8 ms·
Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft
- ars 13y agoHackers don't really have much motivation to seriously go after many sites. Or if they do they don't do much harm. But with bitcoin there is huge motivation. Anyone running a bitcoin website has a huge target painted on them. How do banks manage to make websites without being hacked? Do they not get hacked in the first place, or is it because they are able to "undo" most thefts?
- Sanddancer 13y agoThey do it by hiring competent people, by following standardized accounting and security practices, by having third party auditing, etc. All those things that companies like Mt Gox eschewed in the name of being able to rapidly push site updates without testing, etc. Yes, an environment with more stringent testing is less "fun," but at the same time, it's a lot more secure.
- ghshephard 13y agoMtGox may also have wanted to avoid auditors and security people poking their nose around and discovering that they weren't actually solvent. The jury is still out on what actually happened there.
- FigBug 13y agoTransactions can be reversed. They leave a trail. The punishments are huge. It's not worth the risk. Hacking a bitcoin exchange has no consequences. MtGox has no idea where the money went.
- goldenkey 13y agoThe punishment part is the key. Hacking a bank is not difficult. However, taking the leap to actually funneling money out, and keeping the trail painted black, is well..life-altering and difficult.
- patio11 13y agoBanks don't make websites without being hacked. They do, however, spend more on technical security for a single week than the entire Bitcoin community had spent on all technology to date, and they have substantial processes in addition to the tech to mitigate risk.
- camus2 13y agoBanks have insurances too,something all these exchanges dont have.No insurer would ever back up a bc exchange.
- rahimnathwani 13y agoInsurance just smooths out risks over time and among different parties. It doesn't reduce the (expected) total losses from events, across the entire industry. Banks have insurance for some risks, yes. They are able to buy insurance for a reasonable price precisely because the insurer perceives that the risks are low and well understood.
- valdiorn 13y agoUnlike Bitcoins sites, you can't clean out the entire holdings of a bank with a SQL injection...
- rodgerd 13y agoApplication security modules in firewall/load-balancers. Rigourous patching cycles. Proper source control. Peer review. Functional testing. Load testing. Unit tests. Layer after layer of validation in every tier (browser, app server, database, middleware, etc). Enforced leave. Background checks. Hiring the sort of people who run and speak at white hat conferences to white and black box test applications. Separation of duties. External reviews. Not picking up every trendy programming framework at 0.1 release. Not building dependencies direct from github and rubygems. Internal security teams. Network monitoring and response in real time. Red teams. In short, all that boring, expensive stuff a large chunk of both the bitcoin and HN community love to sneer at buggy-whip wielding by bloated, overweight entities.
- JumpCrisscross 13y ago>Flexcoin was attacked and robbed of all coins in the hot wallet. 'As Flexcoin does not have the resources, assets, or otherwise to come back from this loss, we are closing our doors immediately.' Traders have a concept called value at risk (VaR). VaR can tell a trader the most they are likely to lose over a given time horizon for a given probability [1]. For example, a 1% daily VaR of $10 million means a portfolio will lose more than $10 million 1% of the time (or every 100 trading days). VaR helps instruct (a) traders to reduce their risk and (b) corporate treasuries to hold enough liquidity. The Bitcoin economy is rife with theft and fraud. This is a risk to be managed. Losing one's hot wallet should never be a lethal blow. If hot wallets comprise an unsurvivable fraction of one's capital (a) reduce the hot wallets' sizes or (b) increase your capital. Will either of these divert steam from growth and profitability? Yes - that is the price of prudence. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_at_risk http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_at_risk
- princeb 13y agooperational risk is usually not included in var.
- JumpCrisscross 13y agoYou are correct - VaR is a measure of financial risk. I was using it as an analogy. Theft from one's hot wallet appears to be a common risk of Bitcoin businesses. Traders use VaR to quantify one of their own common risks, financial risk. Capital is then held against the risk. Bitcoin businesses should quantify and reserve against the risk of theft from their hot wallets. Part of this involves limiting the risk (thinly capitalising the hot wallet). Part involves holding reserves (in cold storage or U.S. dollars). That metric and reserve would not be VaR, just inspired by it.
- Ntrails 13y agoOperational risk is usually managed with risk limits, reporting, dashboards. Since it is difficult to model quantitatively VaR tends not to be very applicable - except as a concept. The 1 in 200 event. The concept of setting your risk limit at a non-lethal amount is completely valid. I don't know how bitcoin wallets work particularly, but simply having no more value stored in a hot wallet than can be tolerably lost (or a way of sharing that risk with users) in a single event seems reasonable. Then just work hard to prevent said loss since it destroys value.
