9 ms·
Did an F-15 airplane successfully land with just one wing?
- TehCorwiz 13y agoYes, The answer is body lift + speed.
- Retric 13y agoA better explanation is the adaptive fly by wire system used the remaining wing to generate some lift which would normally cause roll however it compensated by using tail's control surface. Combined with thrust vectoring a high angle of attack to maximize lift from the airframe and a ridiculous amount of thrust and you only need one wing. PS: You can also fly an F-15 sideways the stall speed simply goes through the roof.
- mpweiher 13y agoNeither the original F-15 nor the F-15D mentioned in the article have fly-by-wire, which is considered as a feature for the updated F-15SE Silent Eagle. So interesting aerodynamics and mad flying skills, not fancy electronics :-)
- Retric 13y agoIt has an adaptive electronic control augmentation system which while not a true fly by wire system still players a huge role in keeping the thing fly able.
- rayiner 13y agoThe F-15 has a Control Augmentation System (CAS), and would be difficult to fly without one: http://www.f15sim.com/operation/f15_flight_control_system.htm http://www.f15sim.com/operation/f15_flight_control_system.ht.... Fly-by-wire means there is no hydraulic/mechanical control system, and is a relatively new feature. But computers have been "in the loop" with conventional hydraulic/mechanical control systems for quite a bit longer, especially in fighter planes, where the emphasis on maneuverability calls for airframes that are a lot less statically stable and would be hard to fly without control augmentation.
- afterburner 13y agoI'd assumed the phrase "I reconnected the electric control to the control surfaces" referred to fly-by-wire, I guess it refers to something else?
- rayiner 13y agoSee the descriptions of the PRCA and ARI here: http://www.f15sim.com/operation/f15_hydro_mech.html http://www.f15sim.com/operation/f15_hydro_mech.html. When people use the phrase "fly by wire" they usually mean a system where the control stick feeds a digital signal into a computer, which controls the hydraulic servos for the control surfaces directly. The F-15 doesn't have that. Instead, what it has is a system where the stick is connected mechanically to the hydraulic system. On top of that, two electronic systems (the Pitch/Roll Channel Assembly and Aileron Rudder Interconnect) can provide an additional variable control input to the hydraulic actuators, to even out the feel of the stick in varying flight conditions. It also provides inputs to improve the dynamic flight characteristics of the plane: http://www.f15sim.com/operation/f15_flight_control_system.htm http://www.f15sim.com/operation/f15_flight_control_system.ht... (see the paragraphs under "Control Augmentation System.") So the F-15's control system provides additional electronic input to the control services to improve flight characteristics, but isn't totally in charge of the airplane in the same way as a true fly by wire system. For example, the electronics cannot move the control surfaces through their full range of motion, and are strictly reactive to the pilot's stick input.
- rayiner 13y agoThe point about fuselage lift isn't wrong. The F-15 has a relatively lightly loaded wing because it generates so much lift from the fuselage. Which means that the torque created by one wing continuing to operate while the other is destroyed isn't as much as you'd think.
- stcredzero 13y agoRC plane builders have known for a long time, that if you put ridiculous amounts of thrust on something, you can make anything fly. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kNWfqVWC2KI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kNWfqVWC2KI
- foldr 13y agoThe F-15 doesn't have thrust vectoring.
- kitd 13y ago"Passengers may notice a slight reduction in the number of wings" -- Bob Newhart
- arethuza 13y ago"Ladies and gentlemen, this is your captain speaking. We have a small problem. All four engines have stopped. We are doing our damnedest to get them going again. I trust you are not in too much distress." Actual announcement from a BA 747 flight: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Airways_Flight_9 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Airways_Flight_9
- joshrotenberg 13y ago"He's skiing (flying) on one ski (wing)!" - Better Off Dead
- infinotize 13y agoClassic Far Side comic [not my site]: Edit for image leech removal. Not somewhere I can upload an image to my hosting, but google for "far side wings fall off" to view the comic - http://goo.gl/bnWsM4 http://goo.gl/bnWsM4
- fasteddie31003 13y agoHacker News seems to love fighter planes recently. They are pretty cool. However, there is one fighter plane that I absolutely hate everything about. The F35.
