3 ms·
Panel Wants Deep Space, Not Landings as U.S. Goal
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoBut it would also eliminate the possibility of astronauts leaving new iconic footprints on the Moon or Mars for a couple of decades. Translated: manned extraterrestrial landings probably aren't happening in your lifetime (unless private industry gets in and reduces LEO cost by a thousand-fold somehow) I've given up on NASA. I love those guys, really I do. But you can't keep changing missions every time a president takes office, you can't spread the pork out to every state you'd like to, and you can't run a serious manned spaceflight program on a shoestring budget. They're totally dependent on public opinion and don't have a clue in the world as to how to capitalize on it. In short, NASA is a political animal masquerading as a science agency. As such, it's not much use for controlling/promoting spaceflight. If JFK were alive today he'd be dismayed. Remember his words? We choose to do these things not because they are easy but because they are difficult. Big missions, big drama, big heroes, big goals for the nation. Now the article talks about sending astronauts to Langrange points! That's going to be as exciting as watching cars rust. NASA needs to get out of spaceflight implementation altogether and become a spaceflight promoter.Write the checks (which it seems to be very good at) and let somebody else worry about breakthrough propulsion techniques. Farm out funding of the International Space Station to the State Department. Time to hang it up guys. You were great back in the day, but back in the day you had a clear, steady,long-term mission. Those days are not going to return.
- idlewords 17y agoYour comment only seems to apply to the manned space program, which is a very small piece of what NASA does.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoNASA today is involved in all kinds of things. Dozens, if not hundreds of projects and programs. As opposed to NASA in its heyday, which had only a few major items in it's queue. Which validates my point: mission creep is what is killing NASA.
- maximilian 17y agoI think NASA is no longer in the business of rocketing people around the solar system. It now actively does and funds science projects to better understand our universe. Almost every project revolves around sending a probe into orbit or deep space with some sort of new sensor to detect some sort of particle or whatever. Should NASA create heroes or science? (or both..)
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThe problem is that we can't ask questions that begin with "Should NASA", even though we keep pretending that we can. NASA is political, and is deeply entangled with dozens of key politicians. There is no one mission, and there won't be one any time soon. NASA's only problem now should be reducing cost-to-orbit through the use of progressive prizes that keep increasing in value each year until a solution is found. This would be a much better use of taxpayer dollars because as cost to LEO is decreased, everything else gets easier too. Trying to push science first is getting the cart in front of the horse.