6 ms·
Since Europan life is separated from the sky by a kilometer thick shell of ice, could there be an entire global civilization down there we're unaware of? (Since
by stcredzero 13y ago
Since Europan life is separated from the sky by a kilometer thick shell of ice, could there be an entire global civilization down there we're unaware of? (Since they're aquatic, maybe low frequency acoustics have taken the place of radio for them, so we would not have detected them.)
- guscost 13y agoSurely you mean to say "Europan life would be..."?
- TuringTest 13y agoI'm European, you insensitive clod. (Wait, this is not Slashdot. Are these lame jokes allowed here when they are relevant? I know the site is moderated, but I don't know its netiquette rules. )
- napoleond 13y agoJokes are generally not very well accepted here, unless they're being made by someone on the leaderboard and/or they are abnormally witty (although I'm sure it would be easy to find counterexamples).
- rosser 13y agoIt's not that jokes aren't well-tolerated on HN; it's that cheap jokes aren't well tolerated. The humor styles prevalent on other fora, in particular Reddit and Slashdot, are often very formulaic, and folks here tend to respond negatively to that kind of thing. I've seen (and made) funny comments that get plenty of karma here, though, so I know it can be done.
- kbenson 13y agoI find that humor works here as long as it is also insightful, or paired with some useful information. A joke purely for a joke's sake doesn't generally do too well, depending on how serious the topic is or discussion is trending and how good the joke is.
- Udo 13y agoWell, if there's life in that ocean, they're probably not tool builders (otherwise we'd have detected something). But microbes and maybe multicellular life isn't out of the question. It's also interesting to think about if we should count, say, a global population of whale-equivalents as a civilization or not.
- yk 13y agoI would not rule out that they have a way to build tools, assuming for a moment they exist. So earth technology is closely related to fire as a energy source. ( During the early development for smelting.) But this role could be filled by black smokers, or volcanic activity. But further development would of course be completely different, so I think it is entirely conceivable that we did not detect anything.
- Udo 13y agoTrue, it's a matter of definitions. Octopuses also use tools, but do they qualify as an intelligent civilization? Probably not (yet). We assume, because we have little reference of what an intelligent human-equivalent entity might be like, that they'd probably build very complex tools over time as we have. This judgement of what constitutes an advanced life form sadly carries a cultural component. If we encountered our own species at the very beginning of its intellectual journey, would we have labeled them a civilization? Would we have described them as having human-equivalent intelligence? It's tricky. But then we move hundreds of thousands of years ahead and suddenly there are monumental buildings and clever machines, suddenly you can meet individuals with astonishing capabilities, and now it's very easy to categorize them. So if our hypothetical space Euroctopus species is in its early intellectual development, we might not be able to correctly attribute their intelligence. There's always the possibility of that development being stagnant too, and again we'd have a difficult time recognizing that. Therefore, the only real chances at discerning an intelligent civilization would be by either directly observing its behavior or by looking at the capabilities of their tools.
- bennyg 13y agoThe funny thing is, we can only categorize intelligence to the peak and adjacent possibilities of where we're at now. Go back over 100,000 years or more and it would be very hard to categorize us as extremely intelligent beings.
- nnq 13y agoMaybe. But the cool thing about this mission is that even a negative answer will mean a lot (like not finding anything, or finding primitive life forms plus proof that they have existed for very long but evolved very slowly): it would support the theory that the "3 zones" configuration of atmosphere + liquid water bodies + land masses, with any of the 3 zones in contact with all the others, dramatically increases the probability of life and/or the speed of its evolution compared to other configurations. If I were to place a bet, I'd say that the "3 zones configurations" is as important for life's appearance and evolution as having liquid water.