3 ms·
Anyone got past the login? Apart from the usual methodological checks, I would be interested to know if they controlled for the gender of the investors. Gett
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
Anyone got past the login?
Apart from the usual methodological checks, I would be interested to know if they controlled for the gender of the investors. Getting more investment if you are more attractive is hardly a surprise, what does surprise me is female attractiveness did not count.
So either we are seeing a genuine, global, cross-society level bias against women (possible), or we are seeing male investors wanting to invest in people they think are like themselves (attractive, successful men) or we are seeing a mislabelling of attractive (George Clooney is intelligent, articulate, methodical and good looking. Matt LeBlanc is just good looking (!)
So if they did what I suspect, got a bunch of male students to rate attractiveness of female entreprenuers and females to rate males, then what I guess is the boys picked the ones with big breasts and did not care if she was intelligent, the girls were more likely to pick "life partner", which includes good looking but also "able to provide".
Weirdly it might be useful to control females choosing "attractive" with their menstrual cycle.
WOw - complicated world I make up at times
- aet 13y agoFrom the paper: Study 2 (the gender study). We recruited a nationally representative sample of 521 Americans (46.64% female) over Amazon’s Mechanical Turk (www.mturk.com) to participate in a study.
- humanrebar 13y agoNationally representative, assuming the entire nation is on Mechanical Turk? EDIT: What's with the downvotes? There seems to be some selection bias built in to the sample. If not, please explain.
- Fomite 13y agoYou can adjust and weight samples. Basic survey methodology.
- sliverstorm 13y agoGetting more investment if you are more attractive is hardly a surprise, what does surprise me is female attractiveness did not count. We tend to infer intelligence to attractive people. "They are so attractive, I know they must be smart too" (subconsciously, of course). So what might that say?
- unreal37 13y agoMy first thought was that "affluent people" (investor types) would choose people most like themselves. And if that means more investors are men who consider themselves decent looking, that means more invested ideas are from men who are above average too. Another thing not taken into account is differences between the "men delivering the pitch" and "women delivering the pitch". Are the people delivering the pitch equally experienced at presenting? Gender is not the only change when you swap presenters.
- jdp23 13y agoFrom phys.org's summary: In their first experiment, the researchers recruited 60 actual investors from the business world as volunteers. They asked each to watch videos of people making pitches for a project asking for backing (from actual entrepreneurial contests held across the country). Afterwards the investors were asked to rate how persuasive they felt the people doing the pitch were, and also how attractive they found them. The research team reports that they found that the investors were more likely to choose the male pitchers over those who were female, regardless of whether the content of the pitch was nearly identical. They also found that the more attractive the person giving the pitch, the more persuasive they were found to be—but only for those that were male. The investors didn't seem to care how good-looking the women were, they rated them as less persuasive than their male counterparts regardless. http://phys.org/news/2014-03-investors-good-looking-male-entrepreneurial-ventures.html http://phys.org/news/2014-03-investors-good-looking-male-ent...
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoHuh? They had someone rate a pitch, then ask if the pitcher was attractive? But then they are asking then same thing - you cannot tease the two apart. THere seems to be a heap of different issues tied up together here, and this does not seem to be an elegant way of seperating out biases from anyone. I am happy to be wrong but I am not getting good vibes...
- Fomite 13y ago> I would be interested to know if they controlled for the gender of the investors Controlling this might not necessarily be desirable. One of the problem with randomized studies is that it's difficult to show they generalize well. Given investing does not take place in a randomized environment, that investors were representative of real investors is far more important than they be controlled for.