3 ms·
> It is easily possible to "guarantee" that /dev/urandom is seeded; just seed it from /dev/random. It's a 1-line shell script, or 10-or-so lines of C code. Nei
by saurik 13y ago
> It is easily possible to "guarantee" that /dev/urandom is seeded; just seed it from /dev/random. It's a 1-line shell script, or 10-or-so lines of C code.
Neither today's article nor any of your comments today (before this one) nor what you wrote a while back makes the statement "the correct solution seems to therefore be that when your program starts you should seed /dev/urandom from /dev/random and then continue to use /dev/urandom".
So, is this the correct option? All everything has been saying so far is "do not use /dev/random, use /dev/urandom", which I maintain is actively-harmful advice and should probably be retracted by everyone saying it: making it into a black/white issue is not just silly but will lead people into a situation where they've made confusing mistakes.
This statement so far seems to be well-argued (if nothing else, no one, including yourself, has provided any argument against it; in fact, you seem to presuppose it in all of your statements, assuming that someone smart enough to realize that this is a problem has gone to the trouble of making certain /dev/urandom is seeded sufficiently, despite all evidence to the contrary):
"What's not fine is relying on /dev/urandom as a source of entropy for your application, without first seeding urandom."
Your version, however, seems to only have one argument going for it: that under load a system using /dev/random might block. If the choice is down to using /dev/urandom or /dev/random, I have argued in various ways that this should not be considered as serious of a problem. So far no one (including yourself) has provided any arguments that I'm wrong except to emphatically restate the premise. Like, seriously: I've now spent hours arguing with you, and you haven't actually made any arguments :(.
I also, however, have stated (such as in the other part of this thread I linked to while responding to your other comment) that I think that there are opportunities for a more nuanced discussion of this. Humorously, the solution I came up with was different than yours (I suggested blocking on /dev/random once to make certain /dev/urandom is "ready") and int thinking about it might not work (it relies on an implementation detail of /dev/urandom that I realize I don't know), which frankly just goes to underscore my argument: you and this author telling people "do not use /dev/random, use /dev/urandom" is harmful advice that should apparently be replaced by "use /dev/random to see /dev/urandom, and then use /dev/urandom for subsequent random usage", lest people either 1) use /dev/urandom in a way where it might be used before it is seeded or 2) hear about this issue and then enact some incorrect workaround.
- tptacek 13y agoNo developer is making a mistake by using urandom. Every Nacl user, for instance, is relying on urandom. Every Golang user is relying on urandom. Those are two crypto libraries with impeccable pedigrees. I don't understand the rest of this comment. You build an argument about I didn't write "use random them urandom". But I did; I just didn't word it the way you seem to want me to have. Specifically, I wrote: "But [the problem is] also easily fixed in userland: at boot, seed urandom explicitly". Developers should use urandom to the exclusion of all other CSPRNGs.
- saurik 13y ago> Specifically, I wrote: "But [the problem is] also easily fixed in userland: at boot, seed urandom explicitly". That is not "use random then urandom": that is "configure your computer differently"; the person who has the job of following that advice is no longer the person working on the secure software, but the person building the computer; it might even be the end user, whom we have absolutely no reason to believe has any clue how to secure anything (including his lunchbox). Now more people are involved, we have reason to believe that these new people do not understand this issue well, and there is a possibility of failure mode. This failure mode seems to only be being defended due to some minor performance loss on startup of a select subset of processes. Can I hope to assume you also encourage people to not use stack protector, because the 1% global performance loss is unacceptable, as clearly we should simply trust developers everywhere to write programs that don't have stack overflows? It is exactly the same argument: relying on someone to do something correctly, someone we have evidence to show doesn't do that thing correctly, because we are afraid of some minor performance cost associated with guaranteeing that the problem simply cannot ever happen. > No developer is making a mistake by using urandom. Every Nacl user, for instance, is relying on urandom. Every Golang user is relying on urandom. Those are two crypto libraries with impeccable pedigrees. And apparently OpenSSL, as stated in the paper that analyzed the wide-spread cryptographic fail that happened a year or two ago.
- tptacek 13y agoNot using urandom has caused way, way, way more real-world security problems than any bizarro embedded systems cold start entropy problem ever has.