4 ms·
Its interesting that you immediately translated "means of production" in the preceding comment to "means of production to be owned by the state". There's other
by lamontcg 13y ago
Its interesting that you immediately translated "means of production" in the preceding comment to "means of production to be owned by the state".
There's other possibilities for "the workers owning the means of production" that don't necessarily involve the state owning the means of production. You can have the workers who do the actual work at the plant own the means of production, instead.
Setting up a dichotomy between top-down heirarchial capitalism and top-down heirarchial statism implicitly ignores any possible middle paths.
- mason240 13y agoBecause in the end it they will be owned by the state. You can assign it whatever other names you want, but it will be a state. "workers who do the actual work at the plant own the means of production" This cuts right to the heart of my original comment. That is a very broad model that simply doesn't apply to most workers, and numbers of whom grow smaller ever year. Marxism is an obsolete idea based on a world that hasn't existed for almost a century now.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Setting up a dichotomy between top-down heirarchial capitalism and top-down heirarchial statism implicitly ignores any possible middle paths. Arguably, "top-down heirarchical capitalism" and "top-down heirarchical statism" aren't polar opposites, they're more adjacent neighbors -- there's a reason that many non-Leninist Marxist call Soviet-style Communism "state capitalism".
- dllthomas 13y ago'there's a reason that many non-Leninist Marxist call Soviet-style Communism "state capitalism"' "No True Scotsman"? I'm not trying to say that's all that it is, just that it's certainly a potential explanation.