8 ms·
I don't see that she stated outright or even implied that LEGO was evil, as such. Just an overpriced, indifferent corporate empire with brilliant, unnerving met
by dTal 13y ago
I don't see that she stated outright or even implied that LEGO was evil, as such. Just an overpriced, indifferent corporate empire with brilliant, unnerving meta-marketing. I would say that meta-marketing is the focus of the article, with the LEGO movie merely being the centerpiece. And I'm really not sure where you got "apparently LEGO is being held responsible for girls liking pink now" - the only reference to pink was a quote from the movie in question.
- facepalm 13y agoShe continues with references to the new LEGO girls world which has no fire fighters and so on. Admitted, she doesn't mention pink, but it has been a recent accusation that LEGO created that pink world without manly jobs in it.
- hrktb 13y agoWell, the page on the "Lego friends"site: http://friends.lego.com/en-us/products/41027-mias-lemonade-stand http://friends.lego.com/en-us/products/41027-mias-lemonade-s... I don't see fire fighters or policemen or construction staff, so her statement (and other peoples argument) is valid. How to interpret this fact can be tricky, because there's still more variety than traditional 'girly' toys I think, but when contrasting this with the "City" line of toys (http://www.lego.com/en-us/city http://www.lego.com/en-us/city), the gender bias is blinding.
- SamuelMulder 13y agoThe Lego Friends theme doesn't have firefighters because it is focused on social relationships, not overcoming conflict. It doesn't have to be a girl vs boy thing (although it is undoubtedly targeted toward girls to compete with other non--confrontational toys that have proved popular with girls), it is just part of the theme. Ninjago doesn't have firefighters either. I think it is great that Lego has developed a theme that isn't focused on physical confrontation. I have three girls who play with Lego and they request a mix of sets. For Christmas, they requested sets from Friends, Lord of the Rings, and Ninjago. My four year old got a Chima set. They don't see it as a girl vs boy thing.
- hrktb 13y agoI'm not convinced on the marketing part. How is a lifeguard post or a ranch more social and less conflicting than firefighters or construction workers ? Now, if I was heavily into buying Lego bricks, I'd also mix from the different sets to have more situations, and my kid doesn't really care if his toys are action figures or dolls.
- facepalm 13y agoI don't think "social" is the selling point. If I just look at "all buildings", only very few of them seem to be about actual work. It's more about having fun in exclusive locations with loving animals.
- talmand 13y agoHow about buying the fire fighter set, if the girls want it, and just don't mention boy sets versus girl sets? You know what "traditional" girl toys are? What previous generations, or "parents", say they are.
- facepalm 13y agoHow is that a valid criticism? It doesn't have firefighters because it is about other things. It's valid in the same way as complaining that a set about fire fighters doesn't have any police men. Please show me what makes the actual firefighters and policemen "male"? I see some figurines with beards, but many without beards - they could be any gender. Also never mind the fact that including many female fire fighters would be a lie, because the real world isn't really like that.
- talmand 13y agoIf I wanted my daughters, or if they wanted, to play with LEGOs that had fire fighters then I would buy the sets that had fire fighters. I just don't bother to say that set is for boys while that set is for girls. One of them loves Transformers and Ninjago, we get her those toys with no mention of boy versus girl toys. I just don't understand what the problem is with needing specially made toys for girls to offset some perceived injustice when they can play with the boy toys just as well.
- wvenable 13y agoThe problem with those sets is there are no female firefighter minifigs included.
- facepalm 13y agoHow would you identify a female firefighter minifig as female? Edit: here is a random LEGO firefighter I googled. What does make it male? http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/61cMG%2BjM8hL._SL1500_.jpg http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/61cMG%2BjM8hL._SL1500_...
- krakensden 13y agoNo secondary sexual characteristics bolted to the torso.
- facepalm 13y agoYou mean no boobs?
- facepalm 13y agoI personally think those complaints about female LEGo are ridiculous. I have half a mind to calculate how much it would cost to buy all LEGO kits that have no figurines at all - probably way more than any average family would ever spend on LEGO at all. Also the question is how do you identify female LEGO figurines? If you add feminine traits like lipstick or long hair, aren't you cementing another stereotype? Or adding boobs - again you are exposing yourself to criticism. I'd say as long as it doesn't spot a beard, any LEGO figurine can be taken as male or female at wish. I suspect the criticism assumes LEGO firefighters are male unless they wear lipstick, because I don't think all LEGO firefighters are bearded. And, as you say, what is the problem of playing with a figurine of the opposite sex? We even bought our son a Playmobil horse with girl tender that came in a pink box. I have yet to notice any trauma it might have induced. Maybe the payback will be in 20 years when his psychotherapist will expose our deeds.
- hrktb 13y agoSorry, I meant to upvote but hit the wrong arrow. As a side point, I found the piece very well written. The author's biases are not hidden, while the analysis stays focused on objective points, which makes it very well balanced IMO.
- leobelle 13y ago> "Overpriced" Legos are priced at what people are willing to pay for them. If they were overpriced they would not sell and there would be no Legos. Maybe you are suggesting that Legos should be cheaper because the material cost do not justify the prices you see, well again, Legos are priced at what they sell at and clearly people have voted with their wallets and have said that Legos are worth greater than the sum of their parts. It would be a disservice to Lego's investors to price them in accordance with the wishes of people who think everything should be accessible to everyone. For-profit companies should responsibly capture all the value they can.
- mindslight 13y agoAll hail the global superintelligence known as Market. From Him all purpose and justification floweth. There need be no other.
- leobelle 13y agoNo, there are clearly real problems with market based economies and issues of social responsibility. Selling plastic block toys, for which there are cheap enough alternatives, doesn't really seem to fit in this picture though.
- mindslight 13y agoYour original comment basically just stated the same tautology four different ways, as if it were the last word on the matter. Besides judging the large-scale results of the system (eg your reference to 'social responsibility'), we're also entitled to judge the small-scale details vis-a-vis our own heuristics, even when they are at odds with a market's state.
- leobelle 13y agoI'm not sure I understand what your point is. I explained why Legos are not overpriced, and made some probably unnecessary judgement statements about why people would call it overpriced. I didn't say Legos are not overpriced because they are not overpriced, I said they're not overpriced because their products are selling. Where is the tautology?
- cynicalkane 13y agoLegos are manufactured to an incredibly high standard. Lego knock-offs just aren't the same; they don't snap together and stay together as well, and they are easily deformed. Source: I was a child once. Later on, I learned Lego manufacturing tolerances are measured in micrometers.
- dTal 13y agoI didn't call them overpriced, she did. I was about to defend her by noting the massively increased price of LEGO sets over the past few decades versus the (I would assume) relatively static economics of manufacturing plastic bricks - but then I googled it and it's all a lie[1]. Guess I'll file that one next to "there were more thunderstorms when I was a kid". [1] http://flowingdata.com/2013/02/07/analysis-of-lego-brick-prices-over-the-years/ http://flowingdata.com/2013/02/07/analysis-of-lego-brick-pri...
- tonyedgecombe 13y agoThis is so true, my parents have my 35 year old Lego that my children were still playing with until quite recently. Apart from a few odd pieces it's all as good as new.