4 ms·
Feminist Frequency steals artwork, refuses to credit owner.
- therogerwilco 13y agoFeminism? Moving on...
- sisk 13y agoBefore this goes entirely off the rails, lets keep in mind this is a discussion of copyright infringement.
- Zikes 13y agoYep, and the appropriate response should be via the legal system, not inciting an internet witch hunt.
- Bud 13y agoAppropriate? It's not for us to decide that. And the legal system is an imperfect remedy that is not available to all. Just guessing here, but perhaps the artist in question can't actually afford a legal team? Further, if you actually read what the artist wrote, the wording is actually quite polite and gentle. It is not threatening and does not incite.
- Zikes 13y agoOh? Well then by all means, let's all play pretend legal experts and decide the fate of the accused based on this single one-sided blog post. I'm sure that's never gone wrong before.
- squizzel 13y agoThe culprit had plenty of time to resolve this issue, inciting a "witch hunt" will only spark a faster response from her.
- Zikes 13y agoYou've just perfectly demonstrated my point. Accusation does not equal guilt, and there is no reason for any of us to believe it is on the accused to resolve anything at all. Being a copyright issue the author is well within her rights to send a DMCA takedown and initiate legal proceedings, which is all the "spark" that is necessary for a timely and appropriate response.
- hvjvuu 13y agothe femtards are always a problem; never the solution
- rsingel 13y agoI don't know that this is infringement -- at the very least, it's arguable that the use of the image is transformative (e.g. it's being used in a montage of criticism). Just because something is used commercially doesn't make it non-fair use. That's just part of a 4 part test that courts apply: http://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/fair-use/four-factors/ http://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/fair-use/four-factors/ Copyright is intended to make sure creators have incentives to create. Fair use is intended to keep culture vibrant.
- k-mcgrady 13y agoI'm just guessing but I'd assume fair use laws are different in every country. If for example the content creator was based in the UK and the potential infringer was based in the US (and the content was digital and online) which countries fair use laws would apply?
- k3oni 13y agoI agree but also credit should be given where credit is due.
- rsingel 13y agoThat's an ethical, not legal argument. (Unless we're talking about CC-licensed images requiring attribution.)
- jere 13y agoThe part I'm wondering about is that this is a project about criticizing the depiction of women in video games. In the piece we're discussing, however, it's not from a video game. It's a fan art piece tributing a video game. In any case, I'm disappointed in Sarkeesian for not even responding to the artist.
- DanielStraight 13y agoAccording to that site, the transformative factor pertains to transformation which adds to the original work. Nothing is being said about the original work in this case. In fact, the original work is not even being acknowledge as an original work. It is being used simply to invoke the character of which it is fan art. I don't see any way to construe that as "value added to the original by creating new information, new aesthetics, new insights, and understandings" where "the original" is Ms. Smith's fan art image.
- k3oni 13y agoBefore the discussion derails Feminist Frequency is the name of the website who's owner infringed on the copyright: feministfrequency.com .
- jxf 13y agoThere seems to be a major issue with artists having their work appropriated and stolen. I wonder if there isn't a startup business model in here somewhere. An artist could sign up for a service that automatically does TinEye or a Google reverse image search for images that they upload, and then flags suspicious uses for the artist to review. If it's fair use then you can whitelist a particular site. Maybe the software could even do it for you, by learning about the reputation of various sites for this particular activity and automatically assigning risk factors and so on. Right now, it seems like the only way to catch art thieves is to have the coincidence of someone who's familiar with both your work and the thief's work point it out to you.
- normloman 13y agoArtists know how to use tin eye already. But automating the process for batches would be useful. Now here's the question: How many people would pay for this service? Artists ain't exactly rich.
- TophWells 13y agoHow does Tineye make money at the moment? I'm sure there's a business model somewhere that would work.
- normloman 13y agoHere's how they make money: https://services.tineye.com/MulticolorEngine#plans-and-pricing https://services.tineye.com/MulticolorEngine#plans-and-prici...
- panarky 13y agoArtists wouldn't have to pay upfront. They could sign up for free, register their art, then the service could participate in royalties on a contingent basis.
- leephillips 13y agoStatutory damages for willful copyright infringement go up to $150,000 per offense. Instead of complaining to a content thief who obviously doesn't care, the artist should be looking for a lawyer interested in taking this on for a cut. Then the donors to the kickstarter will at least know where their money went.
- supersystem 13y agoExcept that it doesn't seem to be original work. So how are you going to maintain that your derivative work was fair use, which relies on being non-commercial, while suing someone for damages? Especially when the one who "stole" your work seems to have a better case for fair use.
- leephillips 13y ago"it doesn't seem to be original work" You mean it's a depiction of an existing character from a game or something. That doesn't mean that it's not original artwork. I'm sure that would be a relevant issue in court, but that's why we have trials. "which relies on being non-commercial" As other posters here have pointed out, this is not true.
- chrismcb 13y agoHer derivative work is not fair use. So she doesn't need to argue that. And the other person has NO case of fair use.
- diydsp 13y agoThat's not art from a video game. Therefore, it's not an object of the project's critique and is not likely to be interpreted as Fair Use. That is a piece of fan art about a game. The project's critique is of video games, not of fan art. Therefore, the work, imo, deserves no protection. Furthermore, the researcher is guilty of intellectual dishonesty, or is simply ignorant, for portraying fan art as video game art. ....and this topic is wiped from HN's catalog.