- GotAnyMegadeth 13y agoCare to elaborate?
- ddorian43 13y agoprobably beacuse over-budget, too late, tries to do everything, too pricey
- chiph 13y agoAnd under-performs. Frankly, for the type of wars we're likely to fight in the foreseeable future, the most common mission would call for something like a cheap prop-driven plane with a ton of ordnance hardpoints. Take the flight surfaces off, stuff 3-4 of them into a C-17 and fly them to the theater of operations, go to work. But the aviator community would hate it.
- msandford 13y agoOr an A-10 Warthog. It's basically what you described but with fairly robust jet engines.
- qbrass 13y agoIt sounded more like the description of the AC-130.
- infinotize 13y agoAC-130 is significantly more of a sitting duck to infantry-deployable surface to air missiles. They have to be fairly low and fly in slow circles with the broadside facing the target. It would be hard to imagine a better missile target. One was shot down in the gulf war by one such infantryman/SAM and all 14 crew were killed. A-10s can loiter and provide extended ground support, but can come in/leave quickly, maneuver well, use terrain to hide from ground fire, etc.
- smackay 13y agoIt's always impressive to see pilots who are able to recover from seemingly impossible situations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Transat_Flight_236 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Transat_Flight_236 http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/4288383.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/4288383.stm More tales of derring-do that will be a thing of the past when everything is automated.
- FigBug 13y agoThis one impressed me the most: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_232 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_232 After a total hydraulic failure, the pilots still managed to land just using thrust difference between the two engines. I'm impressed anybody survived.
- oasisbob 13y agoThe interview of the pilot Dennis Fitch by Erol Morris in the TV show First Person [1] is one of the most riveting interviews I've ever seen -- would highly recommend it. [1] First Person, Season 2 "Leaving the Earth"
- ak217 13y agoAdd the RA-85563 test flight to the list. http://aviation-safety.net/wikibase/wiki.php?id=122072 http://aviation-safety.net/wikibase/wiki.php?id=122072
- mhurron 13y agoI've always been extremely impressed and awed by the pilots of the Gimli Glider. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gimli_Glider http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gimli_Glider
- lutorm 13y ago"The aircraft's fuel gauges were inoperative because of an electronic fault which was indicated on the instrument panel and airplane logs (the pilots believed flight to be legal with this malfunction)." Dudes, wtf? Unless Canadian regulations differ from US ones, you're not even allowed to fly a single-seater in day VFR without a fuel gauge.
- giarc 13y agoWait... how did the pilot not know he lost a wing?
- doorhammer 13y agoIn the response, part of the quoted story says that he didn't know he had lost a wing until he had landed
- mikeash 13y agoWell, how would he? He was too busy flying the airplane to look, and the wing is well behind the pilot in this plane.
- jerf 13y agoThe fuel streaming away visually obscured the fact the wing was missing. While the linked History Channel video appears to be partly reconstruction and partly stock footage manipulated to dramatize the situation, at least part of it appears to have been real footage as well. There's an interior cabin angle that appears to show the real plane with the fuel streaming in such a way that it becomes clear why the damage was obscured. There's also at least one quick shot they seem to have gotten of the real plane landing, as it is clearly missing a wing at that point.
- OWaz 13y agoThis reminds me of a case study sponsored by DARPA where a plane that suffered significant damage to a wing could still land when autonomous systems took over. Here's a link explaining the project: https://www.rockwellcollins.com/sitecore/content/Data/Success_Stories/DARPA_Damage_Tolerance.aspx https://www.rockwellcollins.com/sitecore/content/Data/Succes... And here's a youtube clip showing a demonstration of the system. A UAV has part of it's wing removed mid-air and the plane manages to land. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dGiPNV1TR5k http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dGiPNV1TR5k
- jobu 13y agoI had no idea there was a skeptics stackexchange site. That's very cool (although not as cool as landing a plane with one wing). It will be interesting to see if this site has any effect on Snopes.com
- jere 13y ago>No warning light was on and the navigation computer worked as usual; (I just needed a warning light in my panel to indicate that I missed a wing...)." Hilarious.
