4 ms·
> emergently. As a self-styled knitpicker and guardian of language, I had to look it up. The references I found [1] [2] indicated emergent can mean calling fo
by diydsp 13y ago
> emergently.
As a self-styled knitpicker and guardian of language, I had to look it up. The references I found [1] [2] indicated emergent can mean calling for immediate action or urgent, however, it's only in the weakest use of the word. And I find the adverb form of the word another step weaker.
I believe the definition you're highlighting is related to the dictionary definitions referring to "appearing casually or unexpectedly," such as emergent phenomena, which are, arguably slow. These near opposite meanings of the word are unfortunate, b/c people don't really know what sentences using the word are supposed to mean: Is an emergent page one that appeared gradually over time or one that must be attended to immediately?
I find the author's repeated use of the word clumsy and non-descriptive. Exactly the kind of trendy abuse of a word to signal self-entitled and undeserved superiority. To get paged emergently doesn't describe the process of getting paged for an urgent issue, since the action of paging is different from the issue (how was the page button pressed?). To "emergently reverse" blood thinners could just as easily have been stated as "quickly, immediately, or urgently."
Therefore, I would follow your suggestion and drop use of the word as a high-falootin' synonym of "urgently."
[1] http://www.thefreedictionary.com/emergent http://www.thefreedictionary.com/emergent
[2] http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/emergent http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/emergent
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- scoot 13y ago'These near opposite meanings of the word are unfortunate, b/c people don't really know what sentences using the word are supposed to mean' By some strange coincidence, there is a discussion on such antonymous words under the current front-page article on mispronunciation of words: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7384406 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7384406
- blhack 13y agoGuardian of language? That's a bit of a silly position to take, isn't it? I would say that almost everyone who studies language agress that "guarding" language is bad. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_prescription http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_prescription
- keithflower 13y agoDid you mean you are a self-styled 'nitpicker', and not "knitpicker"? ...wink... 'Emergent' is well-established in medicine to mean exactly how it was used in the linked article. There is nothing 'trendy' about that usage (see link to 1914 Stedman's Medical Dictionary definition below).
- jessriedel 13y ago"Emergently" used in this sense is extremely common medical lingo and has nothing to do with the author. It sounds like you're judging this physician based on your own ignorance of the parlance of his field. There's no need to check how Merriam-Webster thinks the general population uses the term.