4 ms·
>“We don’t host anything, and none of the developers makes any money. There are no ads, no premium accounts, and no subscription fees or anything like that. It’
by meowface 13y ago
>“We don’t host anything, and none of the developers makes any money. There are no ads, no premium accounts, and no subscription fees or anything like that. It’s an experiment to learn and share.”
Famous last words. The Pirate Bay has made the same defense, but companies and law enforcement generally don't seem to care.
I would be shocked if they aren't sued or even prosecuted within the next year or 2. Not that that's a good thing, just that being this open and carefree about it will probably come to bite them in the ass later.
- msh 13y agoTPB had ads.
- belorn 13y agoThe Pirate Bay trial was a very odd one. The law that was used to incriminate the founder was a never before cited working material for relative new law, which described an intention to make it illegal to run a service if it is primary used for illegal purposes. Usage determined the legal status of the site, which is why the prosecutor kept asking if the defenders had known how the site was used. He also used a screenshot of the top 100 list as evidence of primary usage. My first thought was that email servers would now suddenly be all illegal because they are primary used to receive spam. However, the law is unlikely to be ever used again given the very political nature of the case.
- wise_young_man 13y agoThis is however another layer of abstraction. They are not a torrent hosting site, just a simple app for your computer that connects to sites. It's no different than a browser that visits web pages. They just made it easier to find content like that of Google.
- rplnt 13y agoThey are not making any money. They are not hosting any service (or are they?). Their liability is same as any other torrent client, such as Opera browser. It's very different from TPB in these regards. Also, they are from Argentina.
- patrickk 13y ago>"There are no ads..." >" The Pirate Bay has made the same defense" The Pirate Bay certainly makes money from ads, without adblock the site is choked with nsfw ads everywhere (not that you should browse TPB in work!)
- ds9 13y agoMost of the rest of the page is discussions of business models, the merits of 'piracy' (economic/service-wise and ethical) -- but the situation of the developers is the important issue. If there is a legal decision that open-source devs can be held liable for enabling illegal actions on the part of users, there will be a big "chilling effect" on software in that country, and a danger of other nations imposing the same rule. Consider the logical implications. Almost any software can be used illegally. If contributors are subject to liability even though their work is non-commercial and they do not encourage any illegal use, OSS will effectively become subject to a government permission regime, and development will go underground.