- raverbashing 13y agoMissed a wing is a rare event, but I find it strange that there are no warnings for all the control surfaces that are not there anymore But then again it's a fighter jet, so maybe the "distraction level" is lower and too many warnings means eject.
- deletes 13y agoThea would need a percentage based hull integrity display.
- commandar 13y agoI'm sure he was getting hydraulic pressure warnings, but that doesn't really mean "the entire wing is gone" in most cases.
- dredmorbius 13y agoNotably the Space Shuttle lacked a wing integrity indicator as well.
- throwaway812 13y agoWhy doesn't the pilot eject and let the plane crash? Is the plane more valuable than the pilot's life? (A damaged plane, no less.)
- DaveLond 13y agoAn ejection seat is actually only slightly safer than crashing the plane; the strain it puts on the vertebrae in particular is enough to force the pilot to retire after a few ejections. And it sounds like he was flying over water, which carries substantial risks in itself.
- throwaway812 13y agoThanks for explaining, this is new to me. Sounds like the situation was just less bad than the video makes it out to be :).
- nosequel 13y agoLiving on a fighter base, I met two people who were forced to eject from a plane. One lost 2" of height due to severe back/spine compression, one bounced off the ground so hard he could never fly again due to leg and hip issues. Not to mention, an ejected plane can now go hit some school or office building, whatever causing all sort of casualties. Most pilots would rather just try and survive the crash and risk their own life.
- mikeash 13y agoEjection isn't a get out of jail free card. I've heard it described as being just barely preferable to crashing. There's a decent chance of significant injury and even death in an ejection.
- AmVess 13y agoThis poor fellow did it at supersonic speeds and lived: http://jalopnik.com/5894022/what-happens-when-you-eject-out-of-a-jet-at-800-mph http://jalopnik.com/5894022/what-happens-when-you-eject-out-...
- S_A_P 13y agoPartially being facetious here, but if he were a "hell of a good pilot" wouldn't this landing not have had to happen? That said it's pretty impressive that he managed to pull this off
- monkey_slap 13y agoRemember that the plane he collided with was being piloted by someone else. I haven't found any evidence to suggest it was the other pilot's fault, but nothing points to this pilot's negligence either.
- MechSkep 13y agoKinda disappointed the total emphasis is on him being a "hell of a good pilot" instead of the control engineers who allowed the plane to compensate for losing a wing. There's no way that plane would have stayed in the air without their work.
- rz2k 13y agoEveryone would have been safe if they were on the ground without all that extra potential energy. Maybe it is the engineers' fault that they were in the air in the first place. That said, I imagine being controllable while missing a wing was a side effect of the performance goals addressed with the fuselage's lift, or the design goals addressed with the width of fuselage relative to the wingspan. Flightworthiness without a wing probably was not a goal, though we can assume that many features such as the one-way fuel valves that make it able to sustain inflicted damage were very important to its survivability in this case. It sounds like the pilot adapted his tools and equipment, and successfully used them in a situation they were not designed for. If you develop some innovative software, it may not have worked without the specific compiler you used, but that isn't the same as saying the person who wrote the compiler wrote your software. It is difficult to tell from the story whether landing was something that very pilots could have done, or whether it was a more or less natural response to the feedback he was getting from the aircraft in the cockpit.
- stackcollision 13y agoIf you go back far enough eventually some germ will get the credit.
- surlyadopter 13y agoI don't want to detract from the incredible skill of the pilot, but the success of this event is also partly due to John Boyd, Pierre Sprey, and the rest of the "Fighter Mafia" who shaped the AF policy that produced the F-15 and F-16.
