2 ms·
I disagree with your analysis. The burden of proof lies on those claiming theoretical benefits (less anxiety) from a plan (some untested flavor of Marxism). Per
by humanrebar 13y ago
I disagree with your analysis. The burden of proof lies on those claiming theoretical benefits (less anxiety) from a plan (some untested flavor of Marxism). Perhaps he was making a argumentum ad absurdum, but it is fair to underscore skepticism by rhetorically asking for any evidence of reduced anxiety in any society.
Besides that, I find shaming people for their reading comprehension to be a cure worse than the disease.
- theothermkn 13y agoI'm completely comfortable having a set of conversational values different from yours. I want people to engage critically with the meanings of people's utterances, whereas you are content to let them proceed rhetorically by exploiting on equivocations of the definitions of the words in the sentences. Also, it seems to me that you're only against explicit shaming, as your closing remarks, situating my behavior as worse than the disease, is obviously, if impotently, meant to shame me implicitly. I hear your criticism, and I want to make very clear to you that I reject it on its schoolmarmy face. That said, I hope your involvement in discussion on HN develops into something that interests me and other interesting people here, despite the lack of promise shown so far. Thank you for the downvote!