3 ms·
Hackers don't really have much motivation to seriously go after many sites. Or if they do they don't do much harm. But with bitcoin there is huge motivation. A
by ars 13y ago
Hackers don't really have much motivation to seriously go after many sites. Or if they do they don't do much harm.
But with bitcoin there is huge motivation. Anyone running a bitcoin website has a huge target painted on them.
How do banks manage to make websites without being hacked?
Do they not get hacked in the first place, or is it because they are able to "undo" most thefts?
- Sanddancer 13y agoThey do it by hiring competent people, by following standardized accounting and security practices, by having third party auditing, etc. All those things that companies like Mt Gox eschewed in the name of being able to rapidly push site updates without testing, etc. Yes, an environment with more stringent testing is less "fun," but at the same time, it's a lot more secure.
- ghshephard 13y agoMtGox may also have wanted to avoid auditors and security people poking their nose around and discovering that they weren't actually solvent. The jury is still out on what actually happened there.
- FigBug 13y agoTransactions can be reversed. They leave a trail. The punishments are huge. It's not worth the risk. Hacking a bitcoin exchange has no consequences. MtGox has no idea where the money went.
- goldenkey 13y agoThe punishment part is the key. Hacking a bank is not difficult. However, taking the leap to actually funneling money out, and keeping the trail painted black, is well..life-altering and difficult.
- patio11 13y agoBanks don't make websites without being hacked. They do, however, spend more on technical security for a single week than the entire Bitcoin community had spent on all technology to date, and they have substantial processes in addition to the tech to mitigate risk.
- camus2 13y agoBanks have insurances too,something all these exchanges dont have.No insurer would ever back up a bc exchange.
- rahimnathwani 13y agoInsurance just smooths out risks over time and among different parties. It doesn't reduce the (expected) total losses from events, across the entire industry. Banks have insurance for some risks, yes. They are able to buy insurance for a reasonable price precisely because the insurer perceives that the risks are low and well understood.
- valdiorn 13y agoUnlike Bitcoins sites, you can't clean out the entire holdings of a bank with a SQL injection...
- rodgerd 13y agoApplication security modules in firewall/load-balancers. Rigourous patching cycles. Proper source control. Peer review. Functional testing. Load testing. Unit tests. Layer after layer of validation in every tier (browser, app server, database, middleware, etc). Enforced leave. Background checks. Hiring the sort of people who run and speak at white hat conferences to white and black box test applications. Separation of duties. External reviews. Not picking up every trendy programming framework at 0.1 release. Not building dependencies direct from github and rubygems. Internal security teams. Network monitoring and response in real time. Red teams. In short, all that boring, expensive stuff a large chunk of both the bitcoin and HN community love to sneer at buggy-whip wielding by bloated, overweight entities.