9 ms·
Tesla Faces New Jersey Challenge as Rule Change Looms
- CamperBob2 13y agoBig surprise, in a state where you're not even allowed to pump your own gas. If they did allow Tesla sales, you'd have to hire someone to plug it in for you. Electricity is dangerous, dontchaknow.
- uptown 13y agoI'd complain about the not-allowed-to-pump-your-own-gas thing if gas wasn't so dirt-cheap in NJ.
- Bluestrike2 13y agoIf only NJ offered the best of both worlds: ultra-low gas taxes and a state that trusts its citizens are able to figure out how to work a gas pump.
- uptown 13y agoThe reality is, you can usually pump your own gas without the attendants giving you a problem. They may come over and take-over the pumping after you've gotten it started - but I've never has any of them get upset at me for taking the initiative.
- Bluestrike2 13y ago:O I'm shocked, shocked to find that New Jerseyans are capable of performing such tasks. Are you sure you're pumping it properly? :D
- mhb 13y agoWhy would they get upset? They get paid either way.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- CamperBob2 13y agoTry that in Oregon, and you'll be treated like a level 3 sex offender.
- cosmie 13y agoThink of how much better the roads would (well, could) be if the mandatory cost of the attendant was deferred into additional tax revenue, while gas remains dirt-cheap.
- mullingitover 13y agoHaving lived in Oregon (where motorists are put on a pedestal and actually served by gas station attendants) and then California, I don't understand the masses clamoring to pump their own gas. Is this supposed to be a privilege, getting out of the car in potentially inclement weather and messing around with flammable liquids?
- CamperBob2 13y agoIt's nothing but the broken-window fallacy in action. If I didn't want to pump my own gas, I'd pull into a full-service lane instead of a self-service one... but the market has pretty much spoken on that issue. I don't know where I'd even find a full-service lane anymore. There is almost no demand for it in the absence of coercion. (Yeah, yeah, I know, I should STFU and move to Somalia...)
- pbreit 13y agoAnother example, along with cigarette-free establishments, that the free market is not capable of delivering.
- CamperBob2 13y agoSmoke-free businesses are a gray area, because we're talking about an addictive substance. Businesses that refuse to serve tobacco addicts are at a disadvantage that apparently can't be overcome by additional patronage from customers seeking a smoke-free environment. So the government steps in, in the name of public health. I don't agree with these laws 100%, but I can see the argument behind them. Full-service gas stations, on the other hand, are neither prohibited nor mandated in most states. They would exist if there was a market. There's not. End of story.
- JeffL 13y agoI would rather not pay someone (in the form of higher gas prices) to do something that takes nearly no effort, and I can damn well do myself. Who is so lazy at they can't get out of their comfy seat for 2 minutes?
- mercurial 13y ago> Big surprise, in a state where you're not even allowed to pump your own gas. I'm afraid I don't understand this bit (being European and all). Are you saying that not only there are attendants, but that you are forbidden from using the pump if an attendant is not available?
- cjensen 13y agoYes. Oregon and New Jersey both forbid consumers from pumping their own gas. If an attendant is not available, you still may not pump your own gas.
- mercurial 13y agoThis is surreal. In western Europe, you'll find somebody manning a shop next to the pumps, if there is one, and you may have to pay for gas inside the shop, but most pumps take credit cards. I think any lawmaker suggesting that an attendant be made mandatory would be cause for much hilarity. I understand that this is a way for the state to provide jobs artificially, but it's definitely a different way of operating.
- maratd 13y ago> This is surreal. Sure, but we still end up paying less for gas than our neighbors. Don't get me wrong, if it were up to me, this would be gone in a heartbeat ... but it's not the end of the world.
- anarchy8 13y agoThat's correct.
- smackfu 13y agoI liked full-service when I lived in NJ. And the gas is fifty cents cheaper than where I live now. I don't even understand what the objection is.
- SilasX 13y agoI like having a home chef prepare my meals. And it was cheaper for me (opportunity cost-wise) than cooking them myself. I don't understand the objection to laws against cooking for yourself at home.
- maratd 13y ago> I don't understand the objection to laws against cooking for yourself at home. If it was cheaper to hire a Chef to cook meals, I wouldn't understand all the noise about making it mandatory either. Bad analogy. If you want ammunition, I'll give you the following. Having an attendant pump your gas sucks because: 1. They screw up what type of fuel you want. Or how much of it. 2. When you yell at them to fix it, they have no idea what you're saying, because they don't speak English. 3. At a busy station, you have to wait for five minutes for them to even get to you. 4. And then you have to wait for another five minutes for them to come back and finish off. 5. If you have the tag you use to pay for gas on your keys ... well you have to hand your keys to a stranger. Same with a credit card, when you could have simply swiped yourself. I can go on, but really, at the end of the day, this isn't a big deal. There are far worse things to complain about.
