3 ms·
Quick question: are the German radicals German? Germany has a storied history with its immigrant Muslim population, as does much of Europe. In other European
by patio11 17y ago
Quick question: are the German radicals German? Germany has a storied history with its immigrant Muslim population, as does much of Europe. In other European countries, for example France, burning cars is a crime which is largely the province for "disaffected youths" who are nearly universally Muslim immigrants or the children thereof, a very uncomfortable fact which is sometimes elided from the reports.
Back during the French civil unrest a few years back there were numerous reports which put the number of car arsons as in excess of a hundred. Per night.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/europe/article607860.ece http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/europe/article60...
- jacquesm 17y agoDuring the peaks of the riots as much as 500 cars were burned every night. The reason why the fact that the youths that commit these crimes are predominantly muslims is edited out because there are some risks associated with that becoming the focal point. First of there is a resurgence in Europe of extreme right parties, almost every country has at least one of these and they are flourishing enough without being able to tap into more fear based populism. (Wilders, Le Pen, Dati, Griffin and a whole bunch of others are gathering wool with every news item that so much as mentions islam). Secondly, the French government has actively foisted the conditions that have led to these riots by turning a blind eye to the festering problems of discrimination and class justice prevalent in France (and again, similar situations exist in other european countries, most notably the Netherlands, Austria, Germany, the UK and Belgium). To put the spotlight on this fact would have risked further escalation, by downplaying it the risks of escalation were diminished, but so was the opportunity to really look at what causes these youths to be so dissatisfied with their lot in life. Being born the son of a dark skinned immigrant in Europe is - in spite of all the politically correct mumblings - not the same as being born 'white'. It's very unfortunate that these issues are still so large in what are supposed to be democratic societies where everybody is equal.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"Being born the son of a dark skinned immigrant in Europe is - in spite of all the politically correct mumblings - not the same as being born 'white'" So do non-white non-muslims participate in these riots? Motivation for question == (1)if the riots are a protest against racial discrimination dark skinned people of all religions would riot, as happens in the USA occasionally (2) if the riots are a protest against religious discrimination one would imagine muslims/non christians riot, dark skinned or not or (3) is it the case that if you are darkskinned and muslim you get discriminated against (but, not say, if you are darkskinned and christian), in which case non-white muslims riot?
- jacquesm 17y agoI think it is neither, it just so happens that the majority of the disillusioned youths in France have a few things in common, most are 'coloured', most are muslims. This makes it very easy for politicians to tap in to the fear factor present in the older and the not so well educated portions of their respective societies because these people are different and do bad things. If it were religious I think the attacks would not be against property the way it is now, if it would be racial there would be other overtones. That does not mean that the risk that it will become that way isn't present though. I think it is mostly an expression of frustration by the 'have nots and probably never will haves' vs the people that can afford the goodies, such as cars. Interesting aside, the current French Prime Minister Nicholas Sarkozy rode to his current position on his 'tough' stance during all this.
- plinkplonk 17y agoInteresting. Thanks. Sounds more like class warfare than religious/racial protests.
- mynameishere 17y agoI can't believe you just blamed the monstrous crimes of a foreign horde on the _right wing_. How much brainwashing did that take? Christ.
- jacquesm 17y agoHm, that is not what I wrote at all. Maybe I can explain it a bit better. These crimes are not by a 'foreign horde' but by children of immigrants with the French nationality. That makes them French, and possibly a French horde but French nonetheless. The fact that the majority of them are children of foreigners (or can trace their lineage to an immigrant within a few generations) is incidental, there are plenty of children of French citizens that take part in these riots that are not of African descent. The 'right wing' uses the high incidence of African descent kids in these riots to justify their tough stance on immigration, deportation and so on and they use it to stoke the fires of xenophobia and use it as a platform to blame those kids. All they are doing is to use them as a cynical pathway to power. Whereas principally it is a problem of French society (and other european countries as well) as a whole that these people - and plenty of them are lily white - think of themselves as totally without any chance to succeed in their society. That is why their anger is directed against property and not against people. The European right wing parties leave out those not-so-convenient facts because it would work against their interests, which are predominantly based on being anti-islam and anti-foreigner. Burning a car is a crime, sure. Is it monstrous ? I don't think so, I think it is as much a crime as creating a society that has an underclass this large. When you push people into a corner you'll get a reaction. Best to create a society where as few people as possible harbour those feelings.
- jongraehl 17y agoThe willful destruction of my car would seem pretty monstrous to me. I would also probably blame the people who did it, before I blamed society.
- cracki 17y ago"die autonomen" usually are germans, not immigrants. they're disillusioned youth too, but kinda like white trash kids that read too much Marx.
- jacquesm 17y agoThat, and a large number of 'hangers on' that have little else to do and are impressionable.
- davidw 17y agoSounds more like they're talking about left wing extremists, which, if it's anything like Italy, are definitely home grown, rather than immigrants. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Brigades http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Brigades For example. What is this doing on HN, though?!
- kingkawn 17y agoThe leftists have a website.