOr you could just add another requirement that if the building is vacant you do something about it lol.
- jeffdavis 13y agoHow are those "reasonable"? The purpose of a sale is to find out who wants something. That's the economic system we use. Aimlessly asking around works when you want to know if your cousin wants your old sofa before you craigslist it; but is just ridiculous in any larger context.
- misterbwong 13y agoI'm not saying there's not a better way but why is this ridiculous in a larger context? If the government didn't have these rules in place, we'd be seeing another article about how the government keeps buying and selling buildings, costing taxpayers billions, when they could have transferred buildings at a relatively minimal cost. I suspect that this is why these regulations were enacted in the first place.
- jeffdavis 13y agoWhy does buying and selling buildings cost money? First of all, it can take some effort to find a buyer. This effort needs to be expended regardless, and I don't see how it's better to in-source the work to the selling government agency. They are not professional brokers, have little incentive to act quickly or efficiently, and we've already established that they don't have any magical database that makes the buyer obvious. Just let a commercial RE broker handle it like a business would. Second, you need to settle-up the accounting so it's no longer on the seller's books, and is now on the buyer's books. That means you need to agree to a price. You can skip this because "it's all part of the federal government", but that leaves us with the mess we have now: nobody knows what buildings are being used by whom at what cost. Accounting costs are not waste; otherwise large private (not publicly-traded) companies would fire their accountants. So it seems like the best course of action is to do the same negotiation and accounting work that happens as a part of the sale. So the buying/selling costs are not a waste, they are money well-spent. It's possible to make them more efficient in special circumstances -- maybe the costs of due diligence, fraud prevention, title insurance, etc. are little or nothing when buying from the federal government. But those special cases can be handled as special cases and there could be a cheaper, quicker path to sell if those circumstances are met.
- crusso 13y agoIf you read this article and you were surprised (dismayed, I hope), then you should examine your news sources. This problem has been floating around for years. Worse, this is just the tip of the iceberg. A building that has been empty for decades is an obvious waste, but there are many wastes that far outstrip this one. There are hundreds of billions of dollars out there that could be put toward paying down our debt and securing programs that are going bankrupt like Medicare and Social Security. That's why when I hear Pelosi and others say that they can't cut a dime out of the budget. She said, "The cupboard is bare." I feel disgusted.
- Kalium 13y agoThe funny thing is, a lot of these costs are so high because of previous attempts to save money. For example, contractors are used heavily at just about every level of government. We're hellishly expensive. You know why this happens? In no small part it's because the government general schedule pay scale is a vow of poverty for any skilled and educated professional. So those people go to contractors to get paid reasonably and the contractor happily applies a markup and sells their services back to the government. Behold, "cost cutting measures" in action.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoThat problem comes from interpreting a requirement to reduce costs as "do the same things with less" but never as "do less".
- untog 13y agoAnd that problem comes from a requirement to reduce costs that does not specify what services will be cut at the same time.
- Kalium 13y agoThat's because in government, you're aren't allowed to choose to do less on your own. That's a choice made above you, and always a difficult one. As a result, the requirement is almost always "do the same with less".
- Shivetya 13y agoI was under the impression a great many of the buildings counted are on military bases. that in itself is an issue because as with post offices Congressmen step and dictate what is open and what isn't
- wf 13y agoThis is pretty insane. It seems like such a simple problem to solve (eg, send auditor with an app on his phone, input building condition, occupancy, etc. sync back to database that has other information, value etc.) But the regulatory hoops and the bureaucracy involved just break everything. It blows my mind that we don't try to approach these problems more rationally.
- Kalium 13y agoIt's hard because there isn't a reliable source of data to begin with. How do you solve a "simple problem" with an auditor and an app if you don't know where to send them?
- bernardom 13y agoAmazing. It would be great to have some sort of open-sourced effort to catalog government owned buildings. Kind of like an OpenStreetMap. I don't see why most govt buildings shouldn't be publicly listed on a database; they can obviously classify the ones they don't want everyone knowing about. $1.7B is a lot. I'd be curious how much they'd (we'd) get if the government sold used buildings that are now in expensive areas. For example, the Department of Transportation has a huge gigantic building in the middle of Kendall Square in Cambridge, MA, which is the most expensive office space in New England. I have to imagine the land alone is worth a ton.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoNothing stops us from doing this. We issue Freedom Of Information Act requests to agencies via https://www.muckrock.com https://www.muckrock.com, and then we integrate it into OpenStreetMap. It's just a matter of someone taking the time to do it.
- Cthulhu_ 13y ago> It's just a matter of someone taking the time to do it. And there's the crux of the matter; it takes a ton of time, and few people care enough to invest that time. And even if there is someone that cares - like the people / organization listed in the article - their efforts will only make a dent in this issue, which is exacerbated by the heaps of paperwork and whatnot they have to go through.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI'll sink the time into it if it was actually put to use. My fear is I'll waste ~100 hours on it, and then some bureaucrat will toss it all.
