6 ms·
FUD. This is a federal case, and the Federal Sentencing Guidelines (while now discretionary, see Booker) simply don't work that way. 100 years is the potentia
by gamblor956 13y ago
FUD.
This is a federal case, and the Federal Sentencing Guidelines (while now discretionary, see Booker) simply don't work that way. 100 years is the potential maximum he would get if the sentences were served consecutively, but at the federal level, there must be special circumstances to justify imposing consecutive sentences. Consequently, consecutive sentencing is the exception, not the rule, and is almost exclusively reserved for the most heinous crimes, i.e., rapes, murders, or high-level drug offenses. (Note that certain factors can also result in consecutive sentences, such as gun "enhancements" which can add 5-25 years to a base sentence.)
Edit: The above assumes the case even proceeds to the sentencing stage. Several US courts have already ruled that merely hyperlinking is not enough; there must be an additional circumstance to make the hyperlinking illegal. For example, if the information hyperlinked was clearly intended to be protected or private (i.e., Schwartz and the AT&T subscriber data), then dissemination of links could fall within the meaning of one or more statutes for unauthorized access.
A physical analogy to explain why this matters: a URL isn't simply an address; it is a path, and this makes all the difference. A p.o. address, for example, may tell you how to get to someone's apartment but it wouldn't tell you how to get up there if the front door is locked. A URL is more akin to giving someone an address and telling them how to get inside. (And for you nitpickers, in this example also assume that you don't know the person at this address; you simply know the URL.)
- sillysaurus3 13y agoWhy did it become socially acceptable for prosecutors to throw around 100-year threats, though? It seems like the only reason that's not a crime is because they're the legal system. Maybe there should be a limit on the span between maximum threat and minimum sentence, so that 100-year threats can't be thrown around unless the minimum plea is at least 5-10 years. That would make a prosecutor hesitate to employ such a powerful weapon, because the defendant would be more willing go to trial in that scenario, which reduces their chances of landing that conviction.
- etherael 13y agoIt seems like the only reason that's not a crime is because they're the legal system. Of all of the activities undertaken by the state, an increasingly high percentage fall firmly under this definition.
- gamblor956 13y agoIt's not, and they don't. For non-heinous crimes (i.e., crimes that aren't rape or murder) prosecutors threaten the maximum sentence for the "worst" crime charged, and only that number, because any competent defense attorney would immediately let their client know that sentences wouldn't be served consecutively. This is true in most, but not all states as well. (For heinous crimes, the consecutive sentences don't matter; the defendant has already received a life sentence and the additional years are meaningless.) This is also a legal ethics issue, since a prosecutor who fraudulently claims a higher maximum penalty during plea bargaining can be suspended or disbarred. Cops can lie to you--prosecutor's can't. They have sworn an oath (to the bar) to be honest in their legal representations. Prosecutors have been sanctioned, suspended, and even disbarred for being dishonest about sentencing because such dishonesty indicates moral turpitude that likely extends into other facets of their legal work. It's the media that throws around the 100-year numbers by adding together all of the potential individual sentences. It turns out that journalists aren't very good at understanding technology, science, or the law.
- sillysaurus3 13y agoAh, thank you. So does anyone know what maximum threat he's actually facing?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 13y agoTo follow up to ageisp0lis's post (which is apparently now deleted, but linked to http://www.dmlp.org/blog/2013/adding-105-charges-against-barrett-brown http://www.dmlp.org/blog/2013/adding-105-charges-against-bar...), the reasoning behind the 100-year number is: (1) that is the total maximum possible sentence assuming consecutive terms, and (2) it includes 2 other cases against him, not just the Stratfor case. My comments on this thread only discuss the Stratfor case, which is the second indictment of the 3 discussed by the DMLP article ageisp0lis linked.
- deleted 13y ago
- NextUserName 13y ago>Why did it become socially acceptable for prosecutors to throw around 100-year threats, though Because the media has been doing it for 20+ years. The news is more "interesting" when big numbers like that are thrown around.
- rayiner 13y agoWhere did anyone throw around a 100 year number, besides the reporter? When someone is convicted of a federal crime, its the Department of Corrections that will put together a presentence report with a computation of the sentence under the guidelines. To get above that, the prosecutor has to argue to the judge that this case is special and requires a sentence above the guideline range. This is very difficult.
- ageisp0lis 13y agoTo respond to your point, the statutes in question here DO in fact mandate consecutive sentencing. Look it up next time. 18 USC § 1028A, etc. "no term of imprisonment imposed on a person under this section shall run concurrently with any other term of imprisonment imposed on the person under any other provision of law..."
- gamblor956 13y agoI did before I wrote the comment. There are two statutes: 1028, and 1028A. (See for yourself: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1028. http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1028.) Only one of the statutes in question mandates consecutive sentences, 1028A. The maximum sentence for these counts is 2 years for the crime charged. (He was not charged with a terrorism offense under 1028A, so the 5 year sentence is not applicable.) The way this statute is written, this 2 year sentence may not be concurrent to any other sentence for any other crime but multiple counts of the same crime can be served simultaneously. (Note that 1028A is an "enhancement" charge, similar to the gun enhancements I mentioned earlier. They are add-ons to other crimes, and cannot be charged separately. Basically, enhancement charges are used when additional circumstances covered by the enhancement make the underlying crime "worse" than a normal instance of that crime.) 1028 imposes a maximum sentence of 15 years for the gravest crime listed in the statute. Assuming he is found (or pleads guilty) this yields a likely maximum sentence of 17 years, or a potential maximum sentence of no more than 33 years.
