4 ms·
Let's rephrase: why would glass be any different than a doctor's normal glasses? If it's not, then are you just saying "we should probably treat this like thei
by jessriedel 13y ago
Let's rephrase: why would glass be any different than a doctor's normal glasses? If it's not, then are you just saying "we should probably treat this like their glasses, i.e. do research but currently do nothing special in a clinical setting"?
- Fomite 13y agoPossibly harder to clean than normal glasses - I'm not worried about frying the electronics in my glasses. That's the only difference I can think of, but it's a major one. Additionally, if they're being used heavily by people not used to wearing glasses, the frequency of touching them is probably higher.
- jessriedel 13y agoSo, essentially no change worth talking about. Look, I get the idea of "Hey, here's something new, it could change something in a bad way, so lets test it." Fine, I hope someone does that. But the fact that these kind of concerns are the first thing that come to people's mind and make it to the top of this thread means the discussion is bad. Every time someone mentions something revolutionary like a self-driving car, we could spend the discussion talking about that super unusual situation when the self-driving car is more dangerous than a normal one. Or when Amazon starts drone deliveries would could imagine that one time it crash and kills a dog. But this is just a distraction.
- Fomite 13y ago> So, essentially no change worth talking about. Umm...depends on how hard it is to clean. Something we don't know the answer to. I can hose down my glasses with clorhexidine, they're entirely inert. Can I do that with a Google Glass? Does interacting with your glasses as an information gathering tool change usage patterns - for better or ill? You can't say there's no change worth talking about until you actually do the study. Not even a particularly hard study at that. > Look, I get the idea of "Hey, here's something new, it could change something in a bad way, so lets test it." Fine, I hope someone does that. But the fact that these kind of concerns are the first thing that come to people's mind and make it to the top of this thread means the discussion is bad. Every time someone mentions something revolutionary like a self-driving car, we could spend the discussion talking about that super unusual situation when the self-driving car is more dangerous than a normal one. Or when Amazon starts drone deliveries would could imagine that one time it crash and kills a dog. But this is just a distraction. First off, I was like the first or second poster on the thread - that it got a lot of comments is possibly just because it was there. Second, I'm an infectious disease epidemiologist with a particular interest in hospital infection control, especially surface contamination mediated transmission. Asking questions like this is my job.
- jessriedel 13y ago> Umm...depends on how hard it is to clean. Something we don't know the answer to. We don't know whether the new curved cell phone screens will harbor more bacteria either. And we don't know if increased close-range tablet usage by doctors will subtlety make them want to focus less closely on patient sores. And of course we can make strong physics argument about why wifi is non-ionizing and so doesn't cause DNA damage....but couldn't the extra heat in the room increase bacterial growth? > Second, I'm an infectious disease epidemiologist with a particular interest in hospital infection control, especially surface contamination mediated transmission. Asking questions like this is my job. This isn't a personal attack, I'm explaining why I don't think this is particularly valuable to the thread.
- eric_h 13y agoI'm willing to bet Google Glass has a lot more nooks and crannies for the little bugs to hide than a normal pair of eyeglasses.
- jessriedel 13y agoYea, and smartphone have a lot fewer nooks than traditional cell phones since they have no keys. Better do a study to see if we should recommend that all doctors upgrade from their old Nokia!
- Fomite 13y ago> Yea, and smartphone have a lot fewer nooks than traditional cell phones since they have no keys. Better do a study to see if we should recommend that all doctors upgrade from their old Nokia! Um...trying to figure out what to do about smartphones and the contaminants they carry is a very active area of discussion in infection control right now.
- eric_h 13y agoYes, but you can not use a smart phone while treating patients. If you're using Google Glass, you can't really not use it, especially if the reason you're wearing it is to help patients. I do believe this is a solvable problem (as do the people working on it, I'd imagine), but it hasn't been solved yet. Perhaps a sealant on the device plus a cleaning regimen will do the trick, but right now I'd put google glass somewhere near neckties (glad that that's been largely dealt with), lab coats and, well, pretty much anything that has places that will readily harbor foreign bacteria as a terrible thing to wear from room to room in a hospital. So I guess that given the state of things right now (riddled with such harbors), it's perfectly reasonable to give the technical benefits of glass a try. Maybe we'll come up with some good software that will save some lives. (This may seem like a retraction, but I was really just comparing Google Glass vs regular glasses in my original reply). [Edit] this was intended as a reply to the person the parent was quoting.