- fmorel 13y agoThe General Services Administration (more specifically the Public Building Service) is responsible for maintaining the federal building portfolio and leases for itself and other agencies. You can see all GSA-owned buildings from here: http://www.gsa.gov/portal/content/104797 http://www.gsa.gov/portal/content/104797 However, many agencies manage some or most of their buildings (VA, IRS, and others). DoD is completely separate. Property disposal (or renovation) is further complicated by historic preservation requirements as well.
- kiba 13y agoCreating good governance(whether it's government, charities, corporations, and so on) is one of the biggest unsolved problem for humanity. Yes, we function quite well on some level. We wouldn't have a civilization otherwise. It does seems that the government is so inefficient in many way that reducing many of them would probably lead to an order of magnitude of improvement in the lives of human beings, economically and socially.
- crusso 13y agoLike a complex computer and software system, government needs to be refactored. Besides revolution, I don't know how to force that refactoring.
- dllthomas 13y agoI think what we need most is testing. Currently, the system looks like this: A bunch of salespeople (legislators), chosen mostly for the feature changes they say they want to make (or prevent) sit down in a room and negotiate. Developers (staffers), chosen by those salespeople, turn it into code - which, after some audit (but no testing) is pushed straight into production. It is then patched in the field by QA & tech support (judges and lawyers) - those patches never make it back into the source. Also, revolution isn't refactoring - it's starting a complete rewrite after you turn off your production system, and is usually every bit as bad an idea as you'd expect.
- rayiner 13y agoI love the software analogy, because it puts people who think we need revolution in the same camp as people who think Microsoft should rewrite Windows.
- crusso 13y agoWow, if only that analogy were appropriate. If you're unhappy with your government, just install Linux over it or get a Mac. On top of that, Microsoft rewrites Windows all the time. Their customers follow them from one release to the next because they do so.
- apaprocki 13y agoWhile talking to someone in NYC government a while ago, they were lamenting the fact that there wasn't a unified system to view all of the city properties, who was occupying them, and how much vacant space there was within the buildings. Fully vacant buildings are one problem, but if you have 100 10,000 sq. ft. office buildings and only 5,000 sq. ft. each is being used, that is a completely different problem -- but equally important in terms of eliminating waste or saving money.
- jeffdavis 13y agoWhat is the incentive to say you're not using the space? It could force you to move to a more cramped location and extend your commute. And your agency's budget is now permanently lower, with no benefit you can see. Better to just fill up the space somehow; even it it means hiring do-nothing people.
- bhousel 13y agoFinancial incentives could be set up between agencies. Say for example DOT has extra office space in one building and they can rent it out to DSNY for cheap. Then DOT gets money they wouldn't otherwise, and DSNY can pay less than they might pay to rent office space in a private building (This is just an example and I don't know if DSNY actually rents, but I know some agencies do). This works if you can relocate teams of people together (along with their stuff). Also advances in technology help here, as you can scan paperwork into a document management system and virtualize peoples machines so that it matters less where they are actually sitting. The city is doing some of this, but they move slowly.
- jeffdavis 13y agoWhat you just described sounds like a lease, to me. I'm sure that's fairly common. The problem you run into here is: who gets the lease money? Why should the DOT get extra money just because they bought a building that is too big? The root of the problem is that budgets are based on perceived need with no downward pressure. The DOT has every incentive to make the perceived need higher, and leasing out half of their office space is not a good way to do that.
- interstitial 13y agoLet's watch the millenialtards confront the idiocies of their 'activist government' beliefs as they collide with reality.
- xacaxulu 13y agoYet another example showing that no profitable company could ever be run like the Federal government and continue to exist. Aren't you glad you paid your taxes on time this year?
- cowsandmilk 13y agoYou should study companies and their real estate portfolios. There are a number of companies sitting on vacant properties that are intentionally unused. As an example, most pharmaceutical and chemical companies have large unused facilities that sit empty while the company is churning out billions of profits a year. The main reason is that these sites are contaminated and the companies are afraid of liabilities from selling the properties. Funnily enough, this is exactly the first hurdle the article says the federal government faces in selling their properties. Guess the corporate world ain't that different.
- aric 13y agoThe difference is that one isn't forced to unwillingly pay those unaccountable companies (the scourge of a government's corporate subsidies notwithstanding).
- kaonashi 13y agoKeeping unused real estate from falling into disrepair and becoming hazardous? Yea, that's real wasteful. I'm piping mad.
- flavor8 13y agoClearly a business opportunity. GAO/GSA are likely to fund an improvement to their database (http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-12-645 http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-12-645). If any other small-outfit contractors out there want to form a coalition and put together a preemptive proposal, shoot me an email. I have some contacts who work in procurement who may be able to advise on the best approach.