5 ms·
Ask PG: Why is Bitcoin so severely penalized on HN?
Every bitcoin story gets buried rapidly, and now we can't even post something about Satoshi (goes dead directly: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7364582
Why is that?
- FatalLogic 13y agoMy views are quite pro-Bitcoin, and I don't think Bitcoin gets severely penalized on HN. The community here appears reasonably open to fair discussion, unlike some other sites. I don't know why your post is dead, because I can't see it, so I can't comment on that issue.
- baby 13y agoIf you look in new, all the post linking to Satoshi's comment are dead, my post got killed right when I posted it (so it's keywords that triggered the kill)
- FatalLogic 13y agoIf you mean the story about the real Satoshi Nakamoto's comment on the situation, then it was already posted, got lots of upvotes, and that's probably why your post are being killed https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7358150 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7358150
- maxerickson 13y agoIt's even simpler than that, ning.com is on whatever block list (or at least, many of the subdomains there).
- baby 13y agothat makes sense.
- raquo 13y ago"Satoshi Nakamoto: I am not Dorian Nakamoto" is not relevant to HN (see first paragraph in http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). It could have well been killed manually.
- baby 13y agoApparently it is for many of us: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7358150 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7358150
- DanBC 13y agoPeople flag bitcoin submissions if they have no information or context. I guess some people are flagging Bitcoin articles in general because there are just so many of them and they are not particularly interesting. Some of them Trigger the flamewar detector. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7359084 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7359084 is an example with appalling quality comments. There have been many submissions about the identity of satoshi in the past few days. I'd link to a few but I genuinely cannot use the HN search on mobile.
- Adlai 13y agoIs there some robot I'm not aware of?
- chippy 13y agoThe news about Satoshi emotionally affects a substantial number of readers on HN. Whilst it could be argued to be interesting and relevant, the news item is considered to be tasteless and infringing on the privacy of a member of a technology community. In the wider world, news about a tech personality would be interesting and "in the public interest". Here - it's too close to the bone. Thus I have seen two posts being removed by the OP who posted it, and I imagine that other posts have become flagged. In short whilst I agree that this news item is probably the worst kind of journalism, HN is self censoring, which I find more interesting, as do you OP!
- sireat 13y agoOn HN, general news and human interest stories get buried(usually) and rightly so, as this is not the place for them. Bitcoin gets treated faily on HN as long as the discussion has some technical merit. For example posting comparing coding styles of Dorian and BTC Satoshi, that shouldn't get buried. Similarly, there has been almost nothing about Ukraine on top of HN, because nothing too hacky has been posted just general news.
- brudgers 13y agoLow quality submissions get buried. Really low quality submissions often are killed. Bitcoin is attracting a lot of attention and therefore generating significant blogspam and redundant submissions to HN. If your submissions are not generating interest, assume they are low quality even though it may be bad luck. If your submissions arrive dead, find better sources. The system provides good feedback. It's up to each of us to act on it in ways that meet or exceed the norms of HN. One way is to create and blog original content and then submit a link.
- throwaway420 13y agoA community without some moderation tends to become filled with low quality spam, so I'm not against that. But I think it would improve things if there was some more transparency about which posts were banned, which moderators or people flag posts, why they were banned, etc.