4 ms·
I posted similar comments before seeing yours. Yes M-B is probably pseudo-science (and of course this poll is unscientific). However, I suspect that some mode
by ds9 13y ago
I posted similar comments before seeing yours.
Yes M-B is probably pseudo-science (and of course this poll is unscientific). However, I suspect that some moderate (better-than-chance) degree of validity has kept people using it all these years.
The MMPI supposedly was validated by assessing personality types independently by other methods and then empirically finding corresponding patterns of answers. I don't think that's viable for the M-B, however, as it's shorter, has been more exposed to the public and probably easy to game.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Yes M-B is probably pseudo-science (and of course this poll is unscientific). However, I suspect that some moderate (better-than-chance) degree of validity has kept people using it all these years. People have kept using astrology for a lot more years than M-B has been around, too. Perceived utility and validity don't always go hand-in-hand.