4 ms·
For readers who enjoy the general topic of the trade-offs of communicating through PowerPoint, the PowerPoint version of Lincoln's Gettysburg Address[1] by Pete
by tokenadult 13y ago
For readers who enjoy the general topic of the trade-offs of communicating through PowerPoint, the PowerPoint version of Lincoln's Gettysburg Address[1] by Peter Norvig, LISP hacker who is now Google's director of research, is not to be missed. Another very interesting discussion of PowerPoint you can find for free online is "PowerPoint Does Rocket Science"[2] by data visualization guru Edward Tufte.
[1] http://norvig.com/Gettysburg/ http://norvig.com/Gettysburg/
[2] http://www.edwardtufte.com/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg?msg_id=0001yB http://www.edwardtufte.com/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg?msg_id=0...
When I give a public presentation, I use a whiteboard and marker, or a blackboard and chalk. If I were in a really large auditorium, I would use an old-fashioned overhead project with blank transparency sheets that I would hand draw on as I speak. I want my talks to be interactive and audience-responsive, not canned. (I do tend to prepare bullet-point outlines with references on a page or two of paper before I give a talk, and email that out afterward, but I say more than I what I write down, and I respond to audience questions.)
AFTER EDIT (TO ADD ANOTHER THOUGHT):
Just last evening I was at a presentation for parents, at which I was presenting with permanent market on paper pads on an easel, and during discussion a parent mentioned that she has her son open-enrolled in the half-day kindergarten program in my local school district. The kindergarten classes largely use smart boards run by the teacher's computer for instruction, so the little pupils (sixteen in her son's classroom) see a lot of slide shows. The other day, the teacher was telling the class about apples, and rather than bring an actual apple into the classroom, the teacher showed a slide of a stock drawing of an apple. (Apples are available year-round in any grocery store in my town, and cost a lot less than a smart board.) Would you want your children to have this kind of education in early childhood? Wouldn't it produce a deeper understanding of apples and how they grow to touch and cut open an apple while in a school unit about apples? (My school district has a paraprofessional teacher aide in each classroom along with the certified teacher for kindergarten and early elementary classes, so there should be sufficient adults in the room to let pupils touch and see actual apples during class.) This seems like PowerPoint gone mad in primary education.
- mistermcgruff 13y agoHere's a reponse to Tufte in defense of PowerPoint, which was on HN a few weeks ago: http://www.john-foreman.com/1/post/2014/01/defending-powerpoint-against-tufte.html http://www.john-foreman.com/1/post/2014/01/defending-powerpo...
- nswanberg 13y agoWhat is good about the response? What is new in it? The author has two main points: 1) that Tufte had information dense slides in his presentations, and because PowerPoint can be used to show information dense slides, Tufte is wrong, and 2) that since Steve Jobs had forceful product announcement presentations with simple slides, and since Tufte likes Apple products, Tufte is wrong. While I suppose the second point is novel, neither are good. Neither point addresses Tufte's central problem with PowerPoint, which is that the software, with its templates and bullet-point lists, encourages a certain style of ritualistic presentation, where the presenter's conclusions are the focus, not the backing evidence that leads to those conclusions. This sort of problem preceded PowerPoint (Tufte writes about similar problems with overhead projector presentations with transparencies filled with bullet points at IBM in his essay The Cognitive Style of PowerPoint), but PowerPoint inflamed the problem.
- mariodiana 13y agoCiting Steve Jobs to defend slideshows only makes the case for what's wrong with slide shows. Jobs' slideshows were only ever a supplement to his presentation. If you removed the slideshows, the presentation would suffer somewhat (and only a little, if you ask me). However, if you removed Jobs, there would be no presentation. His slides were nothing you could review online later because you missed the live presentation.
- steveklabnik 13y agoWhile most industry conferences assume Powerpoint style computerized presentations, Heroku actually let me use an old-school overhead for their Waza conference last year: http://vimeo.com/61113160 http://vimeo.com/61113160 I really enjoyed doing it that way for once. My handwriting may have harmed the actual content, though :/