3 ms·
If we're going to stipulate fantastic concepts like "uploaded minds" then let's just invent a hyperspace engine too and solve all the problems at once. In the
by snowwrestler 13y ago
If we're going to stipulate fantastic concepts like "uploaded minds" then let's just invent a hyperspace engine too and solve all the problems at once.
In the real world, we want to send human bodies because that's what human minds are. Cartesian duality is a religious/philosophical concept for which no scientific basis has yet been found.
- Tloewald 13y agoUploaded minds is hardly an argument depending on cartesian duality. Arguing that there's something irreproducible about the human brain is quite close to cartesian duality. I am not arguing that uploading minds is any more feasible than a generation ship, but it is at least more plausible than hyperdrive -- based on what we think we know right now.
- mitchty 13y agoI guess I disagree that uploading minds is more feasible. One is more of an engineering/physics challenge, and uploading minds is dependent upon a vast set of unknown unknowns. We aren't even out of the door on the idea of biological computing let alone at the mailbox.
- TheCraiggers 13y agoOne key difference is that we know brains can exist. We might not know the entirety of how they work, but the important thing is we already know they can be reproduced in some fashion. Hyperdrive or any other form of FTL travel is purely in our thoughts. Nothing currently exists that even proves it is possible in our current reality. For all we know we could spend an infinite time attempting it and never achieve it.
- mitchty 13y agoTrue, however a key distinction i'm making here is knowing something exists and knowing how it works and being able to replicate that in another system could be just as much of an infinite timesink. I'd rephrase the "nothing currently exists that even proves it is possible" to, nothing has been observed to demonstrate its possibility. That and things like warping space could throw a wrench into the "we can't travel faster than light". But maybe we can end run around it. Though the same can be said of the brain, we really know we don't know a lot more than what we don't know about physics.
- snowwrestler 13y agoWe have no evidence at all that a given brain can be reproduced. We know that new brains can be made and developed (i.e. procreation), and even then we don't really know how that works. But the post above said "mind" not "brain" which typically signifies that the author draws some sort of distinction between the two. I'm just saying: I don't know of any physical evidence for that distinction.
- snowwrestler 13y agoHuman brains are no more difficult to exactly reproduce than any other piece of matter: extremely difficult. The best we've done to date is a few previously entangled particles. Edit to add: what I'm talking about here is quantum teleportation of the matter of the brain. Typically when people talk about "uploading a mind" they mean that the mind is software running on the hardware of the brain--like Windows running on a PC. I'm not aware of any scientific evidence that the mind and brain can be considered separately in that way.
- Tloewald 13y agoThe question comes down to "could you run a sufficiently accurate simulation of a brain on a sufficiently powerful computer that it could pass for the mind of the person whose brain was being simulated"? I'd say the belief that the belief this is impossible is a variant of the cartesian duality.
- Houshalter 13y ago>If we're going to stipulate fantastic concepts like "uploaded minds" then let's just invent a hyperspace engine too and solve all the problems at once. We don't know if breaking the light-barrier is possible regardless of a civilizations level of technology. Brain uploading will certainly be enormously complex and a fantastic feat of technology, but it's certainly possible based on everything we know. Yes it's possible there is more to consciousness than just the physical brain, but that's such an absurd and outlandish assertion, it isn't remotely worth the time to worry about it.
- cousin_it 13y agoI think you have "fantastic" and "real world" backwards. The Blue Brain project is planned to have an uploaded rat brain this year (2014). Uploading human minds is very likely to be closer than capturing the whole energy output of the Sun, which is discussed in the OP. Though uploading will likely cause so many changes that space exploration will seem insignificant in comparison, see Robin Hanson's "The crack of a future dawn" [1] and Carl Shulman's "Whole brain emulation and the evolution of superorganisms" [2]. In general I think most people don't take this scenario seriously enough, the authors I mention are the rare exceptions. [1] http://hanson.gmu.edu/uploads.html http://hanson.gmu.edu/uploads.html [2] https://intelligence.org/files/WBE-Superorgs.pdf https://intelligence.org/files/WBE-Superorgs.pdf
- darkmighty 13y agoThe Blue Brain project will have a rat brain model. It reproduces some of the responses you'd expect from a real. That's orders of magnitude of technical progress away from what an upload would require. We don't even know for sure if it's physically possible to perform an upload (due to quantum mechanics), much less have a device which can come close to measure a significant part of the quantum state of a working brain (i.e. the technical problems beyond physical feasibility).
- jessedhillon 13y agoCan you point to some introductory reading about the quantum mechanical effects at work in the brain? I've read The Emperor's New Mind but was left with the impression that it was more conjecture than research.
- wazoox 13y agoI'm afraid you fell for the hype. We're still unable to understand the puny brain of Caenorhabditis elegans, or how the bees achieve all that they can do with as little a brain. Rat brain is several orders of magnitude harder.