4 ms·
How do you explain it then? It's good enough for a BuzzFeed writer to get it reinstated, but not good enough to at least verify that it's a real name?
by chris_wot 13y ago
How do you explain it then? It's good enough for a BuzzFeed writer to get it reinstated, but not good enough to at least verify that it's a real name?
- nysv 13y agoTheir policy on this has been pointed out to be bad and absurd so many times by now that I'm leaning towards Hanlon's razor now: "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity."
- crypt1d 13y agoExactly. I for one find it slightly annoying that people use the term _discrimination_ so lightly, even though its quite possible that the reason behind this issue is incompetence.
- chris_wot 13y agoThere was nothing light about how I used it. Even if this was not done intentionally, it still discriminated against her. Sort of like how gender fields with only a Male/Female option unintentionally discriminate against transgender people. Nothing intentional, but still happens - and still discrimination.
- judk 13y agoSince Facebook has now fixed this bug in their UI/database, safe to say it is intentional elsewhere. At least in the sense that "supporting gender fluid users is lower priority than adding more whizzy animations to the UI".
- saalweachter 13y agoHow about "obstinacy"?
- vidarh 13y agoThe two are not incompatible. If your incompetence leads you to implement a policy that disproportionally disadvantages a certain group, you are also discriminating against them. Discrimination does not require intent.
- walshemj 13y agoyou can "indirectly discriminate" if you implement polices that effect a larger proportionate of a particular group. It's why stop and search that targets a large number of young black men is seen as racist. It might be incompetence the first time but this has been going on for such a long time now that that is wearing a bit thin as an excuse.
- judk 13y agoThis called "disparate impact" in US law. Quite a controversial issue, and only getting worse ad.machine learning algorithms grow in power and influence.
- hrktb 13y agoShouldn't it be the other way round ? Google's policy was pointed out to be bad and absurd countless times and they knowingly stuck with it anyway, understanding users were prejudiced from it. Isn't it malice ?
- chris_wot 13y agoYou mean like some sort of malicious incompetence? That's really twisting Hanlon's razor!
- Tohhou 13y agoI will explain it. Google wants personal identity attached to posts on Google+ people Google thinks that people will value what they say when they are not posting anonymously. Some engineer wrote a thing to try to catch obviously fake names, and some kinds of real names, which actually are attached to real identity, get caught in the filter. They didn't target specific groups of people because they hate them ffs. I agree that it's a stupid policy, but calling things which are not really racism racism only dilutes actual racism and victims of racism. "Google+ naming filter thinks American Native Indian style names are not real names"
- chris_wot 13y agoSo in other words, it's incompetence then. Which was the alternative to racism. Which is what I said.
- raverbashing 13y agoA filter to catch "fake names" based on dictionary words I presume. If you do that for names of German origin (with a German word list) there will be hit after hit Google apparently doesn't know much about names.
- calibraxis 13y ago> calling things which are not really racism racism only dilutes actual racism and victims of racism. I don't know your racial category, but people of color frequently mention how white people aggressively like to redefine racism so it doesn't include their own racism. This particular argument is common among them. Because after all, racism is one of those -isms which are a fundamental part of many cultures (like the US).
- ebfe 13y agoThat's really interesting, I'd never heard of this before. Can you give us an example you've heard of a redefinition of racism that would exclude whites from being racist?
- 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]