- SilasX 13y ago>If it was cheaper to hire a Chef to cook meals But my point is that it is indeed cheaper to hire a chef to cook meals -- in some cases, but that doesn't justify making it mandatory. You're taking, as given, the claim that attended fuel pumping is cheaper -- but that's only true sometimes, just like with the home chef, especially if (as in my ignorant aristocrat example) you factor in opportunity costs, which was the point. When people insist that attended fuel is cheaper in terms of sticker price ... well, that's dubious, but let's assume, for whatever reason, it is (maybe there are insurance savings?). It still has a higher opportunity cost for several reasons, many of which you just listed.
- grecy 13y agoNot a single country from Mexico to Argentina lets you pump your own gas. When I got back from my 2 year Alaska->Argentina drive I genuinely had to stop and think about what I was doing, unsure of how to proceed. It was a great novelty :)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 13y agoI'm prepared to entertain a defense of a ban on direct-to-consumer auto sales but have not yet seen a compelling one. Did such a ban make sense in the past?
- protomyth 13y agoHere are two interesting papers: http://www.justice.gov/atr/public/eag/246374.pdf http://www.justice.gov/atr/public/eag/246374.pdf http://faculty.som.yale.edu/FionaScottMorton/documents/StateFranchiseLawsDealerTerminationsandtheAutoCrisis.pdf http://faculty.som.yale.edu/FionaScottMorton/documents/State... My only comment is that if Tesla gets to do direct selling then Ford should also be allowed.
- bryanlarsen 13y agoDealerships generally have exclusive rights to a region. In a state with these laws, this exclusivity may have been implicit rather than explicitly in the contract, which does make things tricky.
- protomyth 13y agoIf Ford was forced into dealerships then any relief for Tesla should include relief for Ford, etc.
- pbreit 13y agoI could sorta see that at car price points there could be some structural advantages for the manufacturers over the dealers that might benefit from some protection. But it does seem like little more than local political power here in 2014 USA.
- protomyth 13y agoIf the law were changed overnight so the manufactures could sell direct, then I would expect the number of surviving dealerships to be very low. I would imagine it would be dealers in used and exotic cars that survive or rural areas that do multiple manufactures. It is a local power thing, and I don't agree with it, but I also don't think anyone should get an unfair advantage just because they are new. That doesn't promote competition.
- timdorr 13y agoI can understand things like the Three Tier System for alcohol because that is an addictive substance that can cause serious harm if improperly used. But why is this same logic in any way applicable to automobiles? They want to impose a required distribution layer between the manufacturers and the consumer. Enforced middlemen. Imagine if that applied to the startup world: "Oh hey, you want to buy this SaaS product I built? Well, you can't sign up on my site, you'll have to buy from one of my SaaS distributors." Madness.
- jcampbell1 13y agoFranchise law has a long history built around some truly abusive things done by the manufacturer/parent company. I don't think this is going to be a big deal. If you own a fleet of cars (think rental car company), you can't technically buy from a manufacturer, but the standard loophole is the negotiations happen with the manufacturer, and the local dealer is the official seller and the dealer gets something like $75/car. Tesla should have no problem setting up a similar arrangement.
- Meekro 13y agoHave you ever shopped for high-end routers, like Juniper or Fortigate? For some reason they absolutely refuse to sell directly, and force you to go through one of those stupid resellers that don't even understand the product they're reselling. Ask the resellers any non-trivial questions, and they forward it back to their contact at the main company. Never understood that.
- jurjenh 13y agoThere's a relationship management issue there somewhere - supporting one-off small volume sales has a definite cost at some point - someone needs to process and fill the order. Limiting sales to "big" customers means you can spend less time dealing with all the order processes and focus more on a decent product (or decent profits, wherever the focus may lie)
- Meekro 13y ago
- knodi 13y agoDirect sales should be opened up to all car manufacturers not just Tesla. Tesla is no exception, if GM isn't allowed to do direct sale Tesla shouldn't be able to as well.
- atom-morgan 13y agoRather than worry about whether Tesla is doing something that GM can't, you should be focusing on why Tesla is being stopped for doing this in the first place. It's in the interest of protecting jobs of automotive dealers in an industry Tesla is disrupting. Nothing more.
- cpwright 13y agoIf GM wants to do direct sales, they should buy out the franchisee. Tesla never sold away its franchise rights, so should be allowed to sell direct.
- ctdonath 13y agoAllowed? Question is: by what delegated power does the government have any say in the matter?
- gamblor956 13y agoThe power to regulate commerce at the appropriate level (in a federal system; in non-federal systems this distinction is meaningless), which has been a traditional power of government since the dawn of history.
- runewell 13y agoIt's pretty sad when you're not allowed to sell your product to your customer. If car dealerships provide such a valuable service then they should survive on their own merits and not have to exist parasitically through legislation.
- atom-morgan 13y agoThank you! I'm surprised more people aren't able to pick up on how suspicious it is for the government to make it illegal to avoid a 3rd party.
- ctdonath 13y agoGo read the Supreme Court's ruling in Raich. Upshot: they ruled a violent raid on a terminally ill old lady's home was legal because her home-grown state-legal doctor-monitored half-dozen pot plants decreased demand for illegal interstate commerce. If they want something illegal, they'll torture the law until it agrees.
