2 ms·
Student A took test X and got an 86. Student B took test Y and got a +++. How do you evaluate whether one or both students are making adequate progress?
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Student A took test X and got an 86. Student B took test Y and got a +++. How do you evaluate whether one or both students are making adequate progress?
- sanderjd 13y agoYou trust Student B's teacher to have written prose that attempts to answer that question. Now, how you compare students is a trickier question. But I think a lot of folks don't think comparison should be the primary goal of the education system.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoYou need comparability, otherwise you get into perverse situations like "B would have passed if he took test X, but he got unlucky". You also run into agency problems like teacher Y assigning everyone an A just to avoid whining students. http://qz.com/157579/confession-of-an-ivy-league-teaching-assistant-heres-why-i-inflated-grades/ http://qz.com/157579/confession-of-an-ivy-league-teaching-as...
- sanderjd 13y agoI don't disagree that you need comparability, but I see it as an unfortunate reality that is orthogonal to, and should be very carefully traded off against, actual education. Education is the goal, and tracking student progress relative to one another is merely a means to that ends, and as such, it is very reasonable to actively debate whether it is helping or hindering. That the progress-tracking-based system is game-able is a symptom of the disease.