3 ms·
It could not possibly be more clear that these statutory damages are excessive. How could any court fail to rule that a $600,000 fine (let alone $2 million!) t
by modeless 17y ago
It could not possibly be more clear that these statutory damages are excessive. How could any court fail to rule that a $600,000 fine (let alone $2 million!) to an individual for non-commercial copyright infringement violates the eighth amendment to the constitution? "Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted."
Hopefully the defending lawyers in these cases can stop pissing off their judges long enough to make this blindingly obvious argument.
- jrockway 17y agoPissing off the judge might be a good strategy. If he pisses off the judge enough for him to make a questionably-legal ruling, he gets the chance to appeal and set precedent.
- modeless 17y agoThat's awfully risky for the defendant. If I was the one on the stand I don't think I'd permit my lawyers to risk sticking me with a $2 million fine just so they could set precedent, even if they were from Harvard.
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoIANAL, but this is not a fine, is it?
- modeless 17y agoIANAL either, but I doubt the framers of the constitution meant their definition of "fine" to exclude a case like this. Even if it isn't a "fine" in esoteric legal jargon it fits the definition of "cruel and unusual punishment". After all, $2 million is more than the expected lifetime earnings of an American individual. $2 million is essentially a monetary life sentence. edit: I did some research and you're correct that this doesn't fit the modern legal definition of a "fine". Apparently fines are for criminal offenses and in civil cases like this they're called "penalties" instead. Again, however, I don't think this necessarily applies to the eighth amendment. http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/fine http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/fine
- jrockway 17y agoThe whole civil system is an end-run around the Constitution anyway. The government can't take all the money you'll ever earn, but they can allow some corporate entity to. (Totally different, see! Nobody's rights are being violated!) (Incidentally, the Constitution says "cruel AND unusual" not "cruel OR unusual". So if a cruel punishment is routinely applied, that makes it not unusual, and totally legal.)