3 ms·
Ummm. Those authors look familiar: http://www.examiner.com/article/bogus-paper-on-roundup-saturates-the-internet http://www.examiner.com/article/bogus-paper-on-
by Angostura 13y ago
Ummm. Those authors look familiar: http://www.examiner.com/article/bogus-paper-on-roundup-saturates-the-internet http://www.examiner.com/article/bogus-paper-on-roundup-satur...
One is a long-time 'independent scientist' and the other is s a Senior Research Scientist at the MIT Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory with a degree in Biophysics from the 1960s.
The nature of the peer review isn't really clear, I'm not familiar with the Journal, but this paper makes my thumbs prick.
- tonyarkles 13y agoGood catch. I hadn't looked up the authors, but their associations had raise some red flags for me.
- collyw 13y agoGood science should be good science independent of the authors interests, no? (Not saying this paper is good science, but I dislike the attitude of dismissing based on who the authors are).
- wes-exp 13y agoSadly, oftentimes it is industrial affiliation that can be the biggest predictor of whether a published work supports one side or another in particular issue. Usually this is due to companies funding their own biased research.
- tonyarkles 13y agoYes, but... I wouldn't 100% judge the work based on authorship, but it definitely makes me think twice when Toxicology research is published by a computer scientist. It makes me wonder even more when that work is published by Americans in a Slovakian Toxicology journal. And when it's published by two people who have published work of questionable quality in the past... I think those are decent heuristics to flag this work as having a higher probability of being flawed. Sure, it's not 100% objective, and all scientific literature should probably be looked at through the same critical lens. I'm not a toxicology researcher, and I don't have time to thoroughly investigate the claims of the work. This is enough of a heuristic for me to say "hmmmm, not going to make any life changing decisions based on this work until there's more data from other people"
- danso 13y agoWow, I'm generally sympathetic to the need for ads on content sites, but that site simultaneously threw up a "play this video to see the story" AND a page-wide Captain Morgan animated add that had to be closed before being able to play the video. To save everyone the trouble, the story linked to by the parent comment is dated April 2013 and links to the Huffington Post, ostensibly to criticize it: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/04/25/roundup-herbicide-health-issues-disease_n_3156575.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/04/25/roundup-herbicide-h... And the original source is this paper: http://www.mdpi.com/1099-4300/15/4/1416 http://www.mdpi.com/1099-4300/15/4/1416 The PP-link's main point seems to be this: "While the paper is dense with biological nomenclature and unfamiliar terms, as well as 286 references, the important thing to realize is that the authors didn’t conduct any research at all. It is a review of recent literature with long convoluted arguments leading up to their points. And this is easy to spot, because almost every other paragraph is full of scientific “weasel words” and naïve references to discredited research." And the blog's concluding line is: "This paper is not just baloney, it is a whole delicatessen!" There's some specific criticisms and innuendo, not sure if it's worth the ads to read, because if the paper was really "bogus", there should be a better update and criticism of it by now.
- stygiansonic 13y agoAnother case where Betteridge's Law strikes again.