3 ms·
> testing is the backbone of most school systems at present Any school system for which a state standardized test is the “backbone” of student “evaluation and
by jacobolus 13y ago
> testing is the backbone of most school systems at present
Any school system for which a state standardized test is the “backbone” of student “evaluation and feedback” is completely and utterly broken.
There may be some schools like that, but I hope to never interact with them.
Every school I’ve ever interacted with had student assignments with careful grading, teacher-created tests relevant to the material being studied, report cards with grades or ideally written feedback from the teacher, etc. I would consider those the “backbone” of student assessment. State standardized tests are mostly a waste of time and pretty unrevealing about students, in comparison to actually looking at the students’ work.
- beloch 13y agoThat's not a valid generalization. I grew up in a city that was/is tops in it's province for education. This province is consistently at/near the top of the country, and that country's education system is consistently rated in the top ten world-wide and always well above the U.S.. We had standardized tests in grades 6, 9, and 12. They were weighted heavily towards our grades (50% in grade 12) and were, hence, a pretty big deal. The grade 12 tests also serve the same function for universities as SAT's, only on a per-subject basis. e.g. If you apply to a University mathematics program, they might not care about your results in social studies. Note: A key difference between these exams and SAT's is that curricula in the U.S. are often designed to help students pass SAT's, while the standardized tests here are designed to test the province's curriculum.
- dainla 13y agoIf you're from another country, you really don't understand the problem. Teachers time is spent teaching kids how to pass the test, not teaching kids what they need to know to succeed in life. It is a very broken system
- yummyfajitas 13y agoStudent A took test X and got an 86. Student B took test Y and got a +++. How do you evaluate whether one or both students are making adequate progress?
- sanderjd 13y agoYou trust Student B's teacher to have written prose that attempts to answer that question. Now, how you compare students is a trickier question. But I think a lot of folks don't think comparison should be the primary goal of the education system.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoYou need comparability, otherwise you get into perverse situations like "B would have passed if he took test X, but he got unlucky". You also run into agency problems like teacher Y assigning everyone an A just to avoid whining students. http://qz.com/157579/confession-of-an-ivy-league-teaching-assistant-heres-why-i-inflated-grades/ http://qz.com/157579/confession-of-an-ivy-league-teaching-as...
- sanderjd 13y agoI don't disagree that you need comparability, but I see it as an unfortunate reality that is orthogonal to, and should be very carefully traded off against, actual education. Education is the goal, and tracking student progress relative to one another is merely a means to that ends, and as such, it is very reasonable to actively debate whether it is helping or hindering. That the progress-tracking-based system is game-able is a symptom of the disease.