3 ms·
I understand your point in terms of formal logic (that saying 400k people will die does not necessitate that the other 200k can't also die). However, the initi
by cortesoft 13y ago
I understand your point in terms of formal logic (that saying 400k people will die does not necessitate that the other 200k can't also die). However, the initial sentence that starts the experiment is "Recently, a dangerous new disease has been going around. Without medicine, 600,000 people will die from it. In order to save these people, two types of medicine are being made."
When you follow that by saying "If you choose Medicine A, 400,000 people will die", it is not illogical to assume that they don't mean "oh yeah, the other 200k will also die, too" This isn't a Mitch Hedberg joke.
In these scenarios, we are expected to make many basic assumptions that aren't included in the scenario. We are safe to assume that there isn't an unmentioned side effect of Medicine B that will leave everyone paralyzed, or that Medicine A won't turn the survivors into zombies.
- bittercynic 13y agoAre you referring to this? "I used to do drugs. I still do, but I used to, too." (It's a lot funnier when delivered with good timing than when you read it.) His comedy was very hit-and-miss, but some of it was spectacularly funny.
- cortesoft 13y agoYes, yes I was.