3 ms·
> I really do miss the US military of the 1940s and 50s, I feel they would have the gumption to put someone smart and weird on that project and really solve it.
by chaostheory 13y ago
> I really do miss the US military of the 1940s and 50s, I feel they would have the gumption to put someone smart and weird on that project and really solve it.
imo They would not have fared batter. Vietnam is the prime example.
The problem is that historically the US doesn't do well in long term, large scale unconventional warfare, especially if it isn't conducted on open terrain. Even if SOCOM runs the show now, overall the strategy is still highly conventional.
Capturing Afghanistan is easy. Holding it every year is the true test.
The humiliation from Vietnam has improved our forces as a whole. However, the problem remains. How do you fight an enemy with little to no infrastructure? How do you fight an enemy with no real fixed base of operations or even command? Maybe the US does know how to win the war now. Winning hearts and minds of the occupied is the key. Unfortunately, knowing how to win and executing a win are two very different things.
- ryanobjc 13y agoInteresting, I said 'solve the problem' but nothing really about capturing or fighting. Define the problem and solution broadly, and better ideas start coming out of the woodwork.
- chaostheory 13y agoOk, one of the biggest problems in that time was the continuing spread of Communism, namely China. It wasn't solved. The global landscape would be far different today if China was never a communist state. Cuba is another example of an unsolved problem.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoHow is the Vietnam war (US involvement 1961-1975) a prime example of the US military of the 40's and 50's? Wouldn't Korea (1950-1953), the occupation of Japan (1945-1952) or the occupation of Germany (1945-1949) be better examples?
- chaostheory 13y agoGuess who developed military theory that was used in the 60's? It was the guys in the 40's and 50's who were fighting conventional wars against conventional foes. > Wouldn't Korea (1950-1953), the occupation of Japan (1945-1952) or the occupation of Germany (1945-1949) be better examples? No, because military strategy evolves from military theory. Military theory doesn't happen overnight. It develops over time from hard lessons which almost always involve a lot of body bags. WWI is a prime example of this. You have outdated strategies and theory mixed with new weapons that no one was accustomed to using on a large scale. The lessons learned were applied to WWII by WWI veterans. I also don't lump 70's Vietnam with 60's Vietnam. We were beginning to develop effective strategies to mitigate the guerrillas. However public support at home was pretty much gone.