- dredmorbius 13y agoI suspect it's fair to share the credit. Point being that the pilot utilized the plane's capabilities (and his lack of awareness of the gravity of the situation) to land successfully. Wouldn't surprise me to find other pilots who'd failed at that. In the case of many of the incidents reported here, the scenarios have been recreated in flight simulators. In the case of UA-232 in particular, I don't believe any of the simulator pilots managed to exceed the performance of Alfred Haynes. The official NTSB report is opaque on this but suggests simulator results weren't encouraging as far as training to avoid this type of accident: The DC-10 simulator used in the study was programmed with the aerodynamic characteristics of the accident airplane that were validated by comparison with the actual flight recorder data. DC-10 rated pilots, consisting of line captains, training clerk airmen, and production test pilots were then asked to fly the accident airplane profile Their comments, observations, and performance were recorded and analyzed.... Overall, the results of this study showed that such a maneuver involved many unknown variables and was not trainable, and the degree of controllability during the approach and landing rendered a simulator training exercise virtually impossible. http://www.airdisaster.com/reports/ntsb/AAR90-06.pdf http://www.airdisaster.com/reports/ntsb/AAR90-06.pdf
- bitwarrior 13y agoIn thrust we trust.
- gonzo 13y agoKim Campbell landed a severely damaged A-10 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Campbell_(pilot) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Campbell_(pilot) http://www.aircraftresourcecenter.com/Stories1/001-100/0016_A-10-battle-damage/story0016.htm http://www.aircraftresourcecenter.com/Stories1/001-100/0016_... The A-10 is designed to fly with one engine, one tail, one elevator, and half of one wing missing.
- nether 13y agoMandatory A-10 worship post requirement satisfied. Now onto why guns > missiles, and how the SR-71 was really cool.
- melling 13y agoHard to believe that the SR-71 is almost 50 years old and it's still the fastest plane in the world. [Update] For some reason, I can't reply to the X-15 comment, so I'll add the extra info here. The X-15 is dropped from a B-52. There are a set of rules to qualify for the record. An unpowered scramjet dropped from another plane isn't going to quality either. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_airspeed_record http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_airspeed_record
- stephencanon 13y agoThe SR-71 was never the fastest plane in the world (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_X-15 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_X-15). It's the fastest "air-breathing" (i.e. not rocket-powered) plane.
- lostlogin 13y agoDoes anyone know why the reply function breaks sometimes? Or is it a feature?
- saraid216 13y agoIf you load a comment within X minutes, it won't show the reply link. If you click on "link", you'll see the text box for entering your reply as normal anyways.
- kencausey 13y agoI apologize in advance for posting rather far off topic but I am compelled. Did anyone else who watched the Youtube video have trouble following the dialogue due to the 'background' music? It seemed entirely too loud in the mix for me. The fact that the highest quality was 240p means the audio was also low quality, I'm too lazy to look it up but likely 64kbps or less. Perhaps that is also relevant. Not to be discounted is the fact of my age and the fact that I stopped watching television some years ago. Which is the cause and which the effect is not entirely clear to me.
- zandor 13y agoThis is not related, but still an interesting event. The Cornfield Bomber: An F-106 that went into a spin, pilot ejected, plane then managed to recover from spin and land itself. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3M2XZEYqIpQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3M2XZEYqIpQ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornfield_Bomber http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornfield_Bomber
- dredmorbius 13y agoThus demonstrating aeronautical symmetry: pilot landing w/o a wing, vs. wings landing w/o a pilot.
- vaadu 13y agoThank you John Boyd and McDonnell Douglas.
- tzury 13y ago(domestic backing for the story) This is a true story, known for years here in Israel. The pilot, Zivi Nedivi, is a successful business man, has been running an hedge fund (AXION) and todays he's in charge at Cyalume [1][2]. This is the video with the pilot telling the story http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t739hAxWnxM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t739hAxWnxM [1] http://cyalume.com/ http://cyalume.com/ [2] http://investor.cyalume.com/management.cfm http://investor.cyalume.com/management.cfm
- ChuckMcM 13y agoMy Dad (retired air force) also forwarded this to me, which I found pretty interesting. One of the 'features' of the X-29[1] demonstrator (which was exploring dynamically unstable flight) was that it continued to fly in all sorts of 'outside the envelope' scenarios. The part that amazes me though is that any human being can sit there and figure out that adding thrust or doing some other action helps or doesn't help when sitting in a chunk of steel that wants to hit the ground hard. I have total respect for folks who stay stone cold rational in the face of their imminent demise. [1] http://www.nasa.gov/centers/armstrong/news/FactSheets/FS-008-DFRC.html#.UxoSXNuVuM8 http://www.nasa.gov/centers/armstrong/news/FactSheets/FS-008...
