4 ms·
OS X doesn't have that problem when using sandboxed applications. I choose to opt out by installing non-sandboxed applications, but I know that I'm doing so and
by eropple 13y ago
OS X doesn't have that problem when using sandboxed applications. I choose to opt out by installing non-sandboxed applications, but I know that I'm doing so and I don't install non-sandboxed stuff from people I don't trust. I also have much more accessible tools for inspecting the behaviors of applications, should I want to do so, on OS X than Android - I can do my own homework if I have a notion. (I don't expect end users to do so, but the option is there.)
And Android external storage is explicitly not for sensitive, in-the-clear data. Ever. It doesn't matter what Google "should have" done. They documented What Not To Do, and then WhatsApp went ahead and Did.
- jcampbell1 13y agoFor what it is worth, I wasn't interested in a privacy debate, but rather technical advice. I have come to the conclusion after a bit of research, the only way to make this backup work is to require a passphrase, or for the OS to provide sandboxing. Android 4.4 provides the necessary sandboxing. I am sure WhatsApp will use it. I don't agree with WhatsApp's choice to not require a passphrase, but I at least understand their thinking. They chose frictionless backups with the risk that malicious apps would be able to read you text messages. That is not the choice I would like, but it is not a choice made by an invertebrate. Hacker News at times reminds me of this scene from the Princess Bride: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=18ulbI9k5eA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=18ulbI9k5eA
- eropple 13y agoIt is a choice made by someone prioritizing user acquisition over treating users fairly, and there's no defensible argument for that.