4 ms·
The CMB is "so far away" that the largest structures that you can think of are still incredibly tiny points against the CMB. We can tell it's not being blocked
by jerf 13y ago
The CMB is "so far away" that the largest structures that you can think of are still incredibly tiny points against the CMB. We can tell it's not being blocked by normal matter, because we know what that looks like. If you want to hypothesize other possible effects, well, join the club; that's a popular cosmologist past time, but bear in mind that in addition to explaining the lumps, your new hypothesis must actually explain the non-lumps, and everything else as well. This turns out to be a pretty big hurdle.
Furthermore, we're not measuring "things", we're measuring temperature. If a "thing" was blocking the CMB, it would do so by being a hotter thing. Thus, a "thing" can't create a cold spot just by obscuring the CMB... it can only create a hot spot, relative to the CMB.
Another place you can see this is in "dark matter" replacement theories. As unsatisfying as an invisible, undetectable particle is to answer the questions about the universe, it isn't enough to just explain one or two subquestions; you need to provide a better explanation of everything we see, including the places where it really, really looks like dark matter is the only feasible explanation (where galaxies collide and the visible matter appears to have gotten detacted from the dark matter halos, as seen by gravitational distortions, which is really hard to explain with any of the alternate theories).
It's "easy" to beat the consensus on one detail; it's proved pretty hard to beat the consensus across the board, even as the consensus is known by everybody to be unsatisfactory in some ways.