6 ms·
EFF goes to court, quashes patent troll’s attempt to grab donor names
- jfasi 13y agoDon't celebrate. However ridiculous they might seem, defending against legal actions like this takes time, money, and focus away from efforts that will actually drive the EFF's mission forward. Instead of patting the EFF on the back for quashing this motion, think of all the resources that went into this hollow victory, and do your best to replenish them.
- dhimes 13y agos/Instead of/In addition to/
- rayiner 13y agoThis wasn't a ridiculous legal action. EFF raised money to challenge this company's patent, and the company wanted to know who donated to that campaign. Its not like they asked for EFF's donor list out of nowhere. The speech issue is implicated, sure, but on the other side also the right of litigants to know who the opposing party really is.
- venomsnake 13y agoThen they should as like that - is any of the following named defendants donated for this. And probably get an answer. But I would have think that a rule against EFF would clash with some of the fallout from Citizen United and the related cases. IIRC there is right now a way to inject money in politics that are very hard to trace to the source.
- noonespecial 13y ago"Does" get sued all the time these days. Its about time it came around.
- pg_is_a_butt 13y agoand while this was happening, a different court ruled that a blog operator should be compelled to divulge any personal information from an anonymous commenter so they could be charged with defamation. PG IS A BUTT
- gcb0 13y agoisnt this the same kind of thing that allows most companies to hide behind riaa/mpaa?
- dublinben 13y agoThe membership of the RIAA/MPAA is no secret. You can privately donate to an organization like the EFF and not want your name published as a supporter.
- danso 13y agoOn the face of it, and my assumptions that are mostly based on what I know of political donations, I'm actually surprised EFF won this...Yes, these aren't political donations, but if it has something to do with a pending lawsuit regarding something that is kind of political, well, who knows. In any case, I'll state for the record that I donate to EFF and would be happy to be listed among their supporters, any time, any place.
- anaphor 13y agoIt's more that the first amendment is supposed to protect people from having their association with the EFF exposed if they haven't done anything wrong.
- pg_is_a_butt 13y agowow, you're dumb. the right to peaceably assemble in no way implies that you won't be tracked, or have assembled funding audited in the same ways that campaign financing is regulated. slippery slope. the solution won't be found in any court.
- mhurron 13y ago> I'll state for the record that I donate to EFF and would be happy to be listed among their supporters, any time, any place. But not in a way that would be used against the EFF. That is what was being attempted here.
- rayiner 13y agoSo now we agree that money is protected speech?
- mbrameld 13y agoUh oh, somebody didn't read the article! > At the end of the hearing, Cousins said he would be issuing a ruling in EFF's favor. However, he largely won't address the First Amendment and privacy issues brought up by EFF's motion. To Cousins, a simple issue of timing was paramount.
- hga 13y agoWell, the Supremes have said so since 1976's Buckley v. Valeo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buckley_v._Valeo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buckley_v._Valeo
- Crito 13y agoThe implication being that there exists some notion of "we" which has internally consistent and coherent positions? It's really easy to feel superior to others when you construct an imaginary person (typically named after 'communities' and given names such as "HN", or "Reddit") in your head that is the nuanceless contradictory amalgamation of all of the various opinions that you have heard.
- venomsnake 13y agoLoaded question. Quantity have a quality of its own. A small amount of donated money could land an employee in hot water with the employers/family/social circles (which we as a society don't want). A huge amount of money could outright buy an election - which is unhealthy. The first enhances the marketplace of ideas. The second could drown any other ideas. So money should be protected as a speech to prevent repression. Not sure if it is possible legally (even if we ignore the first amendment)
- nomailing 13y agothis is exactly why I would only donaze anonymously using Bitcoin.