4 ms·
Perhaps it's time to finally attack the source of USA's ID theft problem instead of trying to hide the unhideable? This is a problem mostly limited to USA and
by PeterisP 13y ago
Perhaps it's time to finally attack the source of USA's ID theft problem instead of trying to hide the unhideable?
This is a problem mostly limited to USA and just a few other countries. In most places worldwide such an information leak could be used at best for marketing/spam targeting, not for stealing money through ID theft. The differences are mainly in legislation and liability, which then get reflected in policies of credit institutions that make it much less viable and thus much less widespread.
To put it simply, the information that, say, your spouse or mother would know should not be enough to get credit in your name, bill expensive services to you or gain access to your accounts. If some lender gets duped by their negligence to check who you are, then they got defrauded and it should stay as their problem - mostly to motivate them to put actual effort into preventing this.
- Casseres 13y ago> To put it simply, the information that, say, your spouse or mother would know should not be enough to get credit in your name, bill expensive services to you or gain access to your accounts. Agreed. I hear too many stories of ex-wifes opening up credit cards in their husbands' name when going through divorce proceedings. Second to that, I hear quite a few stories of deadbeat parents opening credit cards in their children's name (once they turn 18) and racking up massive debt without even telling them about it.
- josephlord 13y agoThe whole name "identity theft" is blame and victim shifting. It is "bank fraud" or more generally "credit fraud".
- duncans 13y ago"No, you see, it was your identity ... they said they were you." "And you believed them?" "Yes they stole your identity." "Well, I don't know because I think I have my identity, whereas you seemed to have lost several thousands of pounds..." http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E
- mmcnickle 13y agoRoss Anderson sums this up nicely in "Security Engineering": "I write ‘identity theft’ in quotes as it’s a propaganda term for the old-fashioned offence of impersonation. In the old days, if someone went to a bank, pretended to be me, borrowed money from them and vanished, then that was the bank’s problem, not mine. In the USA and the UK, banks have recently taken to claiming that it’s my identity that’s been stolen rather than their money, and that this somehow makes me liable. So I also parenthesise ‘victims’ — the banks are the real victims, except insofar as they commit secondary fraud against the customer."