10 ms·
> Mr Tyson just said "... prosecuted anyone who dared have opposing opinions to their own." He is talking about the catholic church and galileo, Did he? I was
by mcv 13y ago
> Mr Tyson just said "... prosecuted anyone who dared have opposing opinions to their own." He is talking about the catholic church and galileo,
Did he? I was hoping he'd be a bit more informed on that subject. Galileo wasn't prosecuted for simply having an opposing opinion, but for insulting the pope.
It's a popular myth that he was prosecuted for his heliocentric model, but that's not true; there were plenty of other proponents of a heliocentric model at the time, but they were smart enough not to insult the pope when he didn't accept their model despite its inaccuracies.
- ggreer 13y agoThis is off topic, but I should clarify: The Cosmos episode hardly mentioned Galileo. It focused on Giordano Bruno[1], who was imprisoned, tortured, and burned at the stake by the Catholic church. There's debate whether he was killed because of his scientific ideas or his religious ones, but it's not as if either makes it OK. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giordano_Bruno https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giordano_Bruno
- mcv 13y agoFair enough. I'm less familiar with the Bruno case, and there's no denying that the church did or supported a lot of really attrocious things. It's just that the Galileo case often gets trotted out as an example, when the church was actually remarkably scientific in that case (they didn't accept Galileo's circular orbits because they didn't match the observed positions, caused by elliptical orbits).