- ageisp0lis 13y agoFair enough. Thanks for doing that calculation.
- watwut 13y agoIf you throw around possibility of ridiculously high sentences to scare people and manipulate them into guilty pleas, then you have no right to complain when people act like being threatened with unfairly high sentence.
- Zak 13y agoA p.o. address, for example, may tell you how to get to someone's apartment but it wouldn't tell you how to get up there if the front door is locked. A URL may tell you how to get to someone's file, but it wouldn't tell you how to download it if the server required authentication. A URL might be more comparable to driving directions than a mere address, but it does not grant access to a resource with even the most rudimentary access control.
- ageisp0lis 13y agoSadly, the headline is unfortunate because "Barrett Brown faces 100 years for link" was not supposed to be the story here. The story is that his legal team filed a motion arguing that hyperlinks are protected speech under the First Amendment, etc. lol
- emiliobumachar 13y ago"the most heinous crimes, i.e., rapes, murders, or high-level drug offenses" As a side note, it's amazing how the war on drugs advanced in the propaganda front. Selling drugs in bulk is not only a serious crime, it's high up there with rape and murder.
- roel_v 13y agoLook, I understand that you are referring to that guy in apartment 4c who brings some pot for his buddies from Colorado to finance his daily bong. That is quite different from, say, a Pablo Escobar who sells in tonnes leading an organisation the size of a large multinational, including a private army. I'm as pro-legalisation as they come, but any reasonable person would have to admit that the damages caused by the actions of the leaders of big drug cartels are, in the aggregate, causing at least as much suffering as, let's say, a single rape. I know I'm threading on thin ice here because this might make it seem like I'm trivializing rape, which I'm decidedly not, but regardless of what side of the debate one is one, it's wholly unreasonable to assert that drug dealers do not cause any suffering and that they are in no way responsible for that suffering (i.e. the 'users make their own choices' and 'if I didn't sell it, somebody else would have' arguments).
- emiliobumachar 13y agoYou are conflating the (very real) damages caused by drug consumption with the much larger damages caused by other crimes in the illegal drug trade. Drug cartels do a lot of murder. Drug laws would lock up for good the guy in apartment 4c as well, and large segments of society do not see him as "quite different" than the cartels.
- roel_v 13y agoNo, I'm not conflating anything, I was referring to the suffering of addicts and their families from addiction itself, apart from the second-order crime from cartels and addicts who need to commit petty crime to fund their habit. Now one might argue that that suffering is caused largely by the mere fact of the drugs being illegal, and in fact I made that argument myself usually. That doesn't change the existence of that suffering though, even if it's relatively small compared to the total. And all of that is separate still from the murders drug cartels commit as part of their business operations, I realize that. Apart from all that, there are still harmful effects from their acts. (hence my wording 'in no way responsible' - they are not fully responsible, but are at least contributing, and their contributions to many cases make for a lot of aggregate negative effects).
- guelo 13y agoNo, you're spreading FUD. This is not the system working as intended. If he got 1 day in jail for linking it should be an outrage to every American.
- r0h1n 13y ago> a URL isn't simply an address; it is a path, and this makes all the difference. I'm not sure how you came to the conclusion that a URL is a path. A path implies a route from A to B. When I share a URL with you, I imply no path. > A p.o. address, for example, may tell you how to get to someone's apartment but it wouldn't tell you how to get up there if the front door is locked. You began your comment with the words FUD, so I'd like to add two of my own - Red Herring! If you must use analogies, the physical equivalent of a URL is an address, not a P.O. box. But I suspect you still chose the P.O. box analogy because it allows you to create the false construct of a locked front door. The availability of digital resources at a public URL is equivalent to the availability of physical resources at an address. The "locked front door" is irrelevant in both these (limiting) examples.
- Joeri 13y agoI think a url is both an address and a path. The domain is clearly the address of the server (residence), where the 'path' applies to. You can even construct a path in many cases that includes a password to grant entry to an otherwise protected resource, which is no different from giving someone a key to get in the door. I don't like that interpretation, because i feel it's important that linking remains legal in most crcumstances, if not all, but that doesn't change the fact that if you reason by analogy to the physical world most url's are indeed paths. And this is where the danger is: reasoning by analogy. It doesn't produce good results to reason about dgital resources by analogy to physical resources.
- r0h1n 13y agoAt the risk of prolonging an unnecessary digression (the analogy was brought up by the parent), I still don't believe a public URL in itself contains a path. In fact it's quite possible that some URLs may never lead to a valid path depending on the starting address. Paths are only inferred or drawn up during traversal. I wouldn't mind being proven wrong though, preferably with an example.
- gamblor956 13y ago