- windsurfer 13y agoWhile I agree that selling something as straightforward as cars need not have a middle-man, I could see how some industries might want a gatekeeper such as pharmacists.
- stormbrew 13y agoIt's a good thing the Republicans are around to fight for free enterprise and a friction-free market! ... Oh wait.
- protomyth 13y agoBoth parties take money from auto-dealers, and sadly "small government" doesn't seem to mean the same thing to everyone.
- roc 13y agoIt's an evergreen attempt to cloak plain-ole self-interest-and-politics in more-noble-sounding attire. (Not unlike "States' Rights")
- protomyth 13y agoI don't disagree with the first part, I do disagree strongly with the "State's Rights" part. The Constitution is a balance and should not be Federal heavy like it has become in the 1900's to today.
- roc 13y agoI have no problem with States Rights. I have a problem with people trying to dress up naked self-interest and practical politics by saying "States Rights". Mostly, transparent attempts to restrict services and rights from subsets of the citizenry. In either real attempts at discrimination, or cynical efforts that are doomed to fail at anything but driving up voter turn-out.
- brown9-2 13y agoThere was an article two weeks ago about a similar effort in NY state which I thought had an unusually revealing quote: Deborah Dorman, president of the Eastern New York Coalition of Auto Dealers, was at that meeting and said Tuesday Cuomo aides told the group the governor would sign the bill if it passes. She said the bill was designed to protect consumers because it required companies to create a storefront in the state and was not directed at Tesla because it sold electric vehicles. Some environmentalists have claimed the bill unfairly targets electric car manufacturers. “Everyone is selling electric cars, it has nothing to do with that,” she said. “If you allow someone to come into the market with no overhead, that's an unfair advantage,” she said. http://www.capitalnewyork.com/article/albany/2014/02/8540876/proposal-restrain-tesla-new-york http://www.capitalnewyork.com/article/albany/2014/02/8540876...
- toomuchtodo 13y ago> “Everyone is selling electric cars, it has nothing to do with that,” she said. “If you allow someone to come into the market with no overhead, that's an unfair advantage,” she said. Being more efficient than your competitors in NY state is apparently an unfair advantage.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- malokai 13y agoAn inefficient business model that continues to thrive due to outdated laws. And that most consumers hate. The government should seek consumer input on this. I'm completely unsurprised that Arizona and Texas, supposed bastions of capitalism, oppose a better form of business.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gideonk 13y agoPlanet Money did a piece on the difficulty in selling cars directly to consumers. Short version: the auto dealers are a powerful lobby group that prevent this from happening. http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/19/172402376/why-buying-a-car-never-changes http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/19/172402376/why-buyi...
- crusso 13y agoTrue, but I think that the genie is out of the bottle on this one. Tesla is way too popular and residents of states that can't get them because of lobbiests are probably going to make it uncomfortable for politicians who don't eventually give in.
- natdempk 13y agoFrom the podcast, car dealerships/dealers were rated "least trusted" and "most painful" consumer experiences. Clearly that is for the benefit of the consumers...
- bedhead 13y agoMisaligned incentives in action.
- velodrome 13y agoThis is just an of desperation. Plain and simple. I don't understand what is so unfair about it. Tesla is the one going into these states as a newcomer, they have an expensive product, they have to pay rent and hire workers. If these franchises want to complain, complain to the manufacturer they are representing. The thing is these franchises don't offer enough value-added services needed justify the extra costs (or their existence). That is why they are afraid. They know this (this is why they have such a bad reputation from customers). Also, cars are increasingly becoming more complicated. These hybrids being built now are so complicated that they require automated tests to be done to detect issues. As technology progresses, these franchises will increasingly rely on the manufacturer for assistance in solving problems that are not simple. I think the real advantage to Tesla is that the feedback loop is faster. They can listen to customers and improve their products faster. Improving the products can further reduce the costs and increase it's competitiveness.
- gamblor956 13y agoCar dealers exist because they isolate the risk of local car sales from the manufacturer. This includes not just inventory management but credit risk management and other business considerations. Business-wise, this is a very good thing. Car manufacturers are in the business of making cars, not selling them. (This is an important, if subtle, distinction.) From a customer standpoint, they also provide a guaranteed location at which the car can be serviced. If you buy a common car like a Ford or a Toyota, you'll have your choice of mechanics. If you buy an import or a Fiat, your only option locally may be the dealer you purchased the car from. As technology progresses, these franchises will increasingly rely on the manufacturer for assistance in solving problems that are not simple. Yes, but if any such problem is severe enough that only the manufacturer can deal with it, they've got a mandatory recall issue, and the manufacturer would be forced to handle the problem. Car dealers usually have the best-trained (and first trained) mechanics for any model of car, pursuant to franchise licensing agreements. real advantage to Tesla is that the feedback loop is faster. In the real world, fast iteration for physical products is not a good thing. You end up turning any particular iteration of the car into a commodity, which lowers demand because buyers will want to just wait for the next iteration.
- Istof 13y agoWhile they're at it, why don't they also block Google fiber since it disrupts a duopoly...