2 ms·
For the reasons you said, I don't think that this is a general algorithm they are teaching. May be it is a stepping stone to get to understanding of what divisi
by noobermin 13y ago
For the reasons you said, I don't think that this is a general algorithm they are teaching. May be it is a stepping stone to get to understanding of what division means first and then they'll teach them long division. Clearly this is an inefficient method for larger numbers, so I don't see how this can be expected to be useful as a go-to algorithm for calculating division.
- ronaldx 13y agoI doubt she has been taught to repeatedly take off 10x8s. I find it more likely she been taught that it doesn't matter what she takes off: as long as she gets to the end without error, her answer will be correct. I imagine that she has reasoned that taking off 50x8 is difficult because she doesn't yet have instant access to 5x8 (which would be rare for her age group) but she can confidently subtract 8s without error (also rare). Perhaps she reasoned this earlier and has been consistently using an inefficient version of the method when she doesn't need to. In that case, she will likely be able to fix this herself when she realises. [Edited to add: I interpolate this because I am a schoolteacher who teaches math. It's a big part of my job to recognise what support a student needs: here, most likely she needs 8-times-table support. The method that I describe is well-enough established in the school system that university entrants use it. Of course, it's possible that her teacher has taught her an inefficient method, but that would be unusual. There are bad math teachers in elementary school, but that's not a typical teaching error.]
- noobermin 13y agoThat's a bit of interpolation there. I will admit that we are given very little to work on, just a piece of paper with the algo partially done on it by a child... I'm assuming you think that because of the "10x8" on the side and it could be easily "20x8". It looks like they are teaching it by places, and the 10x_ represents the order of magnitude that is currently being operated, and she was to see how many "8"'s in that magnitude are in the number. That was my assumption, at least.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Someone 13y agoOn the contrary: for larger numbers, it is an efficient method, in the sense that one can expect students to do it. For example, what's the first digit of 1019794644/1457? I would spend a few seconds before taking a guess at 7, compute 71457 to get 10199, conclude "oh, it must be 6", compute 61457, subtract it, etc. And I can make a good educated guess to get that initial 7 because I know 14 = 1/7 (in the same sense that 27 = 1/37 and 91 = 1/11. It helps to know some factorisations of integers close to 10^n). You can't expect all students to do that, and you don't have to. It turns out that, if they just guess a low end 5, they do better than me, because they only have to compute 51457 (for an expert, a bit easier than either 6 or 7, but for them, likely equally difficult), and, from there, already will have simplified the problem. Their next multiplication will be 11457. After 'my' 71457, I still have to do a more difficult 61457. Also, looking at it objectively, it turns out that I do the exact same thing as that student that "isn't that good at long division". The only difference it that that student is honest and that I lie, by writing the answer in a way that suggests that that '6' came to me by some divine intervention, and not by correcting an initially incorrect guess.