3 ms·
Your idea reminds me of Vernor Vinge's "A Deepness In The Sky", where an interstellar sublight civilization comes up with a STL transmission protocol: they broa
by pavel_lishin 13y ago
Your idea reminds me of Vernor Vinge's "A Deepness In The Sky", where an interstellar sublight civilization comes up with a STL transmission protocol: they broadcast information for free, assuming that by providing free information, they'll ensure that wherever they arrive will have a civilization that will a) have something worthwhile to trade, and b) be able to repair their ship and replace crew members.
I don't think that this would work with only one transmitter node; we need to build machines that travel to other solar systems, build receivers/transmitters there (one per system! we don't want to become a source of Aggressive Hegemonizing Swarm Objects, but rather a source of Evangelical Hegemonizing Swarm Objects), and re-broadcast from there.
(This also minimizes our chances of inviting unfriendly folks from coming down to check out who's being so noisy in the solar system.)
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoI do really think everyone overestimates how bad someone finding out where we are would be. For one, unless they are right next to us (in which case they should be able to hear whatever we send already), or by the time they hear our signals hundreds of years would pass at minimum. Even if they do hear, it would be a great deal of time before whatever they do can affect us.
- darkmighty 13y agoWell you're performing an action which -- even if you won't be directly affected by it's outcome, unless you're silly you should be planning for a specific reaction; that reaction would preferably not include destruction of our civilization.
- strlen 13y agoI loved Deepness In The Sky, one of the darkest ("Age of Failed Dreams", twentieth-century style authoritarianism coupled with technologies of the future, etc...) and yet most fascinating pieces of fiction. It's also one of the few (along with Vinge's other work) to depict distributed systems (in this sensor networks) in a realistic manner. Couple of things to keep in mind though: - With the exception of the spiders and two other aliens, most of the civilizations the Qeng Ho (another romanization of Zheng He, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zheng_He http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zheng_He) are human. As a result (and based on their historical and software archives), they are able to understand what drives the civilization they deal with. Even then, however, contact with some of them turns out for the worse (The Emergents in this case) at least in the short term (and by short I here I mean decades -- human life is extended due to medical advances and suspended animation, and that's not taking into the account relativistic effects, e.g., by the time one comes back to their planet, the civilization on that planet may have already fallen). - Qeng Ho is better termed as a culture: they're certainly not a government much less an empire. The book goes very deep into this angle and I won't go further to avoid plot spoilers. - Relativistic time dilation ("grandfather paradox") plays a huge role here in travel. The civilizations rely on Bussards Ramjets (which seem to be impractical, magnetic sails would be more likely) and constant acceleration and then (from half-way point) deceleration: they're effectively marooned if they're unable to repair or refuel their "ram scoops", so they're taking bets that whenever they reach their target, the civilization on the other end is able to repair the ships. Again, that works well if the civilizations are human: even if the civilization has fallen into barbarism (like Pham Nuwen's home, Canberra -- where they've lost even radio and aircraft) it's possible to rebuild based on archaeology, knowledge of human nature (arranging deals and trades), and (as the parent mentioned) radio communications. So I think this is where the analogy fails: it's possible to have an inter-stellar culture without faster than light travel or communications, but probably only as long as civilizations already familiar with each other are within light decades. Fire Upon the Deep is quite fascinating in the sense of what is possible with FTL, although even there it seems that there are mostly cultures as opposed to empires (with Skroderiders -- the sci-fi aliens I want to meet most in real life! -- being the equivalent of Qeng Ho)
- pavel_lishin 13y agoYour points are very valid, but I'm not proposing actually sailing amongst the stars - I'm just proposing getting a network up and running. It doesn't even necessarily have to build a culture - it just has to build up a framework that works well enough to exchange some data and technology.