- fourstar 13y agoWith more of these issues happening in the bitcoin world, it just screams of bad PR and self-limiting for mass adoption. I know it was stated that this helps "weed" out the bad apples, but to be honest, I couldn't even tell you who the legimitate ones are and I bet you can't either because it's just too soon to tell. There's an implicit trust for me with banks in that they've been around for a while (even though many have/will fail(ed)), but you get some satiation with FDIC deposit insurance as well as government regulation. Curious what other people think about the public perception of bitcoin right now, and how to avoid something like this.
- FigBug 13y agoThe way I see it, unless you are a speculator/miner, there is no upside to using bitcoin for transactions right now. The risks are too high for almost existence benefits. I understand when merchants would be pushing bitcoin, no fees, no charge backs etc. But what is the benefit for the consumer?
- berberous 13y agoThe reduced fees could be split by consumer and merchant, so that the consumer gets lower prices. Practically though, I agree with you; right now the ability to reverse transactions is probably worth more than any price savings.
- FigBug 13y agoI just ran the numbers for curiosities sake: The average American spends $20,000 on their credit cards. If credit card fees are 4% and the retailer gives half back, the customer saves: $400 a year. To save $400, the customer: - Gives up access to credit - Gives up 30 day interest free on purchases - Gives up 1% back rewards ($200) - Gives up fraud protection - Takes on the risk of carrying 'virtual cash' Of course all these services could be built on top of bitcoin, but that's going to cost money and eat into what little saving there already was. I can't see bitcoin working in retail. Maybe for easy currency exchange between people in different countries it'll succeed. Not sure where else.
- nemothekid 13y agoThis may be an interesting hurdle for bitcoin that I've never really considered. Because the real life equivalent of bitcoin is essentially cash you have to take security extremely seriously. One fuckup and you lose everything. This isn't really like banks where if someone has their account hacked they can have funds reversed if they are quick enough. Even Google couldn't keep their datacenters 100% secure, so how will startups fair against the extremely high security cost? Hopefully sane security measures will become widespread, or bitcoin services may be only run by those who can afford security audits.
- NN88 13y agoNot to be rude...but how are you JUST NOW considering this?
- j79 13y agoI agree. While not bitcoin, I played around with dogecoin for a while (I was tipped about 3000 doge on reddit for a post). Right before Christmas, dogewallet was hacked (where I had transferred my doges to). Some good folk over at reddit band together to work on helping out those of us who were hacked. I create a new wallet, and then submit my info for donation doges. A week or so later, they send me 3000 doges. I didn't realize until I checked my account (a few days after it was sent) that they had sent them. Here's the interesting part - less than an hour after they had sent it to me, those 3000 doges were immediately withdrawn and sent to another address. Thankfully, I was playing around with Doge (so the value was all of a dollar fifty), but the entire thing turned me off. If this was bitcoin, or if I had actual money invested, I would have lost my investment TWICE. I like to think I'm some what technically savvy, but in that moment, I realized I had no clue what the hell had happened. Trying to imagine my parents working with bitcoin...never.
- mgpetkov 13y agoI suggest to scan your computer for viruses, spyware, rootkits ... Today I checked my wallets and they are intact. I also run small mining pool and guess what ... no coins are missing.
- deleted 13y ago
- ketralnis 13y ago"It's like all these bitcoin sites are running a bug bounty without even realizing it.." (https://twitter.com/jjarmoc/status/440927360821764097 https://twitter.com/jjarmoc/status/440927360821764097)
- tlrobinson 13y agoThis sucks, but there's a bunch of things in the pipeline that promise to vastly improve the state of Bitcoin security. There was a really interesting talk today at the Texas Bitcoin Conference by Ryan Singer of Crypto Corp (https://cryptocorp.co/ https://cryptocorp.co/) about "hierarchical deterministic multisig" (HDM) wallets: https://cryptocorp.co/technology.htm https://cryptocorp.co/technology.htm Even exchanges can make use of this sort of technology to avoid holding customer funds for longer than absolutely necessary. I think we'll start to see a migration to these sort of systems this year. Hopefully there will be increasing competitive pressure on services to implement safeguards like this.
- Fuxy 13y agoThere seem to be a lot of attacks lately is this a coordinated attack or are these exchanges just coming clean now? Regardless since everybody's instinctive reaction is to sell/get out now It's the best time to build a proper exchange with all the best coding practices applied. Best thing is you don't have to pay anybody for a security review since the bitcoins are a prime target just don't keep too many in the hot wallet. Then again paying a few security professionals to hack you may be the cheaper option but how many exchanges do you think actually do that?