3 ms·
Wow, I didn't realize that CA had gone that far off the track. I get mad when they don't allow 3rd parties on, so I guess this is just vote from the approved
by protomyth 13y ago
Wow, I didn't realize that CA had gone that far off the track. I get mad when they don't allow 3rd parties on, so I guess this is just vote from the approved choices crap.
- djcapelis 13y agoThe actual system is a bit more nuanced, (or less nuanced, depending on your perspective) which is everyone runs in the same primary, there are no party divisions and the top two candidates proceed to the general election. FWIW, it was proposed and supported by Abel Maldonado, who is a GOP politician, and it was opposed by the state Democratic party.
- dllthomas 13y ago"FWIW, it was proposed and supported by Abel Maldonado, who is a GOP politician, and it was opposed by the state Democratic party." The notion being "this wasn't forced through by the majority party", and it might therefore be more "fair"?
- djcapelis 13y agoA lot of people just assume the democrats are responsible for everything that happens in California. It is somewhat notable when this isn't the case, so I thought I'd mention it. I don't really buy the logic either way, but if someone else wants to, I figure they should buy something that's accurate. I voted no on that one, for whatever it's worth.
- dragonwriter 13y agoIt moves the more important, and potentially decisive, election for all affected offices to the lower-turnout, more-conservative-electorate, and now badly-misnamed "primary" and only has a "general" election at all for an office if there is no majority vote winner in the primary. Basically, most offices (but not Presidential elections) in California now have what is really the general election as the "primary", with a potential runoff as the "general election" if needed.
- dllthomas 13y agoDo you know how often a majority in the primary occurs? In anything actually contested, I wouldn't think it common. Feinstein had almost four times the votes of any challenger in the primary, and still did not have a majority. I expect it would be more common for more local and/or more obscure offices, but I don't know at all just how common.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Do you know how often a majority in the primary occurs? Its early enough that the political strategies and funding streams haven't really adapted to it yet, so I'd be cautious in generalizing either way from the experience so far with the new system. That being said, AFAIK, there have been very few, if any, first round majorities so far in the offices that used to have party primaries.
- dllthomas 13y ago"Its early enough that the political strategies and funding streams haven't really adapted to it yet, so I'd be cautious in generalizing either way from the experience so far with the new system." An important point, to be sure.
- dllthomas 13y agoI'm not convinced it's "off the track". Third parties are allowed in to the primary, they just need to place in the top two to be allowed into the general (just like anyone else).
- protomyth 13y agoIts a good way to make sure 3rd parties never get the first 5% in an actual election or become any kind of factor (spoiler candidate). Its an establishment trick.
- dllthomas 13y agoThey can still play spoiler in the primary. In fact, might be more of a factor there: I'm more comfortable voting for a third party candidate when I know that I'll be able to still have effect in keeping out the greatest evil down the line. Obviously, if ballot access or funds are still apportioned based on general election results, that's inappropriate.
- protomyth 13y ago"They can still play spoiler in the primary." No, since there is a big difference between reducing a person enough in a general to lose versus keeping them from being one of the top two. "Obviously, if ballot access or funds are still apportioned based on general election results, that's inappropriate." Which they would be. Plus, party collusion that happens (see federal election commission) pretty much locks a third party out of the general.
- dllthomas 13y ago"No, since there is a big difference between reducing a person enough in a general to lose versus keeping them from being one of the top two." In 2012, keeping Emken from being in the top two in the primary would have required removing 278,800 votes. Giving Emken the victory in the primary would have required removing 3,098,000 votes. To the degree that this is typical, I would say that there is a big difference but it favors spoilers. "Which they would be." What do you mean "would be"? This isn't hypothetical - is that the case in CA or isn't it? If it is, then it's a strong objection. If it isn't then it's an objection to a system that doesn't exist. "Plus, party collusion that happens (see federal election commission) pretty much locks a third party out of the general." Agreed, I just don't think this is a strong example of that.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I get mad when they don't allow 3rd parties on, so I guess this is just vote from the approved choices crap. Actually, its, at least superficially, the reverse -- California replaced traditional partisan primaries with non-partisan "open primaries". Under the old partisan primary system, the general election featured the winners of the partisan primaries plus qualified non-party candidates, under the new non-partisan primary system the "primary" is a poorly-named open general election run using majority/runoff, if no candidate wins a majority in the "primary", a so-called "general election" is held which is actually a runoff election between the top two vote winners from the "primary".
- dllthomas 13y agoRight. Now we just need to switch the open primaries to approval voting.
- dragonwriter 13y agoApproval voting is a poor choice for most political elections (its good for non-secret-ballot group decision-making where the voters are people who can opt-out of participation after the election and an approving vote is a binding commitment by the voter not to do so if any of their "approved" alternatives win.) Now, if you said the general elections held in the spring (they aren't "primaries" in the usual sense and shouldn't be called that) should use ranked ballots voting and select the Condorcet winner with tie-breaker elections held in the fall, where necessary, as FPTP elections between the members of the Smith set of the spring elections, I'd agree that might be a worthwhile improvement.
- dllthomas 13y agoI don't agree that approval voting is a poor choice for political elections. I particularly reject any implication (if present) that plurality should be preferred to it. I recognize that ranked methods have some substantial benefits over approval voting, but there are drawbacks. Considering just the theoretical benefits and drawbacks in this context, I would agree with a preference for ranked methods. However, when we consider the complexity (and resulting decrease in transparency) I've come to prefer approval. Even so, I wouldn't strongly object to a ranked method.