5 ms·
Why Do Decent People Accept Dollars? "You can't ban dollars, you'd have to make governments illegal!" is the all-too-frequent reply to anarchocapitalists who a
by dnautics 13y ago
Why Do Decent People Accept Dollars?
"You can't ban dollars, you'd have to make governments illegal!" is the all-too-frequent reply to anarchocapitalists who advocate for the separation of state and economy. And it's true, more-or-less; while we can prosecute corrupt politicians, there's little we can do to get rid of political structures that are inherently problematic.
What I don't get, though, is why any upstanding citizen would want to help them out.
Like any government-backed money instrument, dollars are created through a system that starts with federalized debt; the usual economic cycle is that the treasury issues a note (realistically an unbounded proposition in spite of 'debt ceilings), and exchanges them with a rich person or institutional investor seeking a percentage return. This note is then exchanged with the Federal Reserve bank, which in turn instructs the treasury to print up dollar bills to satisfy this debt (with interest).
The one unique twist is that, being purely a political instrument, there is no physical limit to this process and because overprinting money devalues savings of the poor (and typically only bankers and the rich have impactful access to the yield-bearing interest) the only thing limiting total economic collapse is how effectively the government can hoodwink the populace into thinking that spending is good for them - so the poor are thrown peanuts in terms of token social programmes while other rich people like contractors and so forth (most recently big pharma and healthcare sector) really get the mother lode in spending (and bankers and fund managers make away with the interest)... But in the united states, a full 50% or so percent goes to the "defense" department and the "defense industry" (read: "war" department and "warmaking industry").
Dollars are, as Smedley Butler described, are, a currency designed to facilitate the military industrial complex. When a guy walks into a place of business and uses cash (or really any dollar-backed financial instrument, such as a credit card or checks), ultimately, 50% of the debt that was used to bring that dollar into existence went to finance a sprawling imperial organization with thugs stationed in 180-odd countries around the world, has invaded no less than two countries in the last decade and is responsible for bullyish diplomatic (and sometimes underhanded) tactics for over a century.
And yet we celebrate when a business starts accepting dollars, a currency that comes into existence supporting a questionable military. We create companies whose mission is helping them trade this dirty money for clean. We ask reputable sites to legitimize it by treating it as just one more money transfer service, like accepting a new credit card type.
It's time for those of us who believe in peace to put a stop to this. I don't suggest making dollars illegal - enforcing such a ban would require truly scary violations of liberty. But what we can do is establish a social norm of treating dollars like the warmongering tokens they are. Don't accept them in payment, and look twice at a seller who accepts them - if you can find a similar business that takes, say bitcoins, buy from them instead.
It won't stop dollars completely - an financial instrument that owes a full 50% of its existence to the US military industrial complex. But if decent people don't accept dollars, it means these thugs and worse will have to finance their morally questionable acts by asking us directly, which allows us to at least have some moral oversight, cutting in to their warmaking ability. And that, by the simple rules of democratic principles that supposedly the US believes in, means that people will feel the cost of war by direct taxation, and fewer politicians will choose to wage wars.
- dnautics 13y agorelatedly, I remember the University of Maryland's student-run food coop (which was actually pretty damn good) had a painted sign that said "we only accept cash because we only accept sustainable money". I chuckled every time I passed that sign.
- LispShmisp 13y agoIt's interesting to look at wealth distribution of Bitcoin: http://imgur.com/Vt7PvbW http://imgur.com/Vt7PvbW (source: http://bitinfocharts.com/top-100-richest-bitcoin-addresses.html http://bitinfocharts.com/top-100-richest-bitcoin-addresses.h...). 4% of users own 95.09% of currently available Bitcoins. I think that as the number of users increases so will value of Bitcoin in USD, wealth distribution will only get worse while making top even richer. Even if wealth distribution doesn’t bother you, consider that part of these users(4%) mined/gathered it in questionable ways(mining via compromised systems). Early adopters gaining large part of Bitcoin for little effort seems silly too. I personally consider this unacceptable.
- joveian 13y agoThat might be the most important reason to dislike bitcoin right now. It is obvious why people who have a public ledger that claims they have a bunch of money would be fanatical about wanting other people to recognize that claimed wealth but not at all obvious what is in it for others. However, even if that is fixed (e.g. some other similar cryptocurrency without that issue) I would add two more issues: 1) The system as a whole, for any possible system similar to bitcoin, seems vulnerable to being disrupted by anyone with enough money (at best this would still cost a fair amount of money, but I'm fairly sure it would cost a lot less and be less recoverable than trying to similarly disrupt (at least most) other currencies). 2) The estimates I've seen suggest that a huge amount of power is going into cryptocurrencies for no good reason. This seems like both a horrible response to global warming and (per point 1) is making the same cryptographic mistake that hashcash made on a much smaller scale. Hashcash seemed like a good idea at the time, but I'm not sure why it seems like a good idea to anyone now. I would love to see more work done on various ways to implement robust local currencies rather than all this effort on trying to create fragile global currencies that suck huge amounts of power. Last I looked there were a few things available but it seems like a lot more can be done.