4 ms·
Important information that will drastically affect actual usage not provided: - expected and guaranteed lifetime of discs - minimum undamaged read/write speeds
by dsr_ 13y ago
Important information that will drastically affect actual usage not provided:
- expected and guaranteed lifetime of discs
- minimum undamaged read/write speeds
- recoverable-error read speeds
- bit error rate for writing and reading
Let's take a typical small business system's requirements. We have a 2U database with 12 3.5" hot-swap disks, 2 200GB SSDs for caching and 10 3TB disks in a RAID10. We have up to 15TB that we want to archive.
Optimism: we get 100MB/s write speed and a write BER of 10^-15. We swap 30 500GB disks, each taking about an hour and a half to write, and about one in a thousand disks has an unrecoverable error.
More likely: we get 75MB/s sustained write speed and a write BER of 10^-14. We swap 30 500GB disks, each taking close to two hours, and we can expect one in three complete sets to have an unrecoverable error.
Press releases: not quite useful.
- wazoox 13y agoIn the meanwhile, you could grab an existing LTO-6 drive, and archive everything on 6 uncompressed tapes in about 30 hours (much less if your data is prone to compression).
- hga 13y agoAfter building a very very fast staging disk system to feed it. That's one of many reasons I went with LTO-4 and a slower HP tape drive, I can feed it without shoe-shining from one 15K SAS disk that I have Bacula staging to ... and I don't care about how long it takes to do my backups or restores, which is generally not the case for businesses. Back when I made that choice, it was said no single magnetic disk could keep up with an LTO-5 tape drive.
- beagle3 13y agoOr 4x 4TB drives (at ~$180-$250 each from a quick newegg search), at ~15 hours if you can connect all of them at the same time, or ~60 hours if you need to do that serially (assuming 75MB/sec, which I often get - are you sure you're actually getting 150MB/sec on your LTO-6 tapes?) At about a quarter of the price of the LTO tape drive alone -- data can be recovered anywhere for the next 20 years or so (I have tapes from 2002 that I was unable to find a tape drive for in 2007, but I have a pair of 15GB IDE disks from 2000 that I checked last month and are still readable). At $60-$80/2.5TB, ($24/TB) LTO6 does have an advantage to disk ($40/TB) if you have hundreds of TBs to backup. However, because of the cost of the drive itself ($3000), you only break even after 200TB or so. And if your drive breaks (or you need to backup in one place and recover in another, as is often the case with DR plans), you break even only after 400TB or so. Since approximately 1998, hard drives for backup beat tapes on capacity, price, access speed (drives are random access!) accessibility (an external universal SATA/IDE can be bought for $30 or so, but you already have the connections on your motherboard so you don't even need it). I haven't been able to find anyone with a convincing argument for tapes - maybe you have one?
- hga 13y agoI'd be more interested if you made your case with LTO-5 tape; the latest and greatest generally comes at a price premium. I switched from USB 2 external hard drives to LTO-4 (see my other comment in this thread for one reason for that generation, which BTW per the LTO spec can be read by an LTO-6 drive) because I wanted multiple copies of my data in a less physically fragile form than hard drives (something I'm willing to routinely schlep to a safe deposit box). And I'm an old timer, bought my first DECtape in 1978 (sic), because it was neat, and then it became handy when I learned the -rf flags to the rm command ^_^. I'm very used to tapes, how they work and don't, what you can and can't do with them. And while I was flirting with hard disk backup almost had a catastrophic loss (http://www.ancell-ent.com/1715_Rex_Ave_127B_Joplin/images/ http://www.ancell-ent.com/1715_Rex_Ave_127B_Joplin/images/) only redeemed by luck and offsite storage to rsync.net in Denver. I didn't buy a high end, super fast tape drive, rather an internal HP 1760 EH919 drive, Newegg will sell you one at 2,130, but with some bargain hunting you can get for $1,400 easily (we managed $1,200), and Fujifilm and HP tapes (wouldn't trust any others, except maybe IBM but those are expensive) from them are going for $39 to $42 quantity one, you can of course get better pricing if you buy packs or 20 (or more) and/or go bargain hunting, e.g. 35.45 for the first Amazon Merchant I found with a rating >= 96% for a 20 pack of HP tapes. That's for 800GB uncompressed storage per tape. Per my other comment I also had to buy a 15K SAS drive, that was $250 back then (late summer of 2011). And I should note one of the biggest use cases for LTO drives is fast backups for businesses. With of course plenty of $$$ backing hardware to keep LTO-5 or LTO-6 drives happy.
- beagle3 13y agoCase is not much different for LTO 5: drive is a little cheaper, as you note. Media is slower and almost same price per TB. You still need drive redundancy in most setups. And my experience with tapes has been that they are not significantly more robust than drives: they break and die when they fall on a hard floor, they get ruined if heated too much. And an issue that might be gone in the recent LTO era (has it?), but which I met several times: if you need to recover tapes made 5 years ago, finding a usable tape drive for use or sale might be a big problem. The last drive I had I can't connect to a modern motherboard was an MFM controller-RLL drive pair I had in 1987. IDE came shortly after.