4 ms·
That conjecture is much less certain than it is portrayed. Let's say we found a civilization of oyster-like creatures on a oceanic moon of a gas giant planet of
by Zigurd 13y ago
That conjecture is much less certain than it is portrayed. Let's say we found a civilization of oyster-like creatures on a oceanic moon of a gas giant planet of a nearby star. Are we really going to go that far for a raw bar?
"Conquering" stellar civilizations only happens in space operas.
- spacehome 13y agoThe fact that your first thought is about the feasibility of eating aliens lends tonnes of support to the idea that it's in the aliens' best interest to wipe us out.
- Zigurd 13y agoIt looks like the greater danger is the inability to spot satire. They'll come and and prank us and we'll humorlessly launch nukes on them.
- wmeredith 13y agoAlmost did a spit take while reading that first sentence, thanks!
- rahimnathwani 13y agoI don't know the original sources of this joke, but this version is pasted from http://www.chinasmack.com/2009/stories/what-if-district-9-alien-prawns-landed-in-china.html http://www.chinasmack.com/2009/stories/what-if-district-9-al... - Aliens land in Beijing, Beijing people would ask the aliens if they believe in capitalism or socialism. - Aliens land in Shanghai, Shanghai people would drag the aliens to the zoo to put on display. - Aliens land in Guangdong, they would be eaten… - Aliens land in Wenzhou, Wenzhou people will ask the aliens: is business easy to do on your planet?
- pinkpussycat 13y agoI'm sure there's a new reality TV show somewhere in that...
- freefrancisco 13y agoThe problem is not so much what the aliens might do to us, but what their microorganisms, bacteria/virus equivalents, might do to all of earth's life. Our microorganisms would survive and adapt, we might not.
- Lambdanaut 13y agoTheir viruses wouldn't have evolved to prey on Earth life. The alien germs would probably just die, or at best live a very sickly life here on earth while they slowly evolved to our climate (millions of years later)
- mattlutze 13y agoOr perhaps their germs would drink in the nourishing radiation of our young, yellow sun, grow strong and learn to harvest corn while wearing fake glasses.
- Houshalter 13y agoThere are things like paperclip maximizers (http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Paperclip_maximizer http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Paperclip_maximizer). Even a regular alien civilization is likely to be very, very different than us in entirely unpredictable ways (http://lesswrong.com/lw/so/humans_in_funny_suits/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/so/humans_in_funny_suits/). They may not have a moral system like ours, they may not value our lives at all. Such a civilization might destroy us simply because they don't want us to become too advance and compete with them. Or possibly become a threat to them. Or maybe just because they want our solar system someday. I'm not claiming that any of this is certainty. It really is very difficult to predict. But I caution against anthropomorphic reasoning. I also think it would be wise to be cautious about taking these kinds of risks, if we can.
- saulrh 13y agoThere's also the "Killing Star" argument[1]. Basically, when your weapons are relativistic planet-crackers, any civilization you can observe is an existential threat: any civilization that shoots destroys another [2]. Civilizations have survived evolution and presumably other first contacts, and will probably be willing to shoot first to avoid being shot. Any civilization you observe will go through this thought process, realize you are going through the same thought process, and will proceed to shoot because they assume you will shoot. [1] http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/aliens.php#id--The_Fermi_Paradox--The_Killing_Star http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/aliens.php#id--... [2] http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/spacegunexotic.php#id--Relativistic_Weapons--The_Killing_Star http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/spacegunexotic....
- darkmighty 13y agoToo simplistic reasoning imo. If your civ can build impossibly large relativistic weapons, can't it survive an impact of one? Wouldn't the huge cost of building those/providing energy favor the pacifists? And so on. I think it's essentially impossible to predict what to expect from a point of view of specific technologies, and a more fundamental approach is more interesting: given the possible gains we might have, and the possible threats (termination should have a fair likelihood), the expected utility from contact should be hugely skewed negatively -- assuming -inf utility for termination and +finite for whatever gains.