- mikeash 13y agoThe thing is, it just sort of happens. It's not some massive effort to remain calm, but rather you just automatically focus. That's how people have described it, and it's been my own experience. I've never experienced anything close to this bad, but I've had a couple of aeronautical close scrapes and there's just no room for fear. Edit: had the same experience in a car once as well. Total focus on solving the problem. Terror comes after.
- DavidChouinard 13y agoI'm a (private) pilot. Many years ago, I faced a sudden engine failure and performed an emergency landing in a minuscule pasture surrounded by a very forested area. It very nearly costed me and my passengers' lives. The plane was without engine for several minutes before I landed, yet that time was spent fully engrossed and completely focused on the problem. I had clarity of thought like nothing I've ever experienced. No emotions — no fear, nothing — just stone cold rationality. Going through the checklist, Mayday call, considering options, etc. with swift and decisive precision. Though I believe the extensive training certainly helped, to this day I'm amazed at the incredible stress response our body has evolved. Even though it happened many years ago, I still think about it a lot.
- noir_lord 13y ago
- 001sky 13y agoThe still @ 3.28-29 is surreal.
- milesf 13y agoAm I missing something? Why is this and other articles about planes doing on Hacker News? I like planes, but I thought this site was about internet startups?
- milesf 13y agoWow. Downvoted. This place really has changed.
- zobzu 13y agothe shape of the F-15 isn't exactly unique. but yes.
- amorphid 13y agoThe F-15 is an amazing plane. It blows my mind that it can accelerate in a 100% vertical climb. I've heard stories about A-10 warthogs landing on one wing, too.
- rosser 13y agoIt blows my mind that it can accelerate in a 100% vertical climb. Not to diminish this feat, because it is indeed impressive, but it's a natural consequence of having a thrust:weight ratio significantly greater than 1. It's also horrendously expensive in fuel.
- jjallen 13y agoFor people that missed the wiki page about the incident: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_Negev_mid-air_collision http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_Negev_mid-air_collision
- tgholford 13y agoInteresting. High speed aircraft can generate enough lift to fly just with the fuselage. Wings are really only needed for take-off and landing at low speeds. You will notice that the F-15 pilot said he landed at high speed, 250 knots or so. The F-14 Tomcat, F-111, and B-1 bomber have swing wings, which extend on take-off but retract for high-speed flight. The F-14’s wing sweep has a computer control mode so that the wing sweep angle can change dynamically while the plane is maneuvering. There are lots of stories about airplanes missing wings. One of my instructors in flight training was flying an F-11 Tiger, and lost both wings during a high-G maneuver. He said that he noticed that the controls got “mushy”. In a lot of jets, the horizontal tail surfaces can angle up or down independently and replace the “ailerons” normally on the wing outer edges. He reported a problem to the tower and did a fly-by. They told him his wings were gone. I don’t know if he landed or ejected. There have been numerous documented incidents where planes have launched from carriers with the wings folded. I know of cases where this has happened with A-1 and F-4 type aircraft. When I was in the Mediterranean, I saw an F-4 land on the carrier with an outer wing panel (beyond the fold line) hanging straight down after a collision with a Russian Bear bomber. I also saw an A-6 land at Naples air facility with a missing outer wing panel as a result of a collision somewhere over the Med. The F-15 video was pretty impressive. It really shows how much lift is generated by the fuselage, and how at some point, the wings don’t provide any lift but are just pure drag. If you have enough thrust, you don’t need any wings at all. But then it’s not an “airplane” but a rocket.
- sushirain 13y agoAlso about this incident: "Nedivi (the pilot) reportedly was demoted for disobeying his instructor's order to eject and immediately thereafter promoted for saving his airplane—which two months later was repaired and flying again." [1] [1] http://www.historynet.com/the-10-greatest-emergency-landings.htm http://www.historynet.com/the-10-greatest-emergency-landings...