3 ms·
Roubini isn't laying out the full argument. Bitcoin has low value as a means of exchange currently, but that may change in the future. If speculators are corre
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Roubini isn't laying out the full argument. Bitcoin has low value as a means of exchange currently, but that may change in the future.
If speculators are correct that it may go up in the future, it is in their best interest to bid the price up now and collect money in the future. That would make BTC not a speculative bubble, but merely an asset that speculators have properly valued.
If you want to argue BTC is or is not a bubble, do it right. Choose a theory of money, e.g. Baumol-Tobin. Then come up with predictions about future transaction costs, the size of the BTC NGDP, and the price level. Finally, use your theory of money to predict the value of BTC.
If that disagrees with the current speculative value, you've got a real argument.
(For those unfamiliar with the macroeconomics terms I used, I explain it all here:
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/demand_for_bitcoins.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/demand_for_bitcoins.h... )
- craigyk 13y agowho cares about your fancy pants arguments when it doesn't even pass the smell test? It has a lot of strikes against it: 1) deflationary 2) slow 3) energy hungry
- jpadkins 13y agoworse is better. Also, has anyone done a energy use per transaction comparison to other payment networks? I'd be surprised if bitcoin was really that bad in comparison to Visa or Paypal if you included all the energy costs that go into security enforcement.
- dia80 13y agoSince bitcoin is very new it is genuinely hard to tell if it will be eventually seen as brilliant innovation that was destined to be successful or get compared to the Dutch tulip bubble etc. You raise valid concerns but there are counter arguments to them all so I don't think such a glib dismissal is warranted. From pg's essay[0] The first time Peter Thiel spoke at YC he drew a Venn diagram that illustrates the situation perfectly. He drew two intersecting circles, one labelled "seems like a bad idea" and the other "is a good idea." The intersection is the sweet spot for startups. [0] http://www.paulgraham.com/swan.html http://www.paulgraham.com/swan.html
- yummyfajitas 13y agoSorry that Macro 101 is "fancy pants". You do realize that something failing the "smell test" is just a reason to investigate further, not a reason to go with one's gut feelings over rational reasoning, right?
- james1071 13y agoYou are not even asking the right questions. The most important one is the supply of alternatives to Bitcoin.
- maxerickson 13y agoI think this is easy to overestimate, at least if you are looking at cryptocurrencies. I expect there will only ever be a few networks that have 'high' levels of participation and the rest will all be susceptible to computational attacks (high value networks will attract investment in mining capability and that investment will make it difficult to get people to risk value on smaller networks that use the same proof of work).
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI am asking the right questions. If economic growth shifts from BTC into other coins, then Y (real GDP of the BTC economy) will go down. This will be reflected in the money price level formula.