6 ms·
This is a cool idea, my wife and I did the cross country ride (Oakland to Washington DC) in sleeper cars and it was a lot of fun. Some great scenery and a lot o
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
This is a cool idea, my wife and I did the cross country ride (Oakland to Washington DC) in sleeper cars and it was a lot of fun. Some great scenery and a lot of time to think. Weird things at the time were the plastic utensils in the dining car seemed a bit jarring, and of course train stations in the USA can be fairly tawdry compared to European stations.
There are lots of things that challenge rail in the US, perhaps the most obvious is private ownership of the rails themselves, as opposed to freeways which are state owned and maintained. That shifts a lot of costs on to fewer payers. It also means the rail owner's trains get priority (in this case freight) so scheduling is quite difficult to maintain. There is also a tremendous amount of bureaucracy and complexity built into the system which I've found resists even modestly determined prodding. As part of an exercise in home schooling we tried to find out what it actually cost to put in the San Jose light rail in order to compare that to what we had learned about the Northern Pacific Railroad at a wonderful museum in Sacramento. All of our efforts to get what I had assumed was just boring public data were met with suspicion and resistance. That was pretty weird.
- syncsynchalt 13y agoTo address one point I saw: US passenger rail has signaling priority over freight, by law [http://codes.lp.findlaw.com/uscode/49/V/C/243/24308 http://codes.lp.findlaw.com/uscode/49/V/C/243/24308]. The law is just not enforced. The US has arguably the best freight rail system in the world, and it seems like a lot of the problems with US passenger rail stem from that.
- saalweachter 13y agoI was actually just looking this up. Judging by the numbers on Wikipedia, US rail freight is about 10x per capita the EU's, while US passenger rail is about 1/10th per capita compared to the EU.
- eru 13y agoI remember the Economist had a lengthy special report on rail freight in the US a while ago.
- Crito 13y agoI don't know if this is true or not, but I have heard that most of the US's rail is unsuitable for passenger travel because it is unsuitable for speeds that would make passenger travel reasonable. With freight it doesn't matter so much since the name of the game is moving lots of things cheap, not moving things fast.
- m_mueller 13y agoSee, there's a simple solution to that as the Japanese show: Build more rails. Their bullet train system has a separate rail covering the whole main island of Honshu.
- nostromo 13y agoI think the biggest challenge to rail in the US is just how huge the US is. Take a common train ride in Europe: Paris to Berlin. You've actually traveled less distance than from New York to Chicago, and it took 8 hours to do so. In fact from Paris all the way to Moscow is much shorter than from LA to NYC. Without some amazing new tech in rail, I doubt it'll ever be a popular alternative in the US to flying (other than intra-regional trips).
- mcot2 13y agoYes, the U.S. is big. BUT if you implement high speed rail in specific corridors it would be quite a bit better than flying. The DC, Baltimore, Philly, NYC, Boston route covers millions of people. It is absolutely criminal that we cannot get trains on this route which have average speeds greater than ~90mph (amtrack acela express). DC to Boston is only ~450 miles. Even if we get to only 150-200mph (which is already occurring in China over long distances) we are looking at only 2-3 hours from DC to Boston.
- mikeash 13y agoI doubt rail will replace cross-country flights, but there is a ton of air traffic on shorter routes. As one example where it's already done, the DC-NYC Amtrak route is quite popular, despite being just as expensive, if not more so, as the plane ride. It takes a similar amount of time, factoring in travel to and from airports, waiting, etc. and is much nicer. There are still a ton of airline flights between these two cities as well, of course, and those could probably be supplanted to a large degree with additional improvements. That's with current American trains, which are painfully slow. Imagine modern high-speed rail between, for example, DC and Miami. It's a bit over 1,000 miles which would take about five hours. That would be an excellent substitute for the plane trip, which is about two hours in the air, but tons of time and hassle at the airports. I have family in South Florida and if such a train existed at something like a reasonable price, I'd definitely go for it. As it is, Amtrak on that route takes nearly 24 hours and costs way more than an airline ticket. I don't see why they get any passengers at all, given that. Seems like 1,000 miles is about the limit for high-speed trains. How many pairs of large American cities are less than 1,000 miles apart and have lots of travel between them? I would bet there are quite a number. Rail doesn't have to solve everything to solve a bunch of things.
- eru 13y ago> All of our efforts to get what I had assumed was just boring public data were met with suspicion and resistance. That was pretty weird. I guess your children learned something. I am just not sure whether you want them to